Investor · Portland, OR · Member since 2023 · 11 posts · 1 vote
Hello!
We were just hit with, what I feel is, an exorbitant tax prep bill of $1850. It's a new LLC with just one NNN rental income source. This cost equals 5.5% of our gross income for the year (nearly 2/3rds of one months income) and I am wondering if that sounds right? Should I be looking for another CPA?
@Corinna Woodcock this was a Partnership? If so that is pretty standard for a one off fixed fee.
Nothing is apples to apples though when it comes to scope and pricing. Every CPA bills differently and includes different items. Some bill fixed fee, some hourly, some have subscription models.
What did this include? Was all bookkeeping reconciled etc?
We were just hit with, what I feel is, an exorbitant tax prep bill of $1850. It's a new LLC with just one NNN rental income source. This cost equals 5.5% of our gross income for the year (nearly 2/3rds of one months income) and I am wondering if that sounds right? Should I be looking for another CPA?
I too detest paying my CPA. I think the going rate is about $350/hr. A lot of your question could hinge on how well you prepared your documents for him? Plus the first year takes more initial setup. We have 37 units and we paid our guy over $4,000 last year… but that was just for our business… paid him an additional $1,500 for our personal return on top of that. I know I could pay less elsewhere, but I do like the idea of someone really qualified - more or less covering my butt when it comes to the IRS!
$1,800 is less than a day of billable time for him in all likelihood. Given the need to set up depreciation tables, and just having to interpret a new client’s reporting / submission methods it doesn’t sound horribly bad for a CPA. Is it expensive? Yes! But for a CPA… probably pretty average.
The thing to know is that 5 units would probably only cost you a few hundred dollars more… so the 1 unit example is sort of the worst case scenario possible. keep in mind just like with a doctor’s office or lawyer he is covering a lot of additional people for his fee… a secretary, other accountants on staff, his overhead, his car payment, his health insurance, his kids college fund, his vacation, his retirement, etc (Lol!) you might save a little switching… but probably not much.
@Corinna Woodcock it's tough to say if it's fair without knowing all the details, but it's definitely on the higher end.
Comparing it to the percentage of your gross income might not be the best approach, though. CPA fees can vary based on factors like location, complexity of your situation, and the CPA's experience.
If you're unsure, it doesn't hurt to shop around and get quotes from other CPAs. It'll give you a better idea of what's reasonable for your specific case. And who knows, you might find someone who's a better fit for your needs. Good luck!
@Corinna Woodcock this was a Partnership? If so that is pretty standard for a one off fixed fee.
Nothing is apples to apples though when it comes to scope and pricing. Every CPA bills differently and includes different items. Some bill fixed fee, some hourly, some have subscription models.
What did this include? Was all bookkeeping reconciled etc?
We were just hit with, what I feel is, an exorbitant tax prep bill of $1850. It's a new LLC with just one NNN rental income source. This cost equals 5.5% of our gross income for the year (nearly 2/3rds of one months income) and I am wondering if that sounds right? Should I be looking for another CPA?
Just asking if XXXX is a good amount to pay for Taxes is a pretty broad question.
Was that just for the 1065 prep, [OR]:
Does that include your personal 1040?
Does that include billable time coaching you on what and how to do things?
Does that include bookkeeping service?
Does that include filing state taxes?
Does that include meeting minutes?
What schedules does that include (are they for your 1040 or the 1065)?
Were you on the phone a lot asking questions and being billed for "Education time"?
Does that include your K1 Prep and sending it out?
Is there Payroll associated with this LLC?
Is there Depreciation associated with this LLC that needs to be tracked (are you tracking that or your tax service)?
It is hard to say whether the cost is high or not based on the information provided.
1. Was the accountant doing the bookkeeping as well? If yes, that likely makes it more of a fare price, especially if there was 12 months of activity 2. How many partners / members are in the LLC? If there are many partners that are residents of different states, it may make the partnership return more complex which can justify the price
Furthermore, you should have been aware of what the fee would have been(or atleast a range) upon engagement with the CPA.
In general, larger firms will charge a higher fee. Furthermore, CPA's in large cities will charge a higher fee. Furthermore, CPA's with an expertise in one area(real estate) will charge a higher fee.
You may want to shop around to see if you can get a quality product at a reduced price.