Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
@Calvin Thomas, wow! You seem to have gone to extraordinary lengths to build up a great Credit score, and, you know all the potential downsides if/when things end up going south. BUT, as far as I can see, you would have been just as well off all the way along by instead, taking out standard Mortgage/Loans for your property investments. You would have been able to pay them back within similar time frames as your Credit Card / Margin Account combinations; and probably at similar overall interest! Right?
How would paying back your mortgages on time, every time, hurt your Credit?
I do not think it would. The margin interest was between 0.75% - 1.49%. It would be hard to get that type of loan through any means other than margin. I tend not to pay interest if I do not have too. While my accounts are not very big for New York City standards, if I moved them to another bank for a better rate, the current bank would notice. Thus, it's best to work with me on my rates and fees. Even when the say it is not negotiable, it is. Everything is negotiable. Everything.. Worse case scenario for me is I go to another bank that would meet my needs in fees and rates. Usual scenario, we meet in the middle, and I am happy with that. My dad always told me, it not what you sell things for, it's what you buy things at. It rains true here as well. If you can lower your overall handling costs for OPM (banks), then you realize more money. Immediately. Why pay 5k in mortgage closing costs, where there are ZERO closing costs with a line of credit or a margin loan? Margin is risky, no doubt about that, however, you have three days to bring the funds into the account. In addition, if you had a 1mm in stocks/funds/bonds/etc., and only use 20% - 35%, you can safely say you would be insulated from a margin call. If you used that 250k - 350k to buy two or three (or more homes) outright with no mortgage, you are already ahead of the game. You saved 10k + in mortgage closing and appraisal fees for said homes. It's all about mathematics. The numbers work or they don't. I'd rather have that 5k, or 10k in my bank account or working on a rehab, or investing in a muni instead of giving it to appraisers, brokers, bankers, etc.
However, one could say, the leverage could help you in really really good times, but hurt you in really really bad times. Murphy's law comes out to bite people in the butt at strange times in their lives. In good times, things are sailing through and you are added new properties and renters. In bad times, you have unrented homes, or late payers, or issues with the mortgage, or an adjustable rate, etc. If one is able to not have a mortgage on these properties, or just a few, they could be much better off in bad times. I am not sure if you recall, but for about 1.5 years, most banks dried up lending to only the best of the best companies. If a person is leveraged to the hilt, and they hit some bad luck, they will be in for some real painful lessons in finance 101. In addition, their portfolio, just like in the market, could be wiped out. I know this goes against the BP philosophy, however, as a person who experienced with with friends, family and foes, I can tell you; it is not a pretty sight to see. Well, maybe for the foes, but not the others. Not saying to not take a mortgage, I am just saying, if possible, not go balls to the wall and mortgage every property to the hilt.
I know, most of the ppl reading this thread must think I am crazy. No, just risk tolerant. Only experience in seeing others get wiped out because of being over leveraged teaches a thing or two about financial responsibility. No, I wasn't playing Monday morning quarterback. I was saying for years, the punch bowl can and will be taken away sooner or later. It's best to prepare. No one listed to me and said I am too conservative and have to live life. These are the people that purchased more and more real estate and refinanced their props. when they kept on receiving sky high appraisals. They basically used their homes as ATMs. Well, those homes are no longer with their original owners. Just remember, hindsight is 20/20. Expect the best, but prepare for the worst. As history has told all of us, there is little warning before the perfect storm hits and wipes a few of us out.