Skip to content
General Landlording & Rental Properties

User Stats

343
Posts
70
Votes
Craig Garrow
Pro Member
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Malone, NY
70
Votes |
343
Posts

Ice fell off roof and onto tenant’s boyfriend’s truck...

Craig Garrow
Pro Member
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Malone, NY
Posted Jan 20 2018, 17:08
I had some ice fall off of the roof of one of my buildings, and into the driveway...onto my tenant’s boyfriend’s new truck. Looks like it got pretty banged up. How should I approach this insurance wise?

User Stats

95
Posts
31
Votes
Shawn H.
  • Investor
  • Carbondale, IL
31
Votes |
95
Posts
Shawn H.
  • Investor
  • Carbondale, IL
Replied Jan 20 2018, 17:22
He should have insurance on his truck. Your insurance is to cover your property and personal liability. If a limb, from a neighbors tree, breaks off during a storm and damages your house, your home policy should cover it.

User Stats

6,521
Posts
6,958
Votes
Matthew Paul#2 Contractors Contributor
  • Severna Park, MD
6,958
Votes |
6,521
Posts
Matthew Paul#2 Contractors Contributor
  • Severna Park, MD
Replied Jan 20 2018, 17:24

He contacts his insurance .

Rental Home Council logo
Rental Home Council
|
Sponsored
Advocating for Single-Family Rental Housing Drive rental policy change. Protect your investments with a National Rental Home Council membership.

User Stats

6
Posts
3
Votes
Chris Moxley
  • Oklahoma City, OK
3
Votes |
6
Posts
Chris Moxley
  • Oklahoma City, OK
Replied Jan 20 2018, 20:02

This could also fall under the General Liability Insurance of the Landlord.  I would at least do a “report only” to cover yourself.  The auto insurance for the boyfriend could handle the claim, then surrogate against the Landlord or they might not do anything at all. 

User Stats

142
Posts
104
Votes
Alex Corral
  • Denver, CO
104
Votes |
142
Posts
Alex Corral
  • Denver, CO
Replied Jan 20 2018, 20:57

Been with State Farm for 17 yrs. The truck policy must cover it, not the Landlord policy.

User Stats

99
Posts
42
Votes
Cameron Novak
  • Corona, CA
42
Votes |
99
Posts
Cameron Novak
  • Corona, CA
Replied Jan 21 2018, 03:59
Hire a good attorney and sue Al Gore for misrepresentation.

User Stats

8
Posts
2
Votes
Tim Stine
  • Frederick, Md
2
Votes |
8
Posts
Tim Stine
  • Frederick, Md
Replied Jan 21 2018, 05:56
His insurance!

User Stats

26,662
Posts
17,979
Votes
James Wise#1 Classifieds Contributor
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH
17,979
Votes |
26,662
Posts
James Wise#1 Classifieds Contributor
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH
Replied Jan 21 2018, 07:47
Originally posted by @Craig Garrow:
I had some ice fall off of the roof of one of my buildings, and into the driveway...onto my tenant’s boyfriend’s new truck. Looks like it got pretty banged up. How should I approach this insurance wise?

 This should be his insurance liability not yours.

User Stats

387
Posts
559
Votes
Michael Gansberg
  • Investor
  • New York City, NY
559
Votes |
387
Posts
Michael Gansberg
  • Investor
  • New York City, NY
Replied Jan 21 2018, 18:52

@Craig Garrow - I'd make sure your roof is properly insulated. With a well-insulated roof, there usually isn't ice buildup. If it's poorly insulated- the heat will melt the snow, then as the water will freeze to ice as it runs down to a lower, colder point on the roof. 

Not only are you wasting energy if this is occurring- next time, it might be a person under that giant icicle!

User Stats

142
Posts
104
Votes
Alex Corral
  • Denver, CO
104
Votes |
142
Posts
Alex Corral
  • Denver, CO
Replied Jan 21 2018, 19:14
Originally posted by @James Wise:
Originally posted by @Craig Garrow:
I had some ice fall off of the roof of one of my buildings, and into the driveway...onto my tenant’s boyfriend’s new truck. Looks like it got pretty banged up. How should I approach this insurance wise?

 This should be his insurance liability not yours.

Yep, his comprehensive coverage on the truck.