@Vic Vega, without knowing the specifics I made some assumptions based on your original post. First, I assumed you put 20% down for a total of around 30K, making your principal borrowed around 127K. Second, I assumed a mill rate of around .02 (taxes around 2% of assessed value). I also assumed insurance of around $600 per year. Lastly, I assumed an interest rate of 4.5%. Knowing that those are all variables, I worked the formula to give me a PITI of about $900. If you pass on the exact numbers I will rework my formula.
The first issue I see is a problem with your statement "so great cash flow obviously." I disagree that you will have great cash flow. Let's say you get $1600, which is not smart to plan for because you never want to plan for the highest amount, rather you should hedge your bets and assume worst case scenario. Regardless, assuming $1600 in rent, you are starting off with $683 cash flow. Now, with a rental, you need to plan in other contingencies:
vacancy: 10% (160/month), your cash flow is now $523 per month
maintenance and repairs: 10% (160/month), your cash flow is now $363 per month
utilities (if your county or state requires you to carry some) - 10%, your cash flow is now $203/month
lawn care/snow removal: 5%($80/month), your cash flow is now $123/month
capital expenses(CAPEX): I know you say the place is in perfect shape but you still need a plan to start setting aside for future expenses, roof, water heater, HVAC, driveway, windows, siding, etc...:even on the low end I would plan for 10%(160/month) - your cash flow is now -$37/month
Have you considered refinancing at the current 113K, at current rates as low as they are. If you can afford to, I would suggest getting the rate down to 3.5 or so which will lower your monthly PITI to around $765/month which would bring you whole again. This way if you do decide to rent it out, you are at least cash flowing positive.
It is really hard to be disciplined and look at this investment this way. There is emotion there and I am guilty of it as well. Your current house, if you should decide to rent it, is now an unemotional investment. You cannot plan for top of the market rents long term. You may get them to start because the house is in pristine condition, but how long will it stay that way. One year, two, five??... then what?? You have to plan for vacancy and long term capital expenses because history tells us that those things are unavoidable and a fact of long term real estate investing.
If you want to start building your portfolio, this is a great way to do it. Although it is not the ideal rental, it may be a good opportunity to maintain leverage and gain a second property. The jump from one to two may be the biggest jump to make.
Do what makes the most sense to you and don't look back. Good luck!