All
Members
Companies
Blog
Forums
Podcast
Webinars
    User Log in  /  Sign up
  • Start here
  • Education
    Forums

    Learn from and contribute to 658K+ real estate discussions

    BiggerPockets Podcast

    Listen to weekly interviews with investors & entrepreneurs

    BiggerPockets Blog

    Delve into 8,800+ articles by experienced investors

    Member Blogs

    Read original articles by BiggerPockets members

    Guides

    Master the ins and outs of fundamental real estate topics

    The Money Show

    Listen to weekly interviews that will help get your financial house in order

    Webinars

    Sign up for this week's free webinars hosted by experienced investors or view previously-held webinar recordings in the Archives

    Videos

    Browse our library of real estate related video content

    Free Course

    Experience The Financial Independence Blueprint video series - a free four-part video series

    Topics
    Property Management Property Types Finance Strategy Finding Deals Business Operations
  • Network
    Members

    Search over 1,265,000 members across BiggerPockets

    Companies

    Explore over 31,000 real estate-related companies

    Real Estate Agents

    Find an investor-friendly agent near you

    Hard Money Lenders

    Pinpoint lenders near you with our nationwide database

    Events

    Find upcoming real estate events and meetups near you

    Jobs

    Browse real estate job opportunities in your area

  • Tools

    Calculators

    • Fix and Flip
    • Rental Property
    • BRRRR
    • Rehab Estimator
    • Wholesaling
    • Mortgage Payment
    • 70% Rule
    • Airbnb Calculator

    Services

    Find a Contractor Get a Mortgage Loan Tenant Screening External Link

    Additional Tools

    FilePlace

    Download presentations, spreadsheets, contracts & more

    REI Resources

    Dig into thousands of curated real estate tools & resources

    Calculators
  • Marketplace
    Properties For Sale

    Buy and sell real estate deals or seek out partners, financing, etc.

    Find Foreclosures External Link

    Search this comprehensive database of nationwide foreclosures

    Ads, Jobs, and Other

    Advertise your real estate business, deals, financing & more

  • Bookstore

    Featured Book

    Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing book cover

    Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing

    This easy-to-follow guide will show you how to make money during all of the market’s twists and turns! Accomplished investor J Scott dives into the theory of economic cycles and the real-world strategies for harnessing them to your advantage.

    Get the book now

    Real Estate Books

    • Flipping and Estimating Bundle
    • How to Invest in Real Estate
    • How to Sell Your Home
    • See All Books
    Real Estate Books

    Shop books covering real estate investing and personal finance.

    Lease Agreement Package New

    Don't spend $1,000 on a lawyer!

    Real Estate Forms

    Lease Agreement Package New

    Don't spend $1,000 on a lawyer!

  • Plans
Log In Sign up
User
Quick search links
Podcast Hard Money Lenders Books Washington
ForumsArrowLandlord Forums & Rental Property QuestionsArrowInheriting tenants with A LOT of occupants.
  • Newest Posts Arrow Down Light
    • Newest Posts
    • Unanswered Discussions
  • Trending Arrow Down Light
    • Top Discussions
    • Trending Discussions
  • Landlord & Tenant Arrow Down Light
    • Local Real Estate Forums

      Real Estate Forums near you

      • North Carolina Real Estate Q&A Discussion Forum 2.3K Posts 350 Discussions
      • New York City Real Estate Forum 1.3K Posts 191 Discussions
      • Pennsylvania Real Estate Q&A Discussion Forum 2.5K Posts 434 Discussions
      • Norfolk Real Estate Forum 350 Posts 35 Discussions

