Eventually, both are going to face a class action lawsuit and end up in court over this one.  

Eviction isn't a great option here- I think you'd have major problems in court proving which tenant caused this issue or if it were tenant caused at all.

Although guaranteed you will hear from the Ohio folks I personally think in most instances the home court advantage is an advantage except maybe in VHCOLA like CA. 

@Colleen F. unfortunately, AFAIK, there is no other resource than go to small claims court and go after her, which will take me $2-3K in additional legal fees.

Becca, totally with you—AI should be the silent ops chief, not the face tenants deal with.

We not only obtained a summary judgement in our favor, but we also had the court confirm a provision in our partnership agreement whereby he was responsible for our attorney fees.  

The seller's heirs challenged the land contract in court (because there was a lot of equity between the buyer's contract price and the current market value).

The irs is pretty clear with various court cases that at least two stays is needed to prove short term rental status. you will also need to find a way to materially participate in the assetOne other caveat is that STRs are a business.

We tried doing a payment plan, they agreed and didnt hold up to their agreement and decided to take this to court which was a whole process in itself.

You can either sacrifice a little money or let me stay for another year or get tied up in a 1 to 2 year court battle that you can't win