filing taxes on a note that I foreclosed on AND got the property back a low FMV.

filing taxes on a note that I foreclosed on AND got the property back a low FMV.

Rental Property Investor · Clarkston, GA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes

I did search BP on this topic. Apologies if I missed a thread! I am almost an expert in RE taxes and self file. Just currious re any unforeseen issues with foreclosing the note AND getting the property back with FMV (fair market value) below my credit bid (the price I gave the auctionier as the min price I'd take).

FWIW's

- FANNIE and my note allows me to protect my note by spending funds on legal etc to cover Notice Of Default,  Legal services,  Foreclosure service.  So I spend $$ on legal etc through the life of this note.

- FANNIE and foreclosure statue in my state (GA) allows me to "recover" my expenses through servicing, protecting, managing this note.  I added my hours x $NN hourly rate to manage this performing --> gone non-performing --> foreclosed.  For a fee of $YYY added to my balance due plus $Legal fees paid to others.

- Interest income is just that

- Expenses in the tax year are prescribed as above. Any feed back?

- The Balance was say $50k,  total expenses $25k, credit bid at auction = $75k.    In fact my total costs is the credit bid since I paid out of pocket legal costs and my hours.

- Post auction;   paid for a BPO (broker price opinion) and the value is far lower then my total costs (the credit bid),

== Tax filing Questions start here.

- How do I treat the loss in value between the new lower FMV vs my costs (the credit bid)??

== Converting to an investment property by me rehabing?   If I sell as a flip?   if I keep as a rental?  Cost basis?

- Is my costs basis my $creditbid total costs? Since this is to my advantage (the higher number vs FMV) when converting to an investment property.

Tnx to all,  curt 

0Reply
83 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
Moderator
Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
2y
Quote from @Curt Smith:

@Bill B.  The FC attorneys are the source of FANNIE guidelines for legal fees AND lender fees being "recoverable".  A lender is different then a buy and hold investor re the regs that apply.   Hiring an attorney to file FC is equivelant to putting in an alarm system to protect your flip, its an expense.  The lender is allowed to charge fees to manage a delinquent loan.  But I agree this info is 2nd hand via the  attorney and not 1st hand from reading statute. 

@Jay Hinrichs you are an uber expert in this area. Whats my cost basis in this FC gotten back the house? Can I pick the cost that is favorible. The FMV is not in my favor since its low. My true costs seems to me to be both a reasonable basis and financially the actual costs; balance+expenses.

Just pondering taxes;  the installment sale receives interest and return of principal.  the notes basis is what I paid to buy it.   I'm guessing for the purpose of ending the instalment sale there's a sale as of the auction of the "balance" as the sale price.

Converting to a rental is a Sched E with the basis being the credit bid;  $bal + $expenses + $rehab till "inservice date".  blabla re expenses vs increase of basis there after.

tnx, curt


 speak to your attorney as we have gone through 700+ loans and have spoken to many note investors and I do not know of one or any attorney who would say you can charge your own time for managing an asset. As a reminder, you as the lender when managing an asset are the servicer and fall under servicing laws typically. Thus you cannot charge for servicing, or an increased  rate of a servicers fees from performing to non performing such as additional calls or late notice letters. 

Fees that are typically eligible are attorney fees for foreclosure (Depending on state), court filing costs, and costs to secure a property. 

Also if this was Georgia, I would definitely tread lightly especially if you are not licensed as you can be fined 5 or 6 figures for owning loans without a license and throw into it trying to collect potentially uncollectible fees 

7e investments53 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2y

    1) you’re going to need a CPA who should save you more than you pay them, but here’s my opinions.

    Would your cost basis just be the basis you had before the foreclosure that you were slowing lowering with each payment received? (You are saying the property is worth less today than what you paid for it minus principle payments received right? That’s not good.)

    Could you write off all your expenses to recover the property instead of adding it to the basis, thereby avoiding recapture and taking the deduction today. 

    Are you sure you can bill for your time? This is asked because landlords can’t and obviously you could say your time was worth $1,000/hr or more.

    If you add it to your basis I don’t think there will be a way to show the loss other than selling.

    If you really prefer to do your own taxes maybe you can hire a local or BP tax pro just to handle this transaction?

    Good luck and let me know what you find out, certainly interesting. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    2y

    I dont think you have a taxable event until your sell the property to a third party

  • Rental Property Investor · Clarkston, GA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    @Bill B.  The FC attorneys are the source of FANNIE guidelines for legal fees AND lender fees being "recoverable".  A lender is different then a buy and hold investor re the regs that apply.   Hiring an attorney to file FC is equivelant to putting in an alarm system to protect your flip, its an expense.  The lender is allowed to charge fees to manage a delinquent loan.  But I agree this info is 2nd hand via the  attorney and not 1st hand from reading statute. 

    @Jay Hinrichs you are an uber expert in this area. Whats my cost basis in this FC gotten back the house? Can I pick the cost that is favorible. The FMV is not in my favor since its low. My true costs seems to me to be both a reasonable basis and financially the actual costs; balance+expenses.

