Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Katherine Earle

Katherine Earle has started 15 posts and replied 80 times.

Post: Cash-on-Cash Return Calculation

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @John DeRosa:

Thank you everyone for your input.  This has been very helpful.

John

Hey there John,

Now, I’m going to be the voice of unreason. I’m not going to encourage buying a “bad” deal, but before you get hung up too much on numbers, consider your first deal as your training wheels. Buy something you can afford, something that will hopefully cash flow, and call it education. The other route is to hook up with a partner who has experience and use them to lean on. If you don’t have that, get your teeth cut on a base hit. The experience from the first deal will be worth way more than the monitory return you get!

Post: Single Family or Multi-Family?

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @Nick Robinson:

@Katherine Earle
My personal opinion is to keep scaling up to bigger MF properties. The further you get away from 4units the easier it is to qualify b/c they are basing it off the property's financials and not your own. In addition, you start to get the economies of scale. Obviously either works but having extra doors helps keep CF more consistent over the year. It keeps all your units in a similar area, so it is easier to manage and cheaper from a PM point of view. When I bought my 14-unit it cost me $135k/door and I put about $30k/door in reno so all in for $165k and the single-family homes next to the building were high $300k-low $400k. I was able to buy a lot more doors and the rental rate between them was not as dramatic as the price.

Actually, I was arguing that exact fact to my partner just yesterday. It’s much cheaper here than in CA. So, we typically see $100k/door, but Im getting a duplex right now for $170k. When I bump up to market rates it will be bringing in $1800/mo with a 30-year fixed. The hoops we are having to jump through to secure the financing is ridiculous though! My poor partner has his own business and house-hacks with a house his parents own, but are passing it down to him. The money he got was from an inheritance and it has been a bear to get past underwriting. I’m struggling to find resources on how to secure financing when I’m a new investor, in order to do a cash-out refinance at a later date though. He is fine acting as the private lender in the interim. Just considering if we should just buy another 5-unit with his remaining cash or get a few single family fixer-uppers. I like leaning towards the 5 unit idea though, since none of us have your typical 9-5 jobs for easy residential financing.

Post: Single Family or Multi-Family?

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @John Teachout:

Will these multi-families be your first properties?

Yes, these will be our first properties. 2 are scheduled to close next week, with another under contract, totally 15 units all together. 

Post: Single Family or Multi-Family?

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @John Teachout:

My personal opinion is that anybody starting in real estate should begin with a lower price single family fix up home. There's a learning process involved with real estate investing and there's a lot more exit options with an SFR. If you decide multi family is where you want to wind up, then it can always be sold, or kept, or whatever... It's just a lot safer investment from a potential loss standpoint. (due to financial or management failures)

Ok, 3 year update on question….

I found a wealthy partner and money is now much less of a concern. I’m a realtor now as well. So, I will get commissions and management fees while my partner will get interest before we split the cash flow. Cash reserves are no longer a concern if something were to happen. Would you still keep the safe single family BRRRR strategy or go straight to multifamily? I am closing on 3 multi families over the next few weeks and possibly adding a single family fixer upper after we close on those, but interested in other takes on long term strategies (no interest in short or medium term rentals at this point).

Post: Getting Estoppel Certificates Signed

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @Nathan Grabau:

I would work through the listing agent, and go from there. Do you have the capacity to back out of the deal if they refuse still? In the CO residential income contract we have specific things we request from the sellers in the contract and a deadline to produce them. This just kind of comes down to what you can get the listing agent to do by asking nicely, and if they refuse, what you can get them to do based on their contractual obligations. 

Our residential purchase agreement really leaves it up to the client to request what they want and the seller isn’t coming up with any leases or bank statements that I asked for and so far, the listing agent isn’t being helpful at all. He didn’t get the seller to inform the tenants we were doing an inspection and now I can’t even get clarification about what the tenant’s addresses are, a request coming straight from the lender (it’s a converted single family). This may be one I just have to walk away from, unless the listing agent can get his act together. 

