Physician Mortgage vs. Hard Money Loan for Major Renovation Project

General Real Estate Investing
1yFollow

Physician Mortgage vs. Hard Money Loan for Major Renovation Project

Janell E.
Rental Property Investor · Saginaw, MI · Member since 2019 · 34 posts · 25 votes

We found a home we love and see as the ideal place to raise our growing family. The property needs significant work. The current owner bought it for $420K via tax lien, and we’ve verbally agreed on a $470K purchase price.

Renovation costs are estimated at $180K–$220K (based on two contractor quotes, plus a 25% buffer), with an ARV of $800K–$900K.

The challenge is financing. We're low on liquid cash, with funds tied up in other investments (we own 24 units), and I prefer not to dip into retirement savings. I also want to avoid FHA or conventional rehab loans due to negative experiences I've heard.

I’m considering two options and would appreciate input:

1) Physician Mortgage Loan

  • No down payment or PMI
  • Requires AC and flooring to be installed before closing ($44K)
  • Would ask the seller to cover these costs and adjust the price
  • Drawback: flooring will likely need to be redone during renovation, creating inefficiencies
  • Plan: fund the rest through personal loans and cash over 2–3 years

2) Hard Money Loan

  • Finance both purchase and renovations up front
  • Complete renovation in 6 months and enjoy the home fully
  • Option to buy AS-IS with no additional work needed before closing
  • Plan: refinance after renovations to pay off the HML

Let me know your thoughts or if there's a better route I’m overlooking.

0Reply
43 views

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jeb Durgin
    Lender · South Lake Tahoe, CA · Member since 2019 · 109 posts · 36 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Janell E.:

    We found a home we love and see as the ideal place to raise our growing family. The property needs significant work. The current owner bought it for $420K via tax lien, and we’ve verbally agreed on a $470K purchase price.

    Renovation costs are estimated at $180K–$220K (based on two contractor quotes, plus a 25% buffer), with an ARV of $800K–$900K.

    The challenge is financing. We're low on liquid cash, with funds tied up in other investments (we own 24 units), and I prefer not to dip into retirement savings. I also want to avoid FHA or conventional rehab loans due to negative experiences I've heard.

    I’m considering two options and would appreciate input:

    1) Physician Mortgage Loan

    • No down payment or PMI
    • Requires AC and flooring to be installed before closing ($44K)
    • Would ask the seller to cover these costs and adjust the price
    • Drawback: flooring will likely need to be redone during renovation, creating inefficiencies
    • Plan: fund the rest through personal loans and cash over 2–3 years

    2) Hard Money Loan

    • Finance both purchase and renovations up front
    • Complete renovation in 6 months and enjoy the home fully
    • Option to buy AS-IS with no additional work needed before closing
    • Plan: refinance after renovations to pay off the HML

    Let me know your thoughts or if there's a better route I’m overlooking.


    Sounds like a great opportunity with solid equity upside—especially given your experience with 24 units.

    Between the two options, the Hard Money Loan sounds more aligned with your goals:

    • You get the full renovation done upfront

    • Avoids the inefficiencies and rework from the Physician Loan route

    • Lets you enjoy the home fully in 6 months vs. stretching it out over 2–3 years

    Yes, hard money comes with higher costs, but in this case, the speed, simplicity, and ability to buy as-is without seller concessions may justify it—especially with that strong ARV.

    Just make sure:

    • The HML terms allow for a smooth refi into a long-term loan after reno

    • You have a solid contractor and tight budget management

    • Your exit plan (DSCR refi or conventional?) is locked in early, given tighter lending conditions right now

    You might also explore private money if you have investor relationships—less rigid than hard money and potentially lower cost.

    Overall, if speed and full control are key, HML looks like the better fit here. Happy to dive deeper if you want help running numbers or reviewing lender options.

    0Reply
  • Nicholas L.Pro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Pittsburgh · Member since 2018 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    1y

    @Janell E.

    hello. i don't know anything about 1 so can't be of help there. i would recommend against 2 unless there is something else to note. based on what you wrote, the ARV isn't high enough for hard money to work. when you go to refinance you'd need to bring cash to closing to pay off the hard money loan and based on what you said, you don't have it.  but let me know if i am missing something...