      View all Local Real Estate forums

    • General Info
      • New Member Introductions 488K Posts 56K Discussions
      • Real Estate Success Stories 77K Posts 3.7K Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area 16K Posts 3.0K Discussions
      • Questions About BiggerPockets and Official Site Announcements 42K Posts 4.1K Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Summer Reading List 92 Posts 14 Discussions
      • Real Estate Not-So-Successful Stories 523 Posts 41 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Money Podcast 675 Posts 50 Discussions
      • Real Estate Quizzes 696 Posts 21 Discussions
      • FAQ Forum 132 Posts 9 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Webinar Discussion Forum 459 Posts 15 Discussions
    • General Real Estate
      • Buying & Selling Real Estate Discussion 423K Posts 58K Discussions
      • Military Investing 5.4K Posts 530 Discussions
      • Completed Deal Diaries 5.6K Posts 1.9K Discussions
      • Do it Yourself 32K Posts 3.5K Discussions
      • Construction & Remodeling Diaries 6.1K Posts 1.0K Discussions
      • Investor Deal Diaries 17K Posts 863 Discussions
      • Renters Discussion 44K Posts 5.1K Discussions
      • Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum 6.2K Posts 910 Discussions
      • Get Foreclosure Help - Stop Foreclosure Forum 6.6K Posts 910 Discussions
    • Reviews & Feedback
      • Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice 131K Posts 18K Discussions
      • Ask About A Real Estate Company 24K Posts 2.7K Discussions
      • Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions 28K Posts 2.9K Discussions
    • Investor Basics
      • Starting Out 290K Posts 41K Discussions
      • General Real Estate Investing 144K Posts 19K Discussions
      • Real Estate Investor Marketing Help & Advice 46K Posts 6.5K Discussions
      • Investor Psychology 21K Posts 1.6K Discussions
    • Landlord & Tenant Forums
      • Landlord Forums & Rental Property Questions 358K Posts 39K Discussions
      • Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing 19K Posts 2.3K Discussions
    • Foreclosures
      • General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums 33K Posts 5.2K Discussions
      • REOs 17K Posts 2.2K Discussions
      • HUD, VA, and Tax Sales 10K Posts 1.5K Discussions
      • Short Sales Questions 17K Posts 2.1K Discussions
    • Real Estate Strategies
      • Real Estate Wholesaling Questions & Answers 137K Posts 18K Discussions
      • Real Estate Development & New Home Construction 19K Posts 2.6K Discussions
      • Innovative Strategies 27K Posts 3.4K Discussions
      • Rehabbing and House Flipping 110K Posts 13K Discussions
      • Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion 34K Posts 3.9K Discussions
      • Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options 15K Posts 2.3K Discussions
      • Short-Term and Vacation Rental Discussion 22K Posts 2.0K Discussions
      • 1031 Exchanges 8.7K Posts 1.4K Discussions
    • Commercial Real Estate
      • Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Forums 96K Posts 10K Discussions
      • Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum 36K Posts 4.8K Discussions
    • Business Basics
      • Goals, Business Plans & Entities 25K Posts 3.5K Discussions
    • Real Estate Technology and the Internet
      • Real Estate Technology, Social Media & Blogging 16K Posts 2.3K Discussions
    • Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines
      • Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice 105K Posts 14K Discussions
      • Creative Real Estate Financing Forum 50K Posts 7.5K Discussions
      • Real Estate Crowdfunding Forums 5.6K Posts 384 Discussions
    • Financial, Tax, and Legal
      • Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA 100K Posts 15K Discussions
      • Personal Finance Forum 18K Posts 2.0K Discussions
      • Property Insurance Questions & Discussions 11K Posts 1.8K Discussions
    • Real Estate Professionals
      • Real Estate Agent Forums 47K Posts 7.0K Discussions
      • Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers 12K Posts 1.9K Discussions
      • Contractors 18K Posts 3.7K Discussions
    • Real Estate Marketplace
      • Real Estate Events and Happenings 57K Posts 12K Discussions
      • Marketplace 227K Posts 88K Discussions
    • Off Topic
      • Housing News & Real Estate Market Discussions 15K Posts 1.8K Discussions
      • Off-Topic 43K Posts 5.3K Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit 2.0K Posts 107 Discussions
Start a Discussion

Inheriting tenants with A LOT of occupants.

42 Replies

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
Rotate Log in or sign up to reply
  • 1
  • 2
Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

posted 2 months ago

Hello everyone, 

I am in the process of buying my first real estate investment property and I am hoping to gain some insight into a particular situation that I have found myself in today.

A little information about the property. It is a three family building all units with 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, 1 eat in kitchen and a living room and I would say the units are approximately 1050 sq ft each. 

As of now all tenants are TAW. I just received the schedule of leases and tenancy agreements and I was surprised to find out that the units are occupied by 6 (1 adult and 5 under 18) on the 1st floor, 9 on the second (2 adults and 7 under 18) and 6 on the third floor (3 adults and 3 children). 

We are planning to manage the property ourselves because we want to get the full experience before we start using a management company so we will have to address any issues ourselves. My question is obviously about the amount of occupants living in the building, in particular the 2nd floor which has 9 occupants. 

I guess I am looking for a "what would you do if you were in my shoes" kind of answer. We are going to purchase the property and we are very excited about it but we want to have a clear idea as to how we are going to handle the transfer of tenants and what will be the best course of action.