    Just pondering taxes;  the installment sale receives interest and return of principal.  the notes basis is what I paid to buy it.   I'm guessing for the purpose of ending the instalment sale there's a sale as of the auction of the "balance" as the sale price.

    Converting to a rental is a Sched E with the basis being the credit bid;  $bal + $expenses + $rehab till "inservice date".  blabla re expenses vs increase of basis there after.

    tnx, curt

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Curt Smith:

    @Bill B.  The FC attorneys are the source of FANNIE guidelines for legal fees AND lender fees being "recoverable".  A lender is different then a buy and hold investor re the regs that apply.   Hiring an attorney to file FC is equivelant to putting in an alarm system to protect your flip, its an expense.  The lender is allowed to charge fees to manage a delinquent loan.  But I agree this info is 2nd hand via the  attorney and not 1st hand from reading statute. 

    @Jay Hinrichs you are an uber expert in this area. Whats my cost basis in this FC gotten back the house? Can I pick the cost that is favorible. The FMV is not in my favor since its low. My true costs seems to me to be both a reasonable basis and financially the actual costs; balance+expenses.

    Just pondering taxes;  the installment sale receives interest and return of principal.  the notes basis is what I paid to buy it.   I'm guessing for the purpose of ending the instalment sale there's a sale as of the auction of the "balance" as the sale price.

    Converting to a rental is a Sched E with the basis being the credit bid;  $bal + $expenses + $rehab till "inservice date".  blabla re expenses vs increase of basis there after.

    tnx, curt


    i agree with you on basis thats how i would think it works  but not a CpA or expert all the props I have taken back in foreclosure and its more than a few.. thats how we came up with our basis when we finally resold. keep in mind we did not keep them for rentals as we are not in the rental bizz per se.. so if you keep them I guess you need to figure out basis to establish how much your deprecation is going to be.
  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2y

    You don’t like the idea of writing off all the costs to recover the property as regular expenses deductible today?  Seems better than adding to the basis to save taxes in the future if/when you sell. If it’s allowed. I suppose it doesn’t matter if you plan to sell again soon, but if you plan to hold it seems better. 

    You gotta love BP for getting you access to people with experience and expertise like @Jay Hinrichs. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Clarkston, GA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    @Bill B. tnx Bill, True the installment sale, irs form 6252, has line 11, costs of the sale.  Where I'll report my legal (etc) expenses through the foreclosure (and a BK) process.

    I have other notes (6252s) but none have sold or FC'ed.

    tnx

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Curt Smith:

    @Bill B.  The FC attorneys are the source of FANNIE guidelines for legal fees AND lender fees being "recoverable".  A lender is different then a buy and hold investor re the regs that apply.   Hiring an attorney to file FC is equivelant to putting in an alarm system to protect your flip, its an expense.  The lender is allowed to charge fees to manage a delinquent loan.  But I agree this info is 2nd hand via the  attorney and not 1st hand from reading statute. 

    @Jay Hinrichs you are an uber expert in this area. Whats my cost basis in this FC gotten back the house? Can I pick the cost that is favorible. The FMV is not in my favor since its low. My true costs seems to me to be both a reasonable basis and financially the actual costs; balance+expenses.

    Just pondering taxes;  the installment sale receives interest and return of principal.  the notes basis is what I paid to buy it.   I'm guessing for the purpose of ending the instalment sale there's a sale as of the auction of the "balance" as the sale price.

    Converting to a rental is a Sched E with the basis being the credit bid;  $bal + $expenses + $rehab till "inservice date".  blabla re expenses vs increase of basis there after.

    tnx, curt


     speak to your attorney as we have gone through 700+ loans and have spoken to many note investors and I do not know of one or any attorney who would say you can charge your own time for managing an asset. As a reminder, you as the lender when managing an asset are the servicer and fall under servicing laws typically. Thus you cannot charge for servicing, or an increased  rate of a servicers fees from performing to non performing such as additional calls or late notice letters. 

    Fees that are typically eligible are attorney fees for foreclosure (Depending on state), court filing costs, and costs to secure a property. 

    Also if this was Georgia, I would definitely tread lightly especially if you are not licensed as you can be fined 5 or 6 figures for owning loans without a license and throw into it trying to collect potentially uncollectible fees 

    7e investments53 Reviews
  • Ned CareyPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    2y

    @Curt Smith I am not an attorney but I agree with @Chris Seveney. Your basis is yiour basis. FMV does not change your basis. Your out of pocket costs are your out of pocket expenses. Doing your own work saves you money but is NOT an expense.

    IF you had a separate company to service the loan, those service fees you actually paid to your own company would be added to your basis. However those service fees your service company earned would be then taxible income to your service company. 

    In other words you cant charge for your own time but if you did it would still be taxible income. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Clarkston, GA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    I have tried to search for what IRS form(s) cover my scenario...

    As an example selling real estate on an installment sale is form 6252 which docs the selling price, principal recieved / yr and interest received.

