Furniture frustration, deep pockets, & budget strategy. Is contract grade worth it?

Furniture frustration, deep pockets, & budget strategy. Is contract grade worth it?

Member since 2025 · 5 posts · 7 votes

For those of you with a large STR portfolio, I'd love to hear your biggest pain points when in comes to furniture. What pieces are breaking the most? What are you replacing at least once or twice a year?

I'm asking in an attempt to lead to a bigger question/discussion: when is your operation large enough to justify the cost of contract grade furniture?

I'm new here, so, a quick introduction. I'm an interior designer specializing in short term rentals. I've designed and installed STRs all over the country. One of my repeat clients and I were working on a refresh project as he is slowly upgrading his entire portfolio. Let's call him Louis (from Louisville). He's always replacing beds and out of operational frustration gave me a new rule - I want the same bed in every property, no wood, only metal, three cross bars of support under the slats. He had compared his operation to a hotel - they all have the same furniture in each room and everything is indestructible. Louis wants to have the operational efficiency of a hotel chain.

Knowing that his frustration was due to the lack of quality furniture he had, I searched for commercial grade bed frames. The answer was Room&Board's Jennings bed frame. Modern, but will look good in a variety of house styles. Comes in every size. Comes in multiple colors so I don't have to limit my creative side! Made in the US and they have great customer service so I know my client could quickly get replacement parts when needed. All metal! Built to last. All this and a king is less than $2k. 

Now, I know this is a great price. This is a great solution to his problem. BUT - how many of you have $1600 beds in your properties? Every single client of mine requests durable furniture, made to last. 75% of my clients have budgets that call for $300 beds. It's not that my clients have small budgets. It's that the budget has to be STRETCHED so the home looks competitive. If we need a sauna, wallpaper, a sectional to seat 12 (not even possible tbh), a pool table, and arcade games... we can't afford expensive beds. They get pushed down the priority list. When I first started my design company, I'd push back at clients and really try to get them to invest in higher quality furniture. Now I'd say my approach is really mixed. As you can imagine, my client decided to go in the opposite direction and get the same metal bed from Amazon for every bedroom - less than $200 each. I don't blame him! He knows they will break, he'll have to get a quick replacement, and investing in the "unbreakable" contract grade beds wasn't a financial possibility at this time. Even if he had the cash, that investment might have felt too risky to him. (This is another topic for another post - but I do think it's smart to spend low on items you know you'll be replacing. My designs are always a mix of high and low because that just smart budget engineering).

So, I''m curious. For all of you investors out there with lots of STRs. Where is the line? When, if ever, does your operation become large enough that you start spending more now to save later? Does that line exist in the STR world yet?

We've heard of the amenity race. Add one more thing to your home that the top competitor doesn't have. I see my clients racing to the top with design and amenities, but this conversation with Louis got me thinking about the race towards operational efficiency. I've designed for some very big players in the STR world and even the deepest pockets aren't prioritizing this angle. Are the pockets just not deep enough yet? Or, is this a good strategy and just another reason STRs are unique from hotels?

1Reply
331 views

Most Popular Reply

John UnderwoodPro Member
Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
11mo

I spend the money on quality furniture. I buy  inexpensive cups, silverware etc that is easily damaged or can grow legs.

Sheets and towels are good but not terribly expensive to replace.

Haven't had much issues with damage. 

See this reply in the discussion

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • John UnderwoodPro Member
    Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    11mo

    I spend the money on quality furniture. I buy  inexpensive cups, silverware etc that is easily damaged or can grow legs.

    Sheets and towels are good but not terribly expensive to replace.

    Haven't had much issues with damage. 

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11mo

    I don't have a large operation but like @John Underwood I decided to go for quality furniture even though it cost more because it looks better and should hold up longer.  Some of this decision will be dependent on the type of guest you host. 

  • Michael BaumPro Member
    Olympia, WA · Member since 2016 · 8k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    11mo

    Hey @Bailey Rankin, I am not a big STR owner with 100 doors or anything like that.

    Like @John Underwood, I have quality USA furniture where it is most necessary.

    No metal beds. Always solid wood, oak and pine in my case. Zero issues with damage after 8 years. Bassett and La-Z-Boy stuff for chairs, couches and love seats.

    Personally I would never spend 2k on a king bed frame. I wouldn't make all my furniture identical in each and every bedroom and STR.

    I buy USA made used furniture that I find on Craigslist etc. It is amazing what you can get on various sites for pennies. The Bassett set we have was barely used and it was almost free. The La-Z-Boy queen hidabed couch was $150 and brand new. It is almost 2k brand new.

