Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Jason Malabute

Jason Malabute has started 545 posts and replied 1455 times.

Post: PRACTICING ANALYZING PROPERTY

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690
Originally posted by @John Jacobus:

@Jason Malabute I recommend that you find a few of Brandon Turner's recorded webinars in the BP archives covering the topic of deal analysis.  With a Pro membership, you have access to the archive of all webinars.  Watching a few of these webinars should help you with questions 2 & 3 above.

Regarding your first question, I recommend that you use LoopNet (www.loopnet.com) to find a few properties that interest you. While you won't find many good deals, and they won't always have all of the important details available, you can use the inputs in the marketing package to practice going through the motions. Once you get comfortable with the process and you find a deal worth pursuing, reach out to the listing broker and request the trailing twelve month financials ("T12") and current rent roll to get a better sense of the financial prospects of the property.

I also recommend a few books on this topic that should help you get comfortable with analyzing deals:

  • The ABC's of Real Estate Investing by Ken McElroy (Chapter 7)
  • The Ultimate Guide to Buying Apartment Buildings with Private Money by Michael Blank
  • 13 Steps to Valuing Your First Multiplex by Ben Leybovich

 Thank you John. This is very helpful.

I have read  The ABC's of Real Estate Investing by Ken McElroy and he does advise that you request the current rent rolls and 12 months financials.

I will check out the webinars and 2 other books.

Thank you. 

Post: PRACTICING ANALYZING PROPERTY

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690

Hi All,

I JUST UPGRADED TO PRO!!!!

I am a first time investor. I want to practice and analyze rental properties using the BP calculator. My goal is I want to master (or at least practice) analyzing duplexes so many times using the BP rental property calculator that by the time my agent starts giving me leads I'll be comfortable analyzing properties quickly and accurately.

GOALS: 

Analyze 3 sample properties a week.

QUESTIONS:

1. Where can I get sample property numbers (besides purchase price) to practice with?

 2. What figures (income and expenses) must I include in all my analysis??

3. Since I am a first time investor how do I assure myself that I am analyzing my CF and other projections correctly and accurately?

Thanks.

Post: HOLLYWOOD CA MARKET ANALYSIS FOR DUPLEX

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690

One of the markets to buy my first duplex in was/am (kinda) considering is Hollywood CA (NOT WEST, NORTH, OR EAST). I'm talking about somewhere near the clubs, bars, hotels, and businesses. Prior to my market study I thought Hollywood would be a great idea because I am always going out and see a lot of young professionals and those in the entertainment industry in the scene. Hollywood has a real diverse crowd.  Also, Hollywood has one of the highest rents in the nation ($3110.30). However, when I was doing my research I found that the average income in Hollywood is $40,000 (annually), most residents dont have a HS degree, robberies are higher than national average, spending are lower than national average, etc. Obviously there are many pros of the Hollywood market as well.

However, for argument sake please see questions below:

1. Are my study of the market accurate? How is the rent in Hollywood so high if the average income is so low?

2. Does anybody here own a property in Hollywood and making a positive cashflow (>$200)?

3. Is Hollywood a good market for rentals (duplex) in your experience (not opinion)?

4. Any last advise about the Hollywood market?

Thank you,

Jason

Post: FIRST PURCHASE DILEMA

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690
Originally posted by @Sam M.:

@Jason Malabute, @Ariou B., got it exactly right in his example. 

With regard to your question about how a lender can actually factor this figure in without first having the units rented out, the appraiser completes what's called a Rental Survey, which is his/her valuation for how much the units could rent for. The lender will follow the Rental Survey and use 75% of that total figure as qualifying income. Hope that helps. 

 Thank you this help a lot

Post: FIRST PURCHASE DILEMA

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690
Originally posted by @Sam Shueh:

Get another trusted person to go together. No other way around..... 

 found  1(potentially 2) Thank you.

Post: FIRST PURCHASE DILEMA

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690
Originally posted by @Sam M.:

Also, you can use rental income from the other unit towards qualifying. When an appraiser is out there to do his/her valuation, your lender should also request a rental survey with the appraiser's report. You can use 75% of the monthly rental towards your income

 Hey Sam,

I am trying to get pre-approved right now, This is interesting that you say that the pre-approval should be based on my gross salary and not my net. I will clarify this with him.

Can you please explain more when you say that I can "use 75% of my monthly rental income towards my income"? Do you mean I can add 75% of the monthly rental income to my gross salary in order to increase the chance of getting pre-approved? If yes, how would you do so if you do not have an actual rental property yet?

Thank you,  

Post: FIRST PURCHASE DILEMA

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690
Originally posted by @Derrick Dill:

Your issue is DTI (Debt to income): The lenders see that you have $$, but don't see that you're able to pay off the mortgage monthly.

There's a couple other factors that will come into play:

Do you have other debts? Student loans? Car? If yes, it will be harder to get the loan.

You can alleviate the DTI by getting a Multifamily, with rental income that will off-set the monthly payments. Ex. You buy a 4-plex, each unit rents for 1500$/month, you have a mortgage of ~5,000$/month. 3 units renting for 1500$=4500$/month that is offset, leaving 500$/month for your mortgage. You'll get nicer #s if rent is higher as well. Usually they only calculate 75% of projected rental incomes.

Your other options: Co-signor

Keep searching for another broker/lender (you'll probably get worse rates)

I would consider a lower purchase price multifamily if possible

Regards,

 thank you

Post: FIRST PURCHASE DILEMA

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690
Originally posted by @Shaun Pruett:

Is the $800K property single family or multifamily? 

 I am looking for a multifamily

Post: FIRST PURCHASE DILEMA

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690

I have kind of a unique problem as I am trying to purchase my first rental property.

I am 28 and looking to purchase my first property. I am interested in getting an owner occupied duplex. My research so far has made me interested in areas like Culver City and Hollywood because of the high rent and demand of the market. My situation is unique because I am the opposite of most investors. I can put a big down payment ($200k) and good credit. However, my agent told me that I will have a hard time getting approved for the loan because my salary is too low (net pay is $2000 a month lets say). My agent told me since I am looking for a property that is $800k in value I would have to make $8000 monthly net salary to get approved for the loan. Even for a $600k loan I'd have to have a $6000 monthly net salary to get approved.

The thing is I want to make my investment this quarter while interest rates are low, and AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE I'D LIKE TO AVOID CONSIGNORS.

1. Is there any way around this?

2. Have any of you ever been in my shoes and succeeded? How?

3. If I would like to look for duplexes in the $400-500k price range in Los Angeles (has to be in a good market) where would ya'll suggest?

Thanks!

Post: PRACTICE

Jason MalabutePosted
  • Accountant
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 1,477
  • Votes 690

Hi All,

I would like to get on a real estate broker's mailing list so they send me proformas so I can practice calculating an offer price and analysis of properties. Can you guys please suggest a mailing list?

Thanks.