Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Don Fisco

Don Fisco has started 1 posts and replied 3 times.

Quote from @Jon Schwartz:

@Don Fisco, this is a complicated endeavor, but most of my clients have complicated aims, and I love a challenge.

Firstly, you want to talk to a real-estate lawyer about the in's and out's of a tenancy-in-common deed. (I think I can get a solid referral for you.) A tenancy-in-common (TIC) is when multiple parties collectively own a piece of property and have assigned use of different units within the property. TICs are becoming more common in LA these days; they're like condos, but the structure is different.

I'm not a TIC expert, but from what I understand, adjusting the ratio of ownership is difficult. I believe the different parties can start at difference percentages of ownership, but to change those percentages, you'd need to create superseding deeds... which is doable... but this is where you need to speak to a TIC-experienced lawyer about what's possible and what the costs will be.

Forming an LLC would make adjusting ownership percentages easier, but I doubt you'd be able to get a loan. When you buy a property as tenants-in-common, everybody in the group is essentially combined to qualify for the mortgage. Between the four of you, you make about $510,000/yr, which will qualify you for a sizable loan. If you form an LLC, you'll have a new company with $0 of income. Good luck getting a bank to lend $1M to an LLC with $0 of income!

So, there's a structure through which you can do this (a TIC deed), and you definitely need to consult with a real-estate attorney who has TIC experience to understand how to go about doing this.

Now let's talk about what's possible with the numbers you've shared...

You presently have $640-840K for a down payment and a combined income of $510K. With that income, you should be able to borrow upwards of $2M. Add the down payment, and you're looking at a healthy budget.

Two problems:

You'll need to buy a fourplex or smaller. Once you get to five units, the loan structure changes (it becomes a commercial loan), and you won't be able to qualify with your collective income.

A fourplex means no rental income because your group needs four units, right? There is a workaround: ADUs! Multifamily properties are allowed two detached ADUs and a third ADU, if possible, inside the existing structures. So, without getting into the weeds, you could buy a fourplex, then build 2-3 ADUs for rental income. You have quite a bit of capital for the down payment, and I'd suggest allocated a chunk of it to ADU construction.

The second problem is finding a vacant building. It will be very hard to find a vacant fourplex in LA. If you buy a building with tenants, there are ways to remove them. Namely, I'm thinking of utilizing to Ellis Act to remove the tenants. The only catch is that you can't put any of the four units back on the rental market for a period of five years. If everybody's comfortable staying put for the next five years, you're good.

This remind me of another factor you'll have to keep in mind: Ellis Act evictions require 120 days' notice. That's four months. And you'll probably need to do some renovating to any fourplex you buy; that's another chunk of time.

So, in conclusion, this plan is doable. I believe the legal structure, financing, properties, and path to living in the building all exist. However, it will be difficult! It will be challenging to find a suitable property, then very challenging to go from opening escrow to, months and month later, moving in. You up for it?

Best,

Jon

Jon,

Thank you so much for you fantastic reply, it was very informative. Some questions for you!

TIC sounds like a great idea and something I will definitely speak to a real-estate lawyer about.

When it comes to a commercial loan, what are the major differences preventing us from being able to qualify? Is it exclusively our collective income being in the 500k range preventing us, or is it more complicated like lacking a license or certificate? Or having an established corporation? Could you explain more in detail the ins and outs of this, or point me to something I could read in-depth?

Something I recently spoke to my wife about is the chance that her parents (who are also semi-retired) might be interested in contributing in some way to this endeavor if it made some financial sense. They own two rental properties in Sonoma County so they have some experience in real estate and if my wife and I were able to present an idea that made sense, they could be open to providing more capital for larger properties with more units, on the presumption that they would be able to gather profits from the extra units. 

I know this probably makes this more difficult in ways, but could it not provide more housing stock in Los Angeles? Would this extra boost of capital help us qualify for commercial loans?

Alternatively, if there's no possible way that that idea could EVER work for X number of reasons when it comes to the fourplex suggestion, does that preclude properties that are fourplexes that already have ADUs built on them? Would the fourplex need to be bought AS a fourplex and we would have to build the ADU ourselves?
Quote from @Theresa Harris:

I'd start by talking to your dad.  Just as you don't want to move as your friends are there, he may not want to move for the same reasons.

If there are 5 of you going in on this (well 4 if you and your wife are combining your money for 25% of the costs), you need to talk to a lawyer about the 'what ifs'.  

