All Forum Posts by: Matthew McMenamin
Matthew McMenamin has started 12 posts and replied 35 times.
Post: Turning 2 Bd units into 1 Bd units Multifamily Value Add

- Investor
- Indianapolis & San Diego
- Posts 38
- Votes 15
I'm hoping somebody can weigh in on my idea to turn 2bd units into 1 bd units.
I'm looking at an 82 unit apartment complex. 22 1-beds, 44 2-beds, and 16 2-beds with W/D hookups. 1 bedroom units rent significantly higher per sq ft than 2 bedroom units. I'm thinking about taking 15 2-bed units with W/D hookups and turning them into 20 1-bed units. (three 2-bed units turns into four 1-bed units). Since all units are currently 1 bathroom, I would repurpose the W/D lines for plumbing.
I would capture a roughly $25,000 bump in rent, equating to a $350,000 increase in value based on a 7% cap.
1. I'm not sure this can even be done. Adding an additional kitchen sink, bathroom sink, toilet, and shower might be too much for the existing plumbing infrastructure.
2. I am also unsure what the development spread would be. For an increase in value of $350,000, I would probably end up spending $350,000 (or more). Even if its relatively affordable, this seems like a large undertaking for not a huge gain.
I'm curious if anyone has ever done this. Trying to think outside the box and find ways to add value.
Post: Los Angeles vs. Orange County vs. Henderson??

- Investor
- Indianapolis & San Diego
- Posts 38
- Votes 15
I second San Diego! $4MM goes a long way, even in the high-end communities like La Jolla, Del Mar, etc.
Post: Carmel Indiana Property Management

- Investor
- Indianapolis & San Diego
- Posts 38
- Votes 15
Thanks Paul!
Post: Carmel Indiana Property Management

- Investor
- Indianapolis & San Diego
- Posts 38
- Votes 15
Does anyone have any recommendations for property managers in Carmel Indiana? I need someone experienced to help me find good rental comps for a multifamily investment so I can accurately underwrite the deal. As well as oversee a value add process after purchasing the property. Then manage the property going forward.
Post: San Diego Rental Comps (La Jolla)

- Investor
- Indianapolis & San Diego
- Posts 38
- Votes 15
I'm looking for comps for the Birdrock/La Jolla area. If anybody has the inside scoop please let me know! I need to do some basic cashflow modeling for a potential multifamily development.