    When you buy a quality piece of wooden furniture, it is durable but the main thing is they are easy to repair. We have never had any major damage to any piece of furniture except a handmade futon someone couldn't figure out how to make back into a couch and broke it.

  • Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11mo

    I agree with metal over wood bed frames from a durability standpoint. A $100-200 metal frame is pretty much indestructable and have weight capacities that are 10-20X+ that of the average person. 

    That said, metal frames are ugly and cold. If I were furnishing a higher end listing I would stick with wood and buy something solid. I've found some hybrid frames where the bulk of it is metal but with wood legs and a headboard, that way it looks like wood once it's made up. 

    I don't think Contract Grade is a requirement, although you should certainly purchase with quality in mind. I find that the less hardware and moving parts the better. Looking for items that are already assembled usually solves for this. 

  • Collin HaysBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Gatlinburg, TN · Member since 2020 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    11mo

    I'm a big believer in SOLID wood dining and chairs.  I'm also a believer in heavy duty leather sofas and chairs - no fabrics. No reclining chairs or sofas - they break.   Leather will outlast fabric 5X.  Sturdy metal beds are not only durable, but are somewhat fashionable right now.  

  • Mike GrudzienPro Member
    Lender · Eugene, OR · Member since 2019 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11mo

    Always go for quality to last for the long run.

  • Mike GrudzienPro Member
    Lender · Eugene, OR · Member since 2019 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11mo

    Also, people spend a 1/3 of their life in bed.  It better be a great bed...

  • Kenneth GarrettPro Member
    Investor · Florida Panhandle/Illinois · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    11mo

    I agree with the previous posts.  I buy better quality furniture for couches, kitchen tables and furniture.  Mostly from Rooms to Go.  I have bought furniture at some local discount stores never had a problem.  Beds are off of Amazon with wood headboards.  Never had a problem 6 years and counting.  Towels Costco and Amazon.  Silverware Walmart.  Keep cost down on hanging pictures and small decorative items.  If I buy nice little Knick knacks they seem to walk away with guests. Conserve where you can.  I can generally furnish for $10-$12 a square foot.  No arcades.  Beach themes.  

  • Member since 2022 · 527 posts · 413 votes
    11mo

    As others have said, quality furniture for sure.  I prefer solid wood personally, but I don't mind stylish metal, just not what I've purchased.  Hosts that go the cheap route also have to bake in time for revenue lost due to broken furniture, etc.  It can take you out of commission if something breaks from a guest, terrible reviews, etc...and of course the replacement cost.  I like to buy the right things the first time around.  Like others have said, I go cheaper on dishes etc. since those things break easily and need many replacements.  Also, I get the ease of making everything uniform, but frankly, I like adding a touch of different style to each place and room, so not sure I would buy exactly the same thing for each unit.

  • Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
    Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    11mo

    I manage around 60 doors mostly in FL. I also sell 2-4 units per month, many of which are unfurnished. I do have a local designer who knows to go for durable items for STR. I do let my new clients know that you can be cheap on things like decor (paintings, knick knacks, etc), silverware, TV's even, but anything that is sat on, laid on, etc needs to be commercial grade when possible. Yes, it can be twice as expensive, but it will last more than 2x as long. Buy it nice (or strong) or buy it twice!

  • Member since 2024 · 49 posts · 16 votes
    11mo

    When we bought our first STR, it was fully furnished. Everything had to be replaced. We kept only the kitchen items. We learned a lot. I purchased an inexpensive sofa bed. We were out of budget. I've already had to replace it. It lasted about 18 months. We purchased an inexpensive mattress. It will need to be replaced sooner than a great mattress, but a thick topper has made a big difference. We are oceanfront. We bought a lot off of FB Marketplace. Learning lesson: metal rusts fast at the beach. We've now replaced a lot of that with wood. It was a lesson with costs, but at the same time, we didn't have a lot of options on that first one.

  • Rental Property Investor · Phoenix, AZ and Rehoboth Beach DE · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11mo

    For bed frames, I bought these heavy duty ones from Zinus (4400 lb capacity), and dropped them into a wooden bed frame that is more stylish, replacing the slats that came with it.  https://www.amazon.com/Zinus-SmartBase-Mattress-Foundation-R...  The slats are the weak point.  I like this metal frame because the legs are recessed, unlike other cheaper ones, so no stubbing your toes on the legs. 

    • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      11mo

      Re beds I buy the metal hotel frame bases that wrap around so no cleaning or gross stuff left under the bed and nail headboard to wall.

  • Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 292 votes
    11mo

    Great question! I manage several STRs, and the biggest recurring issue we see is with dining chairs, sofas, and coffee tables, those tend to wear out or break the fastest, especially in high-traffic listings. Outdoor furniture is another one we replace at least once a year because of weather exposure.

    Over time, we’ve learned that choosing durable, easy-to-clean materials (like performance fabrics and metal frames) makes a big difference, it saves both time and money.

    Curious to hear how others are handling this too! Always looking for new ideas and trusted brands to recommend to owners we work with.

    • Member since 2022 · 527 posts · 413 votes
      11mo
      Quote from @Andrew Street:

      Great question! I manage several STRs, and the biggest recurring issue we see is with dining chairs, sofas, and coffee tables, those tend to wear out or break the fastest, especially in high-traffic listings. Outdoor furniture is another one we replace at least once a year because of weather exposure.

      Over time, we’ve learned that choosing durable, easy-to-clean materials (like performance fabrics and metal frames) makes a big difference, it saves both time and money.

      Curious to hear how others are handling this too! Always looking for new ideas and trusted brands to recommend to owners we work with.

      I’m at the beach and bought all Polywood for outdoor. It is a little more pricey but get discounts through Minoan and last forever!
    • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      11mo
      Quote from @Patricia Andriolo-Bull:
      Quote from @Andrew Street:

      Great question! I manage several STRs, and the biggest recurring issue we see is with dining chairs, sofas, and coffee tables, those tend to wear out or break the fastest, especially in high-traffic listings. Outdoor furniture is another one we replace at least once a year because of weather exposure.

      Over time, we’ve learned that choosing durable, easy-to-clean materials (like performance fabrics and metal frames) makes a big difference, it saves both time and money.

      Curious to hear how others are handling this too! Always looking for new ideas and trusted brands to recommend to owners we work with.

      I’m at the beach and bought all Polywood for outdoor. It is a little more pricey but get discounts through Minoan and last forever!

       Agree totally worth it for outdoor furniture. There are less expensive HDPE options than Polywood and Trex now that I have found to be decent. 

  • Specialist · Member since 2025 · 483 posts · 270 votes
    11mo

    Smart line in STRs: standardize where abuse is highest, upgrade where guests notice most. Beds break most, then dining chairs and coffee tables; go metal frames with center support, commercial-grade mattresses protectors, and replaceable slats. Use LVP floors, stain‑resistant performance fabrics, and bleach‑washable linens. Spend up on sofas, dining sets, and outdoor pieces guests touch daily; save on nightstands, lamps, art. I move to contract grade when I’m replacing the same item twice a year across 5+ units or when downtime costs more than the price jump. Create a parts bin and SKU list per item so turnovers are swap‑and‑go, not redesigns. Next step: audit last 12 months of damages, rank top 5 items by cost and frequency, then standardize those SKUs portfolio‑wide.

  • Property Manager · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2018 · 178 posts · 134 votes
    11mo

    We've found Zinus beds on Amazon to be affordable and tough.  You can add a headboard to dress them up.  IMO, a key to making beds, chairs, stools, and even tables last is to assemble or reassemble everything with thread lock.  The structure of today's shipped-in-a-box furniture relies on it being tightly assembled to maintain its structural integrity.

    https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Zinus+bed+frame&i=garden&...

    • Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      11mo
      Quote from @Tyler Divin:

      We've found Zinus beds on Amazon to be affordable and tough.  You can add a headboard to dress them up.  IMO, a key to making beds, chairs, stools, and even tables last is to assemble or reassemble everything with thread lock.  The structure of today's shipped-in-a-box furniture relies on it being tightly assembled to maintain its structural integrity.

      https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Zinus+bed+frame&i=garden&...


      I had a wood Zinus frame break at the corner. Might’ve been installer error, not a fan of stuff held together with lag bolts. 

      For dining chairs I found some solid metal framed chairs with wood back and seats from a restaurant supplier, they come fully assembled and shipped for ~$80/piece. Never have to worry about them breaking, which to me is worth the sacrifice for “warmth”. 

    • Property Manager · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2018 · 178 posts · 134 votes
      10mo
      Quote from @Jon Martin:
      Quote from @Tyler Divin:

      We've found Zinus beds on Amazon to be affordable and tough.  You can add a headboard to dress them up.  IMO, a key to making beds, chairs, stools, and even tables last is to assemble or reassemble everything with thread lock.  The structure of today's shipped-in-a-box furniture relies on it being tightly assembled to maintain its structural integrity.

      https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Zinus+bed+frame&i=garden&...