What if one person wants to sell, if one person gets married, when repairs are needed or someone wants to do renos (for cosmetic reasons).  How are those decisions going to be made?  It can be hard enough when there are 2 people involved (ie husband and wife), but 4 or 5 people...  

If you are all putting in different amounts of money, how does that relate to decisions on the property-does everyone (ie all 4 as you and your wife may be 1 vote) have an equal say regardless if they put in $25K or $400K?  When you sell, how is the money divided up?  Everyone gets their initial investment back and the rest is divided how? 

I've spoken to my Dad about the move and while he's frightened by the prospect of moving, he's more afraid of living out his days on the East Coast alone. Which is why I mentioned the possibility that the most likely scenario would be downsizing from the single-family home he has now to a smaller condo still in NJ which he would be able to split his time between NJ and Los Angeles. He was decidedly more excited about that idea.

In terms of money, my initial thoughts were that the equity in the property would change over time as individuals contributed more throughout months/years until an agreed amount of parity was reached based on whatever the property called for: i.e. everyone owning a 2bed/2bath had contributed the same amount of capital, that sort of thing. So the friend contributing the least upfront would own the least stake at first and would gradually buy more into it as they paid the most monthly to build up equity into the project. We would also have to have a pool of money for shared expenses for the property for renovations, cosmetic, upkeep. 

We would definitely consult a lawyer. What type of lawyer would be best for this? A real estate lawyer obviously but is there a more specific term/type to be looking for?

I'd imagine all of these questions (like what would happen in an instance when one individual would like to sell) would be spelled out in some sort of operating agreement before purchasing any property.

Would we form an LLC? A different type of partnership? I don't know what options to look into but if you point me in the right direction to research I will. I'm not afraid of reading a couple of hefty books to get my feet wet on the subject. 

Just made an account here to try and organize my thoughts as I don't know where to begin. I'm sure I will not provide the proper information for you all to give me the right advice but this is what I've got:

I'm a somewhat recently married 36-year-old dude. My wife and I have been living in Los Angeles for over a decade. Working professionals in the film & TV industry. Since Covid, I work from home. Recently we've started talking about having a kid, probably sometime in the next year. Our current apartment is too small for that. We don't want to move out of Los Angeles as our friends and (more importantly) our careers are here. 

We want to own property.

My father is retiring after working in the post office for forty years and is a widower. He's back in New Jersey where I grew up, but he's all on his own and I want to bring him out to Los Angeles so he's not lonely in his retirement years. 

For the past five years, my wife and I have lived in an apartment together, and before that, I lived with two guys in another apartment nearby. The four of us are all close friends and we hang out regularly and have a good rapport. 

As we all know, the housing market in Los Angeles is incredibly rough. My wife and I won't be able to afford a house on our own, much less one that will have an ADU for my dad, as he would most likely want some amount of privacy and freedom and not just a room in our house. Having done the barest of research, we've looked into the idea of pooling our money to try and buy a multifamily for my wife and I, my dad, and the two friends, as the two friends also want to stop renting and to start owning, even if it is part of a multifamily/apartment building. A place that has enough units that we could have renters beyond ourselves that would help offset the mortgage payments we would be paying.

The breakdown of what we know we have saved up that can be used for a downpayment:

My wife and I: $165,000~, can probably get that to $200,000 within a year. Our combined income is, on average, around $230,000 a year. My credit is above 800. My wife's is in the high 700s. 

My Dad: $50,000-250,000 (the range is dependent on if he were to sell the NJ house and divest himself of the East Coast completely, or sell the NJ house and buy a NJ condo and use the difference to help contribute to a unit out here in LA. Just depends on how attached he is emotionally to NJ. The NJ house is probably not going to sell for a lot either way. As a postal employee, he has a guaranteed pension, but not a lot of savings -- I know, complications, complications). His pension plus survivor benefits will net him around $80,000 a year but I'd like to not have to rely on him spending too much in his retirement for this beyond the downpayment if possible. His credit is in the high 700s. 

Friend 1: $25,000, within a year he expects to have $60,000, which he will keep upping to get him to $100,000. This is a big thorn in our side for the plan. He generally makes around $100,000 a year. I don't know his credit.

Friend 2: $400,000. He inherited and is willing to use it all on this endeavor. He also makes around $100,000 a year. I don't know his credit.

NOW

With all of that said, where do I go from here? I'm itching to learn as much as I can. I want to find a way to make this work. Tell me how I can make it happen, tell me how I'm an idiot and it's impossible. Tell me the books, the courses, the websites, the certifications-- whatever you think I need to know to not be as ignorant as I am now.