@Dave Van Horn
I suppose every state will have a different take on this.. I can't say I am 100% certain but I am 98% certain this would not fly in Oregon or to an Oregon resident. Been there done that with the state regulators any form of buy back guarantee etc would require some sort of securities offering. In Oregon its called a Real Estate Paper offering.. And its a Minnie reg D filing. Not that what your marketing cant be done but the state of Oregon wants full disclosure to their citizens.
So the question becomes. And if I may take the liberty to play devils advocate here.
And I really don't know anything about your business other than I think your selling non performing second trust deeds or mortgages and by your post your offering to service them or replace them if they go bad. I suspect you buy them in bulk for pennies on the dollar then re assign them and make a profit selling them ( does not take a rocket scientist to figure that one out).
So from an investors stand point. And we already know this is high risk defaulted paper in second position.. So the most risky notes you can buy ( except for 3rds)
So we know these are going to default and probably default at a pretty high rate I would suspect 50% or better ( do you provide this information to your buyers IE how many have defaulted).
So I am a buyer of a 2nd it craters and now your going to step in your not going to give me my money back just replace the note.. What if I don't like the note your replacing me with.. How do you handle that.. Does the investor just have to take one that match's monetarily or do you send them 10 and tell them to take their pick.
What happens if there is a run on the bank.. How many of these do you have in reserve to use as substitute collateral. And or do you have any data on how successful your buyers are over time getting these things up and running and keeping them running. How do these investors handle the senior liens if the second is non performing the first usually is these people usually pay the second and not the first because its a smaller payment and no one said the US borrower is that versed in RE and credit.
Back in the day in California we sold notes all the time with an endorsement on the back "with recourse" this meant if it went bad we had to cash them out. and take over the position..
Just seems like warranting a second that is NPN is just highly risky from your perspective.. And what happens if a note default 7 years from now and your no longer in bizz your retired what is an investor going to do then.. Or is there a sunset IE if the note holder pays 24 months the warranty is over. that would make sense.
Anyway look forward to hearing how you handle this.
Last comment if you are selling these notes for 1k to 5k then forget everything I just said other than the legalities of a warranty. too little of money to worry about if they go TU