    0Reply
  • Jeb Durgin
    Lender · South Lake Tahoe, CA · Member since 2019 · 109 posts · 36 votes
    1y

    Here's my two cents, and honestly, coming from the hard money world, most of my peers would probably tell you I'm crazy for saying this, but I think the Physician Mortgage Loan is actually the better bet for you here.

    Why I Lean Towards the Physician Mortgage for Your Home

    You're talking about a place to raise your family, right? That changes the game from a pure investment flip.

    • Massive Savings: Seriously, no down payment, no PMI, and those long-term interest rates are going to be way lower than anything I or any other hard money lender could offer. That interest savings alone could fund a big chunk of your reno.
    • Built for Homeowners: This loan is designed for folks buying their primary residence. It's more stable, more regulated, and frankly, a lot less headache for a home you plan to live in.
    • Minor Hurdles for Major Payoff: Yeah, the $44K upfront for initial fixes and that flooring re-do are annoying. But that's a small price for the long-term financial peace of mind. And while a 2-3 year reno is a grind, you won't be bleeding cash on high interest while you're in it.

    Hard Money: Still an Option, But Know the Score

    Now, is hard money absolutely an option? Yes, it is. We could definitely get you the funds to buy it AS-IS and knock out that reno in six months. If speed and buying exactly as-is are your absolute top priorities, hard money delivers.

    But here's the kicker: it's expensive. It's built for rapid, high-profit investment flips, not for a family home you're holding long-term. The costs would be significantly higher, and you'd be against the clock to refinance before those high interest payments eat you alive.

    So, while I'm deep in the hard money game, for your family's place, the Physician Mortgage just makes more sense in my book. It's a strategic long-term play for a primary residence.

    0Reply
    • Jeb Durgin
      Lender · South Lake Tahoe, CA · Member since 2019 · 109 posts · 36 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Jeb Durgin:

      Here's my two cents, and honestly, coming from the hard money world, most of my peers would probably tell you I'm crazy for saying this, but I think the Physician Mortgage Loan is actually the better bet for you here.

      Why I Lean Towards the Physician Mortgage for Your Home

      You're talking about a place to raise your family, right? That changes the game from a pure investment flip.

      • Massive Savings: Seriously, no down payment, no PMI, and those long-term interest rates are going to be way lower than anything I or any other hard money lender could offer. That interest savings alone could fund a big chunk of your reno.
      • Built for Homeowners: This loan is designed for folks buying their primary residence. It's more stable, more regulated, and frankly, a lot less headache for a home you plan to live in.
      • Minor Hurdles for Major Payoff: Yeah, the $44K upfront for initial fixes and that flooring re-do are annoying. But that's a small price for the long-term financial peace of mind. And while a 2-3 year reno is a grind, you won't be bleeding cash on high interest while you're in it.

      Hard Money: Still an Option, But Know the Score

      Now, is hard money absolutely an option? Yes, it is. We could definitely get you the funds to buy it AS-IS and knock out that reno in six months. If speed and buying exactly as-is are your absolute top priorities, hard money delivers.

      But here's the kicker: it's expensive. It's built for rapid, high-profit investment flips, not for a family home you're holding long-term. The costs would be significantly higher, and you'd be against the clock to refinance before those high interest payments eat you alive.

      So, while I'm deep in the hard money game, for your family's place, the Physician Mortgage just makes more sense in my book. It's a strategic long-term play for a primary residence.


       As you can see, Ive changed my mind after really thinking about it.  I just had to put on my "borrower" hat and take off my "lender" hat to really see it differently! I apoligize in advance if this confuses you

      0Reply
  • Parker Schultz
    Lender · San Diego · Member since 2025 · 39 posts · 6 votes
    1y

    As a private money lender myself (who also does residential loans)

    I would do a private money loan to fund your renovation, knowing that it is BPL (Business Purpose Loan), in which you most likely sign a BPL Affidavit that you not be occupying the property as a primary residence. DRE laws, consumer protections etc etc. After adding value, I would ideally refinance into your physician loan. I havent read the terms of you loan program, or if it works for refinances, but i assume it would. 

    Is there positive equity in your 24 unit to take out a second lien to fund your down payment and/or renovation cost?

    There are non-qm loan products that value your retirement savings and other financial investments as cash eauivalents for the sake qualifying for liquidity. Not on a 1-1 ratio due to penalties and taxes etc. But those investments are much more access for qualifying than you would imagine. 

    0Reply
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
Log InJoin for Free