Post: Getting Estoppel Certificates Signed

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29

I have a great 4-unit under contract with 3 units currently rented and I have asked for a copy of all of the leases and 12 months of bank statements. Instead, the 80 year old woman looking to retire has been living off of the income and could only provide her paper rent receipts and hand written income statement. I didn’t require an estoppel certificate in the PA. Do I give 4 blank ones to the listing agent and tell the seller to have the tenants sign it or the listing agent or go to the tenants myself? How do I encourage them to sign them and get it back to me? Since this is residential, I don’t get the impression that this is a normal request.

Post: Where to find investors

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @Deviare Harris:
Quote from @Katherine Earle:
Quote from @Zackary C Dunn:

If I’m understanding your question correctly, you are trying to figure out how to find other investors to partner with or to lend to you to accomplish your deals.

If that’s the case I have no clue if the chicken came before the egg…. But I know for a fact the deal came before the money. If you find a great deal and can show the numbers make sense you will find the money. 

Relationships require a value exchange. So if you’re looking for the capital you either need to be the deal finder or the laborer. Since your a RN I’m guessing you don’t have a lot of free time which leaves you with having to find a deal along with proving to the investor that you have a good enough relationship with a contractor that the job will actually get done.

If I miss understood the question sorry for the long response. If you find a deal and still can’t find the money let me know and I’ll work directly with you to find it.

I’m also unsure of what you are looking for. I love that you are a nurse and trying to break into real estate! Being in healthcare for 20 years myself, my most recent position in the er of a level 1 trauma center, I know exactly what you are going through everyday. So, kudos to you for taking initiative towards financial freedom (so many burnt out nurses who stay in it because they can’t afford to leave. Very sad)!!!! My question is what are you looking for and what are you bringing to the table? If you lack money, what are you doing on your days off? Are you looking for deals or learning how to manage a rental property? Are you going to meetups and signing up for local associations? If you have the money, why not start small and buy a duplex or a sfh and rent out rooms? If you are doing 3 12s, managing a duplex is very do-able. I have been studying on my days off while working towards buying my first 3-4 unit, got my RE license to get more knowledgeable about the process and for networking. Now, I’m about to close my first deal in 2 weeks with a very nice commission check! It was with a friend who knew I was doing this real estate stuff and wanted to do it too. We will be doing many more deals together because he has money and I have the knowledge and the license. Eventually we both will have money and will partner on bigger deals together. Good luck!!
Hello Katherine,

It's amazing hearing your story and seeing someone in my shoes do what I'm trying to do. I currently work 4-5 12's ( 2 extra to save up) a week. And on my way to work and on my days of I consume as much knowledge as possible. Currently reading the BRRRR book, and I look for deals. I trying to be more active in all the groups. So I have the drive and ability to find the deals but I don't have the money part. I'm thinking of using hard money so I specifically need the 20% or skin in the game as I don't have the cash to purchase a deal all cash. 

It's really cool again to hear your story and see light at the end of the tunnel because everyone keeps telling me I can't do it but I know it's possible. 
Yup, 4-5 12s here too to build up my down payment and reserves for a 3-4 unit! If you are willing to do a live-in flip, you might want to consider a 203k fha deal or look into down payment assistance programs for single family homes. There are special loans for nurses as well. My path was going to be through multi families, but it wasn’t easy to save up the down payment. Was it luck that my friend from California came across money and wanted to use me to invest it? Well, ask Brandon Turner how he came across his 24 unit. He kept doing the right steps and talking to people, telling everybody want he was looking for. Then the deal came to him! Basically, I’ve been planting seeds for the last few years. Have I been frustrated that it wasn’t fast enough? Hell, yes! But trust the process and it will happen when it’s suppose to! In the meantime, keep up the amazing work saving those lives everyday, like I know you are! Someone “up there” is watching…..🤗

Post: New Partner Question

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @Drew Sygit:

@Katherine Earle most important step is to have a solid partnership agreement that details each of your responsibilities and covers what happens if one of you dies or wants out.

