Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Andrew Street

Andrew Street has started 710 posts and replied 977 times.

Post: How do you screen an STR tenant ?

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165
Quote from @Anita Z.:
Quote from @Michael Baum:

Hey @Anita Z., so I don't truly screen the guests like you mention. In the end you always roll the dice on guests.

I don't allow instant booking. I chat with each and every guest wanting to book the place before they actually book it.

I find this screens out any guests that could have issues and lays the groundwork for a great stay.

It also weeds out folks (in our case) that aren't understanding the distance to town and certain activities in our area. I do have folks that don't book because of that.

That is a good thing as not understanding the distance to get places will create bad blood and cause those 2 and 3 star reviews which no one wants to see.

Like , our place isn't cheap so we don't get the folks that destroy places.

The bottom line is that you are renting out an expensive asset to strangers for 3-10 days or whatever. You just need to get your head around that and push on.

@Michael Baum @Grant Woodward @John Underwood @Bruce Woodruff @Terry Ouimet   

@Andrew Street @Patricia Andriolo-Bull @Andrew Steffens @Jake Baker Appreciate all the valuable input from your experience!  For those who are charging higher nightly rates, where would you say your rates are vs comps to try to weed out the trouble guests?  Do you request the ID verification on your own, or is that via Airbnb? How is that done, is it just asking them to send you their drivers license?

Great questions! Setting higher rates than the comps can definitely help attract guests who value quality, but it’s important to stay competitive within your market. For ID verification, I typically rely on Airbnb’s built-in process, as it’s seamless and keeps everything within their platform. If you need additional verification, you can kindly request a government-issued ID, but it’s best to communicate this upfront in your house rules.

Happy to connect and share more insights! 

Post: WHO ELSE has is seeing amazing returns in there areas??

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hey Pete - That's awesome to hear about your success over the past six months! The current market definitely has some great opportunities for strong ROI and equity growth. Finding the right market is key since every area has its own unique dynamics. It's always exciting to explore other booming markets and see what makes them stand out.

Happy to connect and chat more about this!

Post: How do you screen an STR tenant ?

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Congrats on preparing your property for an STR in San Diego! You're correct—Airbnb and Vrbo don't do credit checks, but many hosts screen guests through reviews, verified IDs, and guest profiles. You can also request a security deposit for extra peace of mind.

Happy to connect and share more tips!

Post: Do You Provide TV Options?

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hi Mike - For STRs, a smart TV with internet is usually plenty since most people just log into their own streaming accounts. If you want to go the extra mile, adding something like Netflix or Disney+ is a nice bonus, especially for families or higher-end guests, but it’s not a must.

Cable TV? Honestly, most people don’t expect it anymore unless you're catering to older guests or sports fans. Keeping it simple with a smart TV works, but one popular streaming service could make guests feel extra taken care of without much effort on your end.

Let's discuss more. I'd be happy to connect! 

Post: How Much Time Do You Spend Managing Your STR

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hey Max - Managing an STR usually takes around 5–10 hours a week. Most of the time is spent answering guest inquiries, scheduling cleanings, and handling the occasional issue that pops up. Tools like automated messaging and keyless entry can really streamline things.

Happy to connect if you want to swap tips or chat more!

Post: Considering first time STR investment in Gatlinburg area, looking for advice.

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hey Chris - It's awesome that you're taking steps toward building something for your family! Feeling overwhelmed is totally normal—it means you're taking this seriously. Connecting with local lenders or experienced investors can really help you get clarity. Maybe start with small meetups or forums in your area (or Gulf Shores) to learn from others' experiences.

Remember, every pro was once a beginner! Keep researching, but don’t let fear hold you back—small, intentional steps add up!

Happy to connect and share advice to help you move forward!

Post: Airbnb/str management advice

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hi Nick - If you’re looking for a property manager or cleaner, start by asking around in local Facebook groups or on Nextdoor—you’d be surprised how many recommendations you can get. Apps like TaskRabbit or Handy are also great for finding help. Local cleaning companies might already handle Airbnb turnovers, so it’s worth calling a few. You could even post an ad on Craigslist or ask a real estate agent for leads. And don’t forget to check out Airbnb host groups—hosts love to share tips and contacts.

For setting up your place, a smart lock is a must—it makes check-ins so much easier. Add outdoor security cameras (just let guests know they’re there) and maybe some motion-sensor lights for extra safety. Inside, make sure the Wi-Fi is solid, the furniture is comfy, and the kitchen has all the basics. Throw in a few nice touches, like coffee or board games, to wow your guests.

Keep extra linens, cleaning supplies, and essentials like toilet paper handy so turnovers are quick and easy. Don’t skip safety stuff either—make sure you’ve got working smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, and a first aid kit. Oh, and check your local rules about short-term rentals so you’re good to go.

Ready to dig deeper anytime!

Post: Difficulty finding a tenant

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hi Victoria - First, the timing could be part of the issue—rentals often slow down before the holidays, especially in college towns like Fayetteville. Also, check if there are a lot of similar properties available; if there’s more competition, it could be harder to stand out.

 Expanding your marketing to platforms like Craigslist, Apartments.com, Facebook Marketplace, and even Instagram could help get more eyes on your listing. If you don’t have one already, try adding a video or virtual tour to attract more interest.

Make sure your photos are high-quality and show the best features of the home. If it’s empty, consider staging it with a few key pieces of furniture. Highlight any unique features like a backyard or updated kitchen. Offering incentives like one month free or waiving fees might also help speed things up.

I'd be happy to connect and share more! 

Post: STR laws in Cincinatti

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hey Raza! You're right about Cincinnati's short-term rental rule requiring the operator to live within 50 miles of the property. It's designed to ensure someone nearby can manage things responsibly.

Your plan to hire a local person for emergencies and other tasks is a great workaround. Just make sure they're reliable and familiar with STR operations. You might also want to double-check if having a local property manager satisfies the city's requirements or if the operator still needs to meet the residency rule.

Good luck with your Airbnb arbitrage—Cincinnati can be a great market! 

Feel free to reach out—always happy to connect and share ideas!

Post: STR evaluation in Kissimmee(Reunion)

Andrew Street
Posted
  • Posts 994
  • Votes 165

Hey Himateja,

Welcome to the STR world! It sounds like you've done your homework. The tax savings could definitely be a big plus for you, but the negative cash flow is something to keep in mind. Kissimmee is still a strong STR market, especially with Disney nearby, but competition has increased.

The smaller pool and backyard might be a concern for some guests, but the privacy from the freeway could be a nice bonus. If you're okay with short-term negative cash flow and manage the marketing well, the tax benefits could make it worthwhile.

Happy to connect and chat more about the area!