Rental Property Investor · North Fork, NY · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 631 votes
For tax purposes Airbnb wants to know if you are a US person or entity (W-9) or if you have a tax ID number (W-8ECI). Income is income regardless but what reasons/benefits would you choose one or other? Liability? I have a tax ID# for an LLC which owns a LTR house but run Airbnb for other houses (that are in my personal name - NOT an LLC) and I'd hesitate to use the same tax ID# for my airbnb business.
@Mark Miles Good point. That’s important for people who operate one or more properties as a business entity, either for themselves or others.
If your business is Jane's Management LLC or Jane Smith, US person, the taxes pass through the same so it doesn't seem to matter. But if you're treating it as a business, maybe for liability reasons and other favorable tax or income strategies, it would matter. And that's what I'm asking about, in a round about way. What are the pros and cons of operating your STR as a person vs. a tax ID entity.
@Mark Miles Good point. That’s important for people who operate one or more properties as a business entity, either for themselves or others.
If your business is Jane's Management LLC or Jane Smith, US person, the taxes pass through the same so it doesn't seem to matter. But if you're treating it as a business, maybe for liability reasons and other favorable tax or income strategies, it would matter. And that's what I'm asking about, in a round about way. What are the pros and cons of operating your STR as a person vs. a tax ID entity.
Not a CPA or atty but to the best of my knowledge, for tax purposes:
- LLC is treated same as an individual if it's a single-member LLC
- If the LLC has multiple members then you'll share the tax burden with those other members
That’s the tax difference
From a liability perspective, an LLC is favorable to shield you but also hurts lending terms