Investor · Wheat Ridge, CO · Member since 2009 · 78 posts · 8 votes
We have a close family member who has a property in Denver, CO that has been a restaurant for over 20 years. The structure is an old house and the zoning in the area allows for a business or residential. The property should sell for upwards of 500K. Let's just say we get 500K on a sale for the purpose of this question. The property was bought a long time ago and is fully depreciated. First off how do we determine the long term capital gains on this property. Second, what about having this family member move into the property for two years as a primary residence to save on the capital gains. We could simply add a shower to one of the baths. The thought is if it saves a big tax bill then it would be worth it to this individual. There's even the idea of running a coffee shop and living in a portion of the property although we aren't sure if this is even an option legally. They could also rent their current house out while living in what was once the restaurant providing an income in the mean time, including being a place they could move back into after 2 years. Would like to avoid a 1031. Any thoughts/ideas on this would be greatly appreciated.
It sounds like the restaurant has closed. You will run into issues moving in now and attempting to avoid capital gains. You will still have recapture from the purchase price etc.
Your issue here is Depreciation Recapture, as Steven Hamilton says, and not so much Capital Gains. With an unwillingness to consider a 1031, there's really not much else to do but be ready to pay taxes. Even an owner carry won't defer the recapture.
So if the original purchase price was 79,000 wouldn't there technically be a gain of 421,000 to pay long term capital gains on? Then they would have to pay taxes on what was depreciated? Sorr, I'm pretty green here. This was a discussion we had over dinner over what will be owed on the sale. I guess I always thought that with a renal property, you could technically move into the property for two years to avoid a cap gain.
The property has to be your primary residence for 2 of the last 5 years to get a section 121 exclusion on capital gains of $250K/$500K (single/married) But I bet he doesn't want to live there for the next 2 years.
The tricky thing here is it's been a restaurant for the last 20+ years, not a residence. That makes it commercial property which gets depreciated over 39 years. So if he hasn't had it as a business for 39 years there should be some depreciation left. Congress changed the depreciation rules in 1987, so if he bought it before then different rules apply.
So to convert this from commercial property to a primary residence could take some work. You'd have to turn it back into a livable residence and probably remove everything that makes it a restaurant and not a house. You'll probably have to get approval from the city to convert it as well. They might want it to stay a restaurant. Was it originally his residence and he converted it into a restaurant?
Assuming he took depreciation the IRS is going to want that back when the property sells. Even if he didn't take depreciation they can still say it was allowable and want it back anyway unless he made a statement that he would not be taking depreciation which is very rare.
You might be able to swing the conversion to a residence only because it is actually a house. So it makes sense that it would be a residence. Any other building and this would be ridiculous.
If you actually convert it back to a residence and he lives there for over 2 years before selling he may be able to get the capital gains exclusion (thats a big may), but would likely have to pay depreciation recapture either way.
Talk to a CPA that understands commercial real estate and everything should become much clearer.
Thanks Paul Caputo you bring up some good points. Since the current restaurant (who was leasing the property) left it now looks like a vacant house (all equipment is gone). Converting it back to livable house could easily be done by adding a shower or bath as the current bathrooms do not have one. As it stands now if you walked in you would have no idea it was a restaurant. The answer to your question regarding how it was used when purchased - It was a restaurant also when purchased about 20 years ago. The property is zoned for residential or commercial. The owner will definitely be talking to her CPA this week although I'm not sure how RE savy they are. I'll likely have to help her talk with someone who is more familiar with real estate tax. It just helps to run things by The BP folks. I really appreciate you taking the time to write back on this.
The thing about the IRS is all they care about is documentation and applying the tax code correctly. The problem is there are thousands of pages of tax code and they are constantly changing things.
I did a little more digging for you on the subject and found this article. Check it out.
Seems like there would be depreciation recapture when its converted to a residence, but that's probably gonna be around $10,000 or less and probably wouldn't be recaptured until the property is sold. ($79K initial cost, half depreciated = about $40K in depreciation taken that is recaptured at 25, probably about 20% less than this since there's some non depreciable land value in that initial $79K)
I was unaware of the non qualifying use rules mentioned in the above article. Any non qualifying use since 2009 applies pro rata to the exclusion. So she'd have to live there for 8 years to get 50% of the gain excluded since it had 8 years of non qualifying use before being converted into a residence. If she only lives there for the required 2 years and has 8 years of non qualifying use then she can only get 20% of the gain excluded.
So the more I delve into this the more it seems like it's not the best course of action. With the non qualifying use selling is probably the best bet unless she plans on living there long term.