Far Rockaway, NY · Member since 2013 · 4 posts · 0 votes
Why would someone sign over their entire home to me just to be able to avoid the responsibility of paying the mortgage. They can move out and rent/lease and cover the mortgage which is any way what the prospective buyer is going to do in a subject-to deal?
I think you misunderstand how this works. When a house is sold "subject to", the seller no longer owns it. They will never get paid anything, if they don't get something up front. The buyer now owns the house and take over making the payments on the existing loan. "Subject to" is short for "subject to the existing loan".
Million dollar houses make horrible rentals. Half million dollar houses make bad rentals. A house that rents for $3000 and costs $500,000 is a horrible deal. A house that rents for $300 and costs $50,000 is an equally bad deal.
If you had a house worth $1 million and had $500K in outstanding debt, the only way you might sell subject to was if you received a $500K down payment. That might well make sense. You get you asking price on a house that may be difficult to move. You can half up front and the other half in the form of someone else taking over the debt payment.
Most subject to deals do not involve such numbers. They're for a house worth $100K with $95K in debt or some such. The seller would only net $94K after commissions, and would have some closing costs. A subject to deal still has some closing costs. So, if the buyer and seller can cover those, the seller gets rid of a debt and the buyer gets a house without having to qualify for a loan.
Only an idiot would do a subject to deal on a house with 50% equity without getting cash up front.
Thank you so much for taking the time to respond! But let me use houses in my area since that is most likely where I would be starting out. Let us say a house is worth 1 million dollars (which is the average in my area) - would someone sign over their home with zero money down just because they don't want to be a landlord. Furthermore, how long can a subject-to buyer typically postpone full payment. In my area where as I said homes go for a million, and rentals go for approx 3000.00 even if there is only 500,000.00 of debt left on house, it would still take approx 14 years to pay off debt. And that is without taking into account real estate tax and other operating expenses. Would a sane person let go of a million dollar home and trust me that I would pay him 1 million dollars in 15 years just to avoid the bother of being a landlord. If i was the seller , I would rather take less than a million dollars - I would even take 800,000.00 , so I cover the remaining 500,000.00 of mortgage and know for sure that I have my money, as apposed to waiting 15 years for a million dollars with no money down. Thank you in advance for taking the time to advise me!
I think you misunderstand how this works. When a house is sold "subject to", the seller no longer owns it. They will never get paid anything, if they don't get something up front. The buyer now owns the house and take over making the payments on the existing loan. "Subject to" is short for "subject to the existing loan".
Million dollar houses make horrible rentals. Half million dollar houses make bad rentals. A house that rents for $3000 and costs $500,000 is a horrible deal. A house that rents for $300 and costs $50,000 is an equally bad deal.
If you had a house worth $1 million and had $500K in outstanding debt, the only way you might sell subject to was if you received a $500K down payment. That might well make sense. You get you asking price on a house that may be difficult to move. You can half up front and the other half in the form of someone else taking over the debt payment.
Most subject to deals do not involve such numbers. They're for a house worth $100K with $95K in debt or some such. The seller would only net $94K after commissions, and would have some closing costs. A subject to deal still has some closing costs. So, if the buyer and seller can cover those, the seller gets rid of a debt and the buyer gets a house without having to qualify for a loan.
Only an idiot would do a subject to deal on a house with 50% equity without getting cash up front.
Why do people in poor health eat fast food? Because that is the best decision they believe is right for them. Never waste your time trying to understand the 'why'. Just do good business and do what is right by your client.
Elliot, and Tzvi, there are tons of threads here on BP about sub-2, depends on the cicumstances as to the motivation of the seller. Some are ready to walk away, some must be "sold" on the idea.
How successful you might be has alot to do with your knowledge in establishing trust with a seller, if they see you as the solution to a problem Michael's approach can work (not knowing his approach, but from his comment) and personality, professionalism and your track record will have a bearing on making a deal successful with any sub-2.
In most deals, you'll be putting money down, if you're less motivated sellers, the normal deals, and putting in safeguards discussed here on BP can help swing a seller to your thinking. Read up on the topics! :)
Found this thread interesting because I'm currently weighing the pros and cons of "subject to" deals.
A huge risk I didn't see addressed (may have just overlooked as I skimmed through) is that of the "due on sale" clause that exists in the majority of conventional loans. Does the seller own the house outright in this scenario? If not, the bank may require full payment of the remaining balance of the loan, leaving both of you in a pickle.
Any insight you guys could give on the actual probability of the bank demanding cash at title transfer, rather than continuing excepting payments, I would greatly appreciate.
The seller does not own the house in a subject to transaction. The deed is transferred to the buyer. The buyer takes over the seller's existing mortgage. If the buyer fails to make payments, the bank can foreclose on the new buyer since they are on the deed. The seller's credit will be ruined, even though they have no control over the buyer making payments anymore.
I have never done a subject to transaction but it is not very common for the bank to call the loan due when the "due on sale" clause is triggered by the transfer of the deed. There are alot of experts in this area on BP, but most people say they have never had the bank call the loan due--but it is possible. If payments are being made on time, the bank doesn't have much incentive to call the loan due.
I don't have any real-live experience w/ a subject to deal but I've heard that if the note is performing, the bank really has no reason calling the "due on sale" clause.
Also, wondering if you ever pulled the trigger on a subject to deal because I'm currently assessing doing the same thing.
Hey, PM me anytime since we both live in San Antonio, TX. I'd like to chat more.
Quite an interesting topic. For the sub 2 experts, are there any unwritten "rules of thumb" that should be followed by new investors to this form of transaction? I am currently evaluating a deal with only the following information currently provided:
-Asking $25,500
-Approximate ARV 90k
-Approximate Mortgage including taxes/insurance: $470
-Currently occupied with tenant wanting to stay and is willing to accept increased rent(market rent in this area $900-$975/mo)
-Listing individual states this is a "no interest mortgage"?
-Property requires zero renovations
**Of course when I contact this individual I will ask disclosure questions; how much is the current rent, how much is left on the note, financials,etc....but how would you experts proceed on something like this?
ok can someone guide me in how to do a subject to deal I have a property owner that wants to sell his property just for what the mortgage he owes. Now here's the situation the property ARV $ 78,000 he owes $59,678 on his mortgage at first he was asking $69,999 for the home then changed his mind to sell the home for the mortgage he owes. But for me to make a profit spread i'll have to do a subject to. Where I would take over the mortgage payments do some fixing up find another buyer cause theirs no investors interested buying for mortgage owed and they won't make a good roi on their money. So I was thinking getting a subject to with the owner find a buyer after fix it up get the down payment about 10% of value of the home which will be $7,800 and pay payments to me that'll pay the off but enough payments to pay the mortgage and the spread in between including the interest rate. But I guess what i'm trying to say is how do I write up the contract with the owner and should I find a buyer first any advice will help thanks
The easy answer is because that's your business model.
The bigger answer is within a book I wrote. I would be happy to load it on BP so people can read it or ill send it to anyone who could use it.
Hey Michael, I just found this post from 2013 regarding a book you wrote that includes subject-to deals. I am wondering if you have uploaded it onto BP or if you could send it to me?