Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Rich Hupper

Rich Hupper has started 228 posts and replied 1234 times.

Post: commercial lender question

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348

Its a local bank in boston not too large. Okay so any perm loan lender would require a 21e?

Post: commercial lender question

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348

I have two properties, one a commercial building for auto repair, the other is a mixed use building, commercial retail on the bottom floor and 2 residential units above ( this building is currently out of service needs full reno). Both properties mortgage free

I approached a bank for a line of credit on the auto repair building and a construction loan for the mixed use building. 

The bank told me their desktop underwriting flagged my mixed use building as a hazardous space but not the auto repair building. So now the bank is requiring me to do a 21e on the mixed use building but not the auto repair building. 

This is beyond me because I would think the auto repair business is more of an issue environmentally. However they are telling me because there was a dry cleaner business at the mixed use building in the past there could be soil contamination. 

With that, I am considering not getting the construction loan and putting the building back in service with private money. Then approaching perm loan lenders after completion. Will perm loan lenders look for a 21e?

Post: CPA vs Tax Strategist

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348
Quote from @Chris McCormack:

Transactions vs. Relationships. Tax Strategists, when done correctly, are about relationships and will work with you year round. Tax Preparers and CPAs/EAs stuck in the traditional way of doing business will meet with you once a year and tell you what you owe. We started our business in Boston and have a few connections still in the area. Would be happy to touch base.


 Thank you for helping me better understand the difference here.

Post: CPA vs Tax Strategist

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348
Quote from @Michael Plaks:

@Rich Hupper

What I noticed is that you posted your question 3 months ago stating you were looking, and you got a lot of good feedback and a link to BP directory of tax pros. Yet, 3 months later, you're still stating that you need a new strategist. Apparently not much progress in 3 months. 

Now is mid-year, and many of us are not taking new clients for this year anymore. Your choices are dwindling the longer you wait. You might have to either settle for whoever is still available or wait until late in the year to start looking for next year's switch.

Here're several older threads that may be helpful.

https://www.biggerpockets.com/...

https://www.biggerpockets.com/...

https://www.biggerpockets.com/...

https://www.biggerpockets.com/...


 Thanks for following up mike I will review what you sent.

Post: CPA vs Tax Strategist

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348
Quote from @Bonnie Griffin Kaake:
Quote from @Rich Hupper:
Quote from @Bonnie Griffin Kaake:

@Rich Hupper There are some great CPAs on BP. At the same time, most good CPAs are so busy, they don't have time to add clients for strategy sessions. We are not graduating enough students from college with accounting degrees and going on to be CPAs to fill the pipeline. I am an inactive commercial RE broker, invest in commercial properties and for the last 7 years have been specifically trained to strategize with clients and their CPAs to maximize tax benefits for their RE investors and add cash-flow. 

The tax benefits available to investors in commercial and residential real estate are very complex. A good example is that the vast majority of depreciation schedules on STRs being done be CPAs/tax professionals are being done incorrectly right now. You may find you will do better with a tax strategist/consultant and a CPA/tax professional. We do work together very well. 


 Hi Bonnie are these Tax Strategist licensed or do they have some kind of degree? Or are they self taught?


 Excellent question, Rich. Select carefully. There is a wide spectrum of qualifications. Our company only hires degreed individuals and then spends an enormous amount of time training them before they are allowed to work with clients. Ongoingly, we have twice weekly meetings to keep us up-to-date. Nevertheless, some of us are more qualified than others. You should always ask questions of whoever you are considering or choosing to work with. Some companies only see their reps as salespeople. We are consultants. I am happy to let my clients and the CPAs/tax professionals I work with know my background. We have a huge team of professionals at our home office that are always at the ready to answer any questions I cannot answer. The IRS regulations are very complex in this area and need specialists to interpret them. I teach CPAs how to leverage the tax benefits available for their clients.  


 Unfortunately that is what I am starting to see. I have been with my CPA for 5 years but all she does is collect my statements and prepares the returns. She never offers advice or suggestions how to structure my entities to reduce taxes or even open retirement accounts / health accounts.

Post: CPA vs Tax Strategist

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348
Quote from @Lucas Caruso:

I am a former tax attorney and would classify myself as a "tax strategist." I could design a tax efficient structure for a business (cross-boarder or domestic), however, I could not prepare that same business' tax return. I would expect any good CPA to be able to perform similar functions to a strategist, for example, helping you determine entity type to use as your investment vehicle (partnership, disregarded entity, corporation (C or S) or partnership). 

Hi Lucas I will DM you directly. Thank you

Post: CPA vs Tax Strategist

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348
Quote from @John Malone:

@Rich Hupper this is a great question!

Technically speaking, a “strategist” is just branding. As a lawyer focusing on tax planning, l can say I’m a strategist as well along with my CPA partner but its more of a way to show prospects what we focus on.

However, you’ll want to look for companies who are focused on year round proactive planning for RE investors vs a pure 1X compliance model in your situation. Hope this helps!


 Hi John thanks for reaching out. I will DM you and we can talk about what you do. I need a new accountant and strategist.

Post: Phantom Buyers? What is this?

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348

thank you for clarifying

Post: Phantom Buyers? What is this?

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348

Hello I am wondering if this is an actual concept in real estate. Basically creating a strawman entity or trust to make offers on another's behalf to protect their anonymity or give them the ability to buy something they normally wouldn't be able to buy because of a tarnished relationship between the two parties?

What would be the best entity to do this. What would be reasonable compensation for the fiduciary? How would proof of funds be disclosed to the sellers if they request to see it?

Post: Turn around on Construction plans for a 3 unit design

Rich HupperPosted
  • Broker / Investor
  • Tewksbury, MA
  • Posts 1,263
  • Votes 348
Quote from @Ke Nan Wang:

Sorry this is happening to you. Real estate is full of landmines and I definitely had my fair share of mistakes so it's important to negotiate a good contract upfront. Or ask for experience person to guide you through the process the first time. 

To screen a professional whom I have never worked with before, I would ask to see their portfolio and past client references. Any reputable and experienced people would be proudly to supply that. If someone who's new to the industry and can't provide any, we wouldn't disregard them right away because I understand everybody has to start somewhere. For starter professional, I would still ask for work they have recently done that they feel proud of, and negotiate a contract in my favorable terms and price. You would find someone sometimes they just starting and they want to charge like a seasoned professional, those aren't the people for you and you need to have the discipline to walk away. 

In the contract, typically architect charge by milestones. Price is set based on either an hourly, or a price per sq ft rate. These are all negotiable. Deposit, existing (for renovation) site plan and preliminary floor plan proposals, then elevation and remainder of the print. Interior design and landscape/hardscape would be cherry on top. 

Also be aware there are difference between someone who's only give you a floor plan and some interior rendering vs. an engineered stamped building blueprint set that you can use to pull permit with. I have talked to clients who had no ideas what the differences are. And some people who aren't actually licensed architect and claimed they can do the plan where in reality they just give you a floor plan and interior rendering and it's useless for permitting nor the contractor. 


 Thanks for the advice Ke. Yes I didn't ask for all those references when choosing. I spent so much time just getting the 5 bids I was ready to pull the trigger with the most affordable option. Unfortunately doing this cost me time. It is in the contract that he provide me with plans to pull a permit but I know what you mean about the floorplans vs construction plans. Just looking forward to pulling a permit and starting work. The building needs a lot of TLC and the sooner I get it finished the sooner I get cash flow.