As a side note I call the water department for the town and I was told the building has an average water bill of $200 a month, yes that is $2,400 annually. I can assume this has something to do with the 21 occupants who are all bathing, flushing the toilet etc. 

Any insight will be greatly appreciated 

Mark Bookhagen
  • 358 posts
  • 134 votes

Mark Bookhagen
from Buffalo, New York

replied 2 months ago

Property should be vacant at closing or walk on the account of thew water bill (due diligence).

Thomas S.
  • 13K posts
  • 11K votes

Thomas S.

replied 2 months ago

I will assume your tenants are not paying for utilities.

What you should do is find out from your buildings department what the allowable number of indivulaes is in regards to the second floor unit and if they are over the code give them notice to cure or quit. If not then terminate when legally allowed.

In most cases inherited tenants will either vacate or be evicted so with luck you will be able to find more suitable tenants for all three units.  You will also be able to pass on the utility costs to new tenants. Utility costs can be expensive which is why it is best to avoid investing in properties that are not separately metered.

This post has been removed.

This post has been removed.

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Mark Bookhagen I do not want to walk on the account of the water bill because I have reason to believe that issue can rectified with more suitable tenants. I am guessing what you are getting at is remove the current tenants ASAP? I could contact the agent and have at least the one unit with 9 occupants be vacant at closing. 

@Thomas 

@Thomas S. The only utility bill not paid by the tenants is the water bill. I will give a call to the buildings department first thing Monday morning and inquire about occupant limitations. I have a feeling they are not in compliance. Having the tenants pay for water is not common practice in the area I am looking. That does not mean I can't meter them out but that might affect my ability to find tenants.

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

This is directly from the MA tenant law

"in a dwelling unit, every room occupied for sleeping purposes by one occupant shall contain at least 70 square feet of floor space; every room occupied for sleeping purposes by more than one occupant shall contain at least 50 square feet of floor space for each occupant"

Based on that info each of the bedrooms would need to be 150 sqft and I am pretty certain that is not the case. 

Christopher Brainard
  • 852 posts
  • 654 votes

Christopher Brainard
Investor from Rockwall, TX

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell  

Before you get involved with this property too deep, you need to read up on federal fair housing guidelines. Just because you think there are too many people (in this case children) living there, doesn't mean that removing/evicting them is legal. This is discrimination based on familial status and is subject to enormous fines levied by HUD.

With that said, last I checked HUD guidelines allow two adults per bedroom, so it sounds like they're well within compliance with federal laws. You can check with local code compliance to see if there are any local limitations on occupancy. You can also select other reasons to evict them, but they can still file a complaint.

Also (don't quote me on this), I believe that landlords with three or less units are exempt from the HUD requirements and you may be able to skirt this issue, however, you should create a firm set of rules to run your business and I do not recommend starting off in this fashion, even if it may be allowable. My guess is they could still cause you a lot of trouble.

I agree with @Mark Bookhagen - take the property vacant at closing. If not, be willing to wait the tenants out and do not renew their lease. In the future, screen your own tenants. Don't allow situations like this to develop, but don't address them from an illegal viewpoint. 

-Christopher

Sam Shueh
  • 3.3K posts
  • 1.3K votes

Sam Shueh
Real Estate Agent from Cupertino, California

replied 2 months ago

Suggest you have seller to serve them xxx days (local custom) to get them out as condition of making the offer. There is a limit how many can occupy. So you have 15 cars outside? Conflict with neighbors often occur with over crowded situation.


Mark Bookhagen
  • 358 posts
  • 134 votes

Mark Bookhagen
from Buffalo, New York

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell - You want to be cognizant of fair housing laws. You cannot say, "...too many kids so they have to leave."

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Christopher Brainard  

So are you saying a minor does not count as an occupant? or counts less than an adult? I did not see any distinction between adults or children when someone is considered as an occupant (other than 12 months or younger) they don't count, or at least here in MA.  

If I cannot get the unit(s) delivered vacant I will just do the other option you had mentioned and wait them out, that is if they are actually in compliance at the moment. They are on a month to month lease so it would be fairly easy to not renew the lease.

To be clear I would never allow this situation to happen but I don't want to let it deter me from a great cash flowing property just because of a tenant issue. Inherited tenant issues seem to be common. 