You should charge for your normal services. Important to create a papertrail to avoid future disputes.

You can then agree or choose to reinvest those fees back into the partnership.


 I appreciate the feedback. That’s actually what we are doing. I’m working with the attorney to spell out the details today!

Post: Where to find investors

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @Zackary C Dunn:

If I’m understanding your question correctly, you are trying to figure out how to find other investors to partner with or to lend to you to accomplish your deals.

If that’s the case I have no clue if the chicken came before the egg…. But I know for a fact the deal came before the money. If you find a great deal and can show the numbers make sense you will find the money. 

Relationships require a value exchange. So if you’re looking for the capital you either need to be the deal finder or the laborer. Since your a RN I’m guessing you don’t have a lot of free time which leaves you with having to find a deal along with proving to the investor that you have a good enough relationship with a contractor that the job will actually get done.

If I miss understood the question sorry for the long response. If you find a deal and still can’t find the money let me know and I’ll work directly with you to find it.

I’m also unsure of what you are looking for. I love that you are a nurse and trying to break into real estate! Being in healthcare for 20 years myself, my most recent position in the er of a level 1 trauma center, I know exactly what you are going through everyday. So, kudos to you for taking initiative towards financial freedom (so many burnt out nurses who stay in it because they can’t afford to leave. Very sad)!!!! My question is what are you looking for and what are you bringing to the table? If you lack money, what are you doing on your days off? Are you looking for deals or learning how to manage a rental property? Are you going to meetups and signing up for local associations? If you have the money, why not start small and buy a duplex or a sfh and rent out rooms? If you are doing 3 12s, managing a duplex is very do-able. I have been studying on my days off while working towards buying my first 3-4 unit, got my RE license to get more knowledgeable about the process and for networking. Now, I’m about to close my first deal in 2 weeks with a very nice commission check! It was with a friend who knew I was doing this real estate stuff and wanted to do it too. We will be doing many more deals together because he has money and I have the knowledge and the license. Eventually we both will have money and will partner on bigger deals together. Good luck!!

Post: New Partner Question

Katherine EarlePosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Hart, MI
  • Posts 89
  • Votes 29
Quote from @Ari Stern:

@Katherine Earle, at first glance, I would ask yourself what you bring to the partnership. If your contribution is the management and leasing, then adding those fees as an expense, and then also receiving your share of the investment, seems like double-dipping. 

On the other hand, since you've already suggest to this investor that he purchase the property alone, and he hire you to do the management and leasing, and he wasn't interested in that arrangement, then clearly you bring more to the table than just those two functions.  

That being the case, since these expenses are legitimate expenses that the property would have incurred, whether you performed them or someone else, I don't see why you shouldn't be able to charge for them. 

With that in mind, I will second @Kevin Sobilo and say that however you decide to go about this arrangement, these details should be discussed and formalized beforehand.

One other thing you may want to keep in mind, is that you should look at your long-term relationship with this investor/partner. If you think there is a potential of him being there long-term, investing with you in future properties for years to come, then it might be wise to compromise slightly to ensure he's still making something when all is said and done.  Every investor expects a return on their money. And if you do end up charging for these services, and he ends up not making much after that, he may not be enticed enough to follow you to your next deal.

Lastly, from a financing perspective, since a management fee is a basic expense that every property has, even if you decide not to charge for these services, lenders will still include them in their underwriting when determining the NOI and value for the property. Depending on the size of the property, it's usually between 3-5%.


 Thank you both for your input and yes, there is more to the backstory along with a 10-year friendship than just financial gain. I have talked to him in more detail about some financial goals that I can go to the cpa and attorney with now, where it will feel a little more balanced and less where I am taking advantage of a grieving widower. This is intended to be a longer-term partnership where we grow the portfolio to a size that will make a real impact on much bigger goals, in the name of his dead fiance, who passed away unexpectedly several months ago. It helps me get a clear idea of how I might form a partnership in the future though. So, thank you!