    When buying a note for $NN,  and getting return of principal / yr and interest recieved/yr how is this cost basis captured?  IRS Form?

    Is this as simple as a Sched C per note?

    In time the note pays off, its sold, or is foreclosed where I get $YYY from the sale at auction or worse I get the security back (a house) and I'll have to have it appraised to set the selling price of the note.

    I know I'm making this more complicated then it is... Once the simple answer is heard or figured out.  Tnx to all.  

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Curt Smith:

    I have tried to search for what IRS form(s) cover my scenario...

    As an example selling real estate on an installment sale is form 6252 which docs the selling price, principal recieved / yr and interest received.

    When buying a note for $NN,  and getting return of principal / yr and interest recieved/yr how is this cost basis captured?  IRS Form?

    Is this as simple as a Sched C per note?

    In time the note pays off, its sold, or is foreclosed where I get $YYY from the sale at auction or worse I get the security back (a house) and I'll have to have it appraised to set the selling price of the note.

    I know I'm making this more complicated then it is... Once the simple answer is heard or figured out.  Tnx to all.  

    Lets make this as simple as possible:
    Bought a loan for $50k. That is your initial basis and what it shows on your balance sheet is you have an asset of $50,000
    1. Principal payments reduce your cost basis. So if you got $10,000 in principal payments, your costs basis is now $40,000

    2. Servicing and other expenses some people leave on the balance sheet to increase the cost basis, but we move them to the profit and loss. So lets say we had $5,000 in expenses. We show a $5,000 loss that year.

    3. But wait, we received $10,000 was received in interest payments. That goes on your P&L as well. So now your P&L has $10k income and $5k loss so a profit of $5k. You would pay taxes on that $5k which would be taxed typically as ordinary income if you are a LLC.

    Next year you sell the loan for $60,000. Your profit is $20,000 which goes on your profit and loss and would be taxable.

    this make sense?
    BTW what is non recoverable vs recoverable expenses etc. should have zero impact on your profit and loss statement. On your balance sheet some people may leave recoverable costs on the balance sheet which would increase your cost basis, but you cannot also move it to the P&L to offset profit. 
    7e investments53 Reviews
  • Morris County, NJ · Member since 2020 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    @Curt Smith

    Apologies, didn't quite read the whole post, but to your OP and last reply...

    Your cost basis should be "your cost."  Your thought process sounds to me like as if you found a rare widget, say a baseball card, at a thrift store for a $1 --- nobody there knew what they had.  You auction it off for $1mil.  The cost basis is $1 since that's what you paid for it...

    So, for your foreclosed note, don't worry about the fmv for the property.  Its just your cost for the note.  Otherwise, if a savy investor was to purchase a property for say $75 when if it was "listed" it would sell for $100...  the investor's cost is $75, not $100.

    For my Notes, I just report interest.  There is nothing to report when principal is returned.

    I admit, the "conversion" of the Note to the property I've never done.  Need a savy accountant to tell me if that's a taxable event --- I think that is part of the crux of the issue.  I THINK it depends on how you handle the rest of the transaction.  The "recovery process" (could be a tax term, idk) would be the foreclosure and the sale of the property to recover your principal and default interest (which would be taxable).  But, if your intention was to hold the property long term, I THINK the cost basis of the note would just tranfer to the property (just like buying any other property under value).

    As for trading a Note, I should think it would still be SchD and f8949?

  • Rental Property Investor · Clarkston, GA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    @David M.  Tnx!   If this to be foreclosed note sells at auction, I can see where I claim legal costs on 8949/sched D.   I'll set the credit bid (the min auction amount) to be my balance plus legal costs.   This would be break even since I would be selling at auction for the current balance and I received principal payments.   form 8949  and sched D would show the selling price to be equal to the cost.

    I'm presuming that all notes reported in this way are break even on sched D and your only gain is the interest collected.

    AND in years with just P&I received on a note, just report the interest on 1040 interest received..  Tnx

  • Morris County, NJ · Member since 2020 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    @Curt Smith Uhhh...  Yup, I think so...  That's my layman's approach from somebody who hasn't bought a note for foreclosure :)  But, I believe it tracks with our experienced Note investors above.

    Now that you have the property, when you go to sell, the basis that you claimed for the Note would become the basis for the property.  There is no free lunch with the IRS...

    Like I said, the conversion of the Note to taking back the collaterial and becoming the Title holder I'm not sure how its handled.  You might just skip the SchD/f8949 since you didn't transact the Note.  Just when you one day assumedly go to sell the property, your cost basis is the aforementioned value that you would have declared on the SchD/f8949.

    As you presumed, the capital gains is break even since you never had a "transaction."  You are just exercising the provisions of a Note you own to gain Title to a piece of real property and now the Note disappears.  So, I best I understand it would be as a barter exchange --- the Note for the Title/Deed.  Since there was no other consideration for the barter, no gain/loss and no additional change to the cost basis.

    Does that approach make sense?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.