@Sam Shueh  

From what I gather there are only 6 adults in the property that are of driving age. There is also three off street parking spots available behind the property but yes I see what you are saying. Once the older children become of driving age they might pick up a car causing more crowed streets. 

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Mark Bookhagen

I would never say they have too many kids but is there something wrong with saying there are too many occupants? If the rooms, based on square footage, cannot support the amount of occupants according to local tenant law then I have a legitimate reason for not renewing the lease. Please correct me if I am wrong.

Mark Bookhagen
  • 358 posts
  • 134 votes

Mark Bookhagen
from Buffalo, New York

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell You're correct. NY (my state) laws are a bit different than what someone quoted above. MA law seems much more reasonable. I just try to avoid these situations by making the seller deal with the issue so I don't have to.

Christopher Brainard
  • 852 posts
  • 654 votes

Christopher Brainard
Investor from Rockwall, TX

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell

The answer to your question is yes....and no. 

If I remember correctly, HUD states that two persons per room, as a general rule, is acceptable. I think we can all agree that if you have five adults living in a two bedroom apartment, they are over the limit.

The problem with the HUD position is the 'general rule' part and it doesnt clearly define the ratio of 'children' to 'people'. They may find more than two people acceptable based on the age of the children, size of the bedrooms, layout of the residence, and who knows what else. For example, if you have a one bedroom unit which is occupied by an infant, the mother, and the father, there are three occupants. If you evicted them based on this, you would be in a world of hurt. Now, lets say that its a single mother with two kids that sleep in the living room? Is this ok? I have no idea.

My wife and I own a mid sized apartment complex and the advice that our lawyer gave us was pretty simple - two adults per bedroom, ignore the kids. This interpretation of the HUD rule gives us the least legal liability and we really haven't had any issues with it. We've had several occasions where we had a mother and four kids or two parents with three in a two bedroom without any issue. The problem is usually the quality of tenant, not the number of occupants.

In your case, given they are month to month, no-cause ending their leases is defenately the easy way out. 

-Christopher

Chad Kastel
  • 43 posts
  • 19 votes

Chad Kastel

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell

I don't know if this was asked and answered.  But how long has floor two been living at the property?  If it's several year, they have a good track record of paying on time, AND the apartment is in good condition is it something you even want to worry about.   Just because you have too many people in one space does not means they will be bad tenants (just more likely) and the reverse is certainly true.    If maybe they are pushing the envelope with expenses then renegotiate that.  

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Mark Bookhagen  

I will do my best to have the current owner resolve the issue before closing but if that is not possible I guess I can take on the responsibly and chalk it up as a learning experience. I know moving forward  I will not let a unit that I fill turn out like the one in question. Sounds like I need to make a few phone calls on Monday morning. Thank you for you input! 

@Christopher Brainard  

I just read a Federal Register article about the Department of Housing and Urban Development and that instance was mentioned. Having two parents and an infant living in a 1 bedroom apartment should be within acceptable standards but having two parents and a now teenager living in that same 1 bedroom apartment should allow grounds for denial of tenancy. I can understand ignoring the kids to make sure you air on the side of caution but where should the breaking point be? 

In this particular instance, based in what the previous agreement between the current landlord and tenant, which I remember reading in @Brandon Turner's book on managing rental properties, that you should never ask the age of the occupants only the amount of occupants under and over 18 years of age but that is besides the point, there are two parents and a young child >12 months old which should use 1 of the three bedrooms. Then there are 6 other occupants 17, 12, 11, 9, 4, and 3 utilizing the other two bedrooms (all of which are less than 150 sq ft). I just don't see how this complies with occupancy standards. 

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Chad Kastel

Floor two has been living there since May of 2018, so not very long. I am not sure about what kind of tenant they are but from what I saw in the unit they keep it well kept. I just don't want to be caught up with having too many occupants living in one of my units according to local law. They might be great tenants who pay on time but that still doesn't change the amount of occupants residing in the unit. 

Chad Kastel
  • 43 posts
  • 19 votes

Chad Kastel

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell

I am not an expert and am going off comments in the section I read, but it seems like with children occupying the space the laws are not super clear.  I would say just reevaluate when the lease comes up.  Their lease ends in 6 months, so you can just choose not to resign them.  It's unlikely you're going to have a problem with the law between when you buy it and the lease ends.

Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Chad Kastel  

All three unit are on a month to month lease and are TAW. I have noticed that laws regarding children occupying the units is unclear like you said, but I am just going off the requirements for sq ft per occupant. I am by no means an expert either and to be honest I had no idea what options I had when I first noticed this earlier today. Should be interesting. 