      I had a wood Zinus frame break at the corner. Might’ve been installer error, not a fan of stuff held together with lag bolts. 

      For dining chairs I found some solid metal framed chairs with wood back and seats from a restaurant supplier, they come fully assembled and shipped for ~$80/piece. Never have to worry about them breaking, which to me is worth the sacrifice for “warmth”. 

      I've had wood bed frames crack at the corner, too.  Both times, it was loose bolts allowing wobble.  IMO assembling furniture without Locktite is a fool's errand.  You're asking for a monthly tightening project, forever.

  • Investor · FL · Member since 2016 · 332 posts · 388 votes
    11mo

    I self manage and closing on my 12 rental soon. I have also built or renovated another 6 that I operated then sold.  I also recommend the heavy duty all zinus metal bedframe with a zinus mattress and attach a headboard using the zinus headboard kit.  Couches we have some from Costco, Sams Club and made to order to fabric selection ones from Wayfair and they all have held up well. We stay away from pull-out couches as that is our business model.

    • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      11mo
      Quote from @Account Closed:

      I self manage and closing on my 12 rental soon. I have also built or renovated another 6 that I operated then sold.  I also recommend the heavy duty all zinus metal bedframe with a zinus mattress and attach a headboard using the zinus headboard kit.  Couches we have some from Costco, Sams Club and made to order to fabric selection ones from Wayfair and they all have held up well. We stay away from pull-out couches as that is our business model.

      I'm not a fan of pull-out couches or any situation that might involve myself or others sleeping in the living room but felt like it was expected for STRs. Do you use something else? Or just roll with whatever number of bedrooms the property has? 

    • Investor · FL · Member since 2016 · 332 posts · 388 votes
      11mo
      Quote from @Jules Aton:
      Quote from @Account Closed:

      I self manage and closing on my 12 rental soon. I have also built or renovated another 6 that I operated then sold.  I also recommend the heavy duty all zinus metal bedframe with a zinus mattress and attach a headboard using the zinus headboard kit.  Couches we have some from Costco, Sams Club and made to order to fabric selection ones from Wayfair and they all have held up well. We stay away from pull-out couches as that is our business model.

      I'm not a fan of pull-out couches or any situation that might involve myself or others sleeping in the living room but felt like it was expected for STRs. Do you use something else? Or just roll with whatever number of bedrooms the property has? 


      We go by the number of bedrooms. Depending on the property some bedrooms have two kings or queens in some bedrooms or built in queen bunks. We also have a huge bunk room with 5 queens and two twins but the room is about 600 sqft and tastefully designed. More heads in beds does not necessarily mean a better occupancy, ADR or ROI. We do not want to over pack a place. We want to attrack people willing to pay more money to have a real bed for each guest in their party. The one place we have pull out couches we don't advertise the and only have them so the cabin can sleep our family when we visit.

  • Boulder, CO · Member since 2023 · 174 posts · 97 votes
    11mo

    Hi @Bailey Rankin, we put Thuma's Classic bed in every bedroom except the bunk room (but with different finishes as each room has its own unique design). Solid, simple, extremely well-designed except... that center post makes it tricky to "unbunch" an area rug underneath (which adds warmth and is super soft for guests, so much so that they've commented on them and looked at the manufacturers to purchase for their homes). (I did have rug pads but that made it worse.) If I had it to do all over again, I'd go heavy metal (lol, rock on!) with no center post. But we haven't had any issues other than that.

    I think operational efficiency has to be kept in mind- even with a varied budget or a small budget. But personally? I also value sustainability and my time. I don't like replacing goods over and over and I'd prefer not to contribute more to the "most things are disposable" mindset (which is why turnover for items such as dishwashers, washer/dryer, fridges, etc. frustrates me because they don't build to last anymore). I also like pieces that can serve multiple purposes (e.g. modular coffee tables that the guests can move to better suit how they want to use the space, night stands with built-in USB A and C, art that doubles as lighting, etc.). 

  • Interior Decorator · Member since 2025 · 82 posts · 42 votes
    10mo

    As a Designer too, for the STR Industry, I always always do performance velvet platform beds or wood. And mattresses that are high quality — but not break the bank. I low end the other items like art, kitchen, etc. Its beds and couches that I focus on — and I understand game rooms get hella pricey — but there are ways around that too.

    I hear you and understand 100%. Not sure if there will ever be a true answer to this — even with bougie budgets.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.