How a Dallas Duplex Appraisal Turned a Good Deal Into a Great One

[Susanna Hayrapetyan]

For me, the takeaway is simple: I recently looked at a duplex in East Dallas that checked a lot of the boxes. The property was listed for $350,000, and each side was renting for $1,100 a month. After taxes, insurance, and maintenance, the net operating income worked out to about $18,000 per year. On paper, it looked like a solid investment.

The bank, of course, required an appraisal before moving forward with financing. When the report came back, it valued the property at $390,000—$40,000 more than the contract price. That single number shifted the deal dramatically.

With the higher appraisal, the lender was willing to increase the loan amount based on the appraised value instead of just the purchase price. That meant less cash out of pocket at closing and $40,000 of instant equity built in on day one. It also improved refinance options down the line, making it easier to pull capital back out for the next deal.

It’s a reminder that appraisals aren’t just another box to check for the bank. They can uncover hidden upside, improve your leverage, and change the entire trajectory of an investment.

Of course, it doesn’t always play out in your favor. I’ve seen deals in Phoenix where properties listed at $420,000 appraised at $390,000. In those cases, buyers either had to renegotiate, bring additional cash, or walk away. Still, the appraisal was what kept them from overpaying in an overheated market.

never treat the appraisal as a formality. It’s one of the most powerful tools in an investor’s toolbox.