Chad Kastel
  • 43 posts
  • 19 votes

Chad Kastel

replied 2 months ago

@Alexander Wardell

Seems like an easy fix.  Because the don't have a lease, just find new tenants.  Probably not a great idea to ask these tenants to "comply" with the laws, if they could have less people in the apartments they probably would've done that already.

Shirley Rozenshteyn
  • 53 posts
  • 46 votes

Shirley Rozenshteyn
Rental Property Investor from Hartford, CT

replied 2 months ago
@Alexander Wardell Not gonna take you through my sob story but I have recently learned the hard way that better have a fresh start with a property and certainly if you suspect a code violation. Did you know about the relocation act? https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/847/topics/646231-epic-fail-3-family-in-hartford-ct?highlight_post=3848841&page=1#p3848841
Alexander Wardell
  • 103 posts
  • 57 votes

Alexander Wardell
from Sandwich, MA

replied 2 months ago

@Shirley Rozenshteyn

I just had the chance to read through your post and that is very unfortunate. I would have never thought having both means of egress located on the same side of the home being an issue but now that I think about it, it makes sense. If there is a fire causing one means of egress to be blocked it is more than likely the area is impacted creating a very difficult situation in case of fire. 

This particular property has one stair case in the front of the house and the back, both of which reach all 3 floors. If I call on Monday and it turns out that having that many occupants in the unit is a serious violation, I will have the owner deliver the unit vacant. If that is not a possibility they are TAW on a month to month lease so solving the should be fairly easy. Key word should be but we shall see. 

I hope you are able to resolve your issue. I know building new fire escapes can cost upwards of 17k and take about 2 months from start to finish, at least from what I have seen. Good luck and keep us posted. I am interested to see how it all plays out. 

Jill F.
  • 585 posts
  • 773 votes

Jill F.
Investor from Akron, Ohio

replied 2 months ago

Perhaps you could make the tenants responsible for water moving forward with submetering or RUBs ?

Shirley Rozenshteyn
  • 53 posts
  • 46 votes

Shirley Rozenshteyn
Rental Property Investor from Hartford, CT

replied 2 months ago
@Alexander Wardell Check in your city to see if there are any open violations on this property. Good luck
Maurice D.
  • 337 posts
  • 186 votes

Maurice D.
from Coppell, TX

replied 2 months ago

check the code.  some cities go as far as saying X unrelated people allowed. etc.

are those "kids" just a bunch of unrelated teenagers rooming?

  • 1
  • 2

Top Contributors

Thomas S.
Thomas S.
8.76
Score
Nathan G.
Nathan G.
Cody, WY
8.55
Score
Dennis M.
Dennis M.
Erie, pa
5.89
Score
James Wise
James Wise
Cleveland, OH
2.91
Score
Joe Splitrock
Joe Splitrock
Sioux Falls, SD
2.44
Score

Trending Discussions

  • Should I report this agent to the Board of Realtors or?
    97 Replies
  • California to make "Solar "mandatory for new Homes!!!!!!
    56 Replies
  • Does Number of Days on MLS affect your buying decisions?
    76 Replies
  • Should we wait or go for it?
    31 Replies
  • How many of you have bought a note this year ?
    20 Replies
Close Thin

Create Lasting Wealth Through Real Estate

Join the millions of people achieving financial freedom through the power of real estate investing

Start here

Already have an account? Click here to log in

Log in Sign up

Log in

Forgot password?

If you signed up for BiggerPockets via Facebook, you can log in with just one click!

Log in with Facebook

Let's get started

We just need a few details to get you set up and ready to go!

Use your real name

Use at least 8 characters. Using a phrase of random words (like: paper Dog team blue) is secure and easy to remember.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.

Why create an account?

Receive a free digital download of The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing.

Connect with 1,000,000+ real estate investors!

Find local real estate meetups and events in your area.

Start analyzing real estate properties, we do the math for you.

It's free!

Explore

  • Membership
  • Community
  • Education
  • Marketplace
  • Tools
  • Perks
  • iOS App
  • Android App

Company

  • About Us
  • Press
  • Advertising
  • Careers
  • Stats
  • Contact Us

Important

  • Terms of Use
  • Rules
  • Privacy
  • FAQ

Social

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
© 2004-2019 BiggerPockets, LLC. All Rights Reserved.