Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Benjamin Sulka

Benjamin Sulka has started 53 posts and replied 809 times.

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Alex Speer:

Definitely find something 2-4 units if you need a low down payment. If you have the funds or means to creatively finance you can find something bigger with more cashflow opportunities. Make sure you are screening your tenets to know you have quality renters. Totally up to you when it comes to telling your tenets if you're the land lord. It may work out just fine, or you may get someone knocking at your door at 2 am!


 Thanks for your response, Alex! 

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Ryan Thomson:

@Benjamin Sulka House Hacking is amazing. Here are some resources I found really helpful on my journey:
1. For podcasts I really like the House Hacking episodes on Bigger Pockets Podcast and other channels. Here is a playlist with the best House Hacking Podcasts I’ve found: https://open.spotify.com/playl...
2. Great beginners guide: https://www.biggerpockets.com/...
3. The Book on House Hacking Strategies by Bigger Pockets is also a fantastic book
4. Happy to talk if you want more advice
5. Connect with a realtor who understands house hacking and has invested themselves
6. Connect with a lender to see what you qualify for and how you can improve that situation
7. Go to local Real Estate meetups and learn from people there


 I'm really grateful for all of the info, Ryan. I got your message and I look forward to being connected.

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @James Wise:
Quote from @Benjamin Sulka:

Hey BP,

I'm seeking any advice on house hacking and personal experience from people on BiggerPockets. 

Any advice for dos and don'ts to make this strategy more successful? 

I have my plan almost completely mapped out for this year but I'm looking to fill in any gaps. 

Grateful for any responses.

-Ben, aspiring real estate investor 


 Don't buy a house in a neighborhood you aren't comfortable living in just because the numbers are better.


 Thanks for the comment, James! 

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Julien Jeannot:

My personal favorite is duplex, triplex, & fourplexes which you can get great financing.

Find a place and location you don't mind living in for a few years.

Find a property which you can renovate.

My first was a duplex in a decent and safe area. Poor management, low rents, and needed a cosmetic rehab in both units. If I remember right, YouTube my way through most projects.


 Julien, 

Thanks for the response! YouTube and BP have taught me most of what I know about real estate to this date. Such a great tool. 

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Richard Elvin:

@Benjamin Sulka I would look for a duplex/triplex/quad, easiest financing for OO without being SFH.
Personally, I wouldn't rent to anyone in my "network". Keep business and personal separate.

Buy somewhere you would want to live, for me this is a big deal. If I am comfortable in a neighborhood, then I'm more likely to understand the wants/needs of my tenants. I prefer to rent to working class vs upper class, because I understand what they're looking for in a place. My duplex was in a rental neighborhood where property lines weren't really respected, the neighbors liked to play soccer in my back yard (my lot was the biggest and flattest in the neighborhood). Some people would be offended by that, never bothered me or my tenants though. 

That's just an example to illustrate why I like buying where I'm comfortable living. The tenants that were interested in living in my place had similar expectations, family friendly, comparatively inexpensive (Not cheap/war zone), safe, and comfortable, housing. So I didn't have "the neighbors are annoying" calls. I did have calls about a psychotic tenant, inherited, never vetted by me, that harassed the other tenant because he kept "hearing people in the crawl space", but that's another story. 

Just my two cents. Take it for what it's worth. Best to you!


 Really awesome advice. I've heard time and time again to owner-occupy in an area where I'd be comfortable living. 

Thank you! 

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Jimmy Bostic:

@Benjamin Sulka I think it's important that you figure out your target market and what type of property you're trying to hack with. I see that you're from Cleveland, so if that's where you're buying I think a duplex could be a good fit. I'd personally advise for a first time hack to have someone from your own network rent out the other side. Goodluck 


 Thanks for your response, Jimmy! 

Post: Seeking Advice on House Hackings

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576

Hey BP,

I'm seeking any advice on house hacking and personal experience from people on BiggerPockets. 

Any advice for dos and don'ts to make this strategy more successful? 

I have my plan almost completely mapped out for this year but I'm looking to fill in any gaps. 

Grateful for any responses.

-Ben, aspiring real estate investor 

Post: Having Multiple Loans in Your Portfolio

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Doug Smith:

I think one good thing to remember is how the math works for Conventional and FHA loans vs Investor Loans Like DSCR and Bridge/Flip/Construction. Although Fannie/Freddie allows you to get to 10 loans, few people, including myself, are able to do that based in how cash flow is calculated.

With Fannie, Freddie, and FHA, Debt-to-Income (DTI) ratios are used. That formula takes into account ALL of your debts...mortgage, insurance, taxes, hoa, car payments, student loans, credit cards, etc. Investor Based Loans like the envogue DSCR loan only look at the cash flow of the property. Here's what I mean:

In a DTI scenario with Fannie/Freddie/FHA, let's say you make $1000/mo. I know that's a silly number, but the math is easy to do in my head. Guidelines state that you can have a 43% DTI (50% for FHA), but it actually goes a bit higher in reality. 43% of $1000 is $430, so for every $1000 in income you have, Fannie says you can have $430 in debts going out. Follow me so far? So let's say your current debts are $430 for your $1000 income for a 43% DTI. Now let's say you find a positively cash flowing rental property that gives you an extra positive cash flow of $200 (rents of $1000 with mortgage, insurance, taxes, and hoa payments of only $800). If you use DTI to calculate that and we add your current and new debts and income together, your income is now $2000/mo ($1000 old vs new rents of $1000) and your debts are now $1230 ($430 old plus the new payment of $800). DTI = Debts / Income = $1230 / $2000 = 61.5% DTI...you no longer qualify with Conventional or FHA.

Conversely, DSCR uses only the property cash flow and ignores your other debts. As long as the property cash flows, you have a decent credit score, and you have at least 20%-25% down (I know...a couple of programs have only 15% down at a higher rate), then you can do that deal. DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) is the inverse of DTI. DSCR = Rental Income / Principal + Interest + Taxes + Insurance + HOA Payments. It ingores other debts. It allows a real estate investor to scale beyond what they can get with Conventional/FHA because it cash flows you/your deal differently.

Bridge/Fix-n-Flip/Ground-Up Construction are nearly identical loans in that they are very short-term (12-18 months max) with higher rates and no prepayment penalties that allow you to take a run down property and turn it into something you can take to market...or convert to a longer term hold loan. They really only look at the viability of the deal itself only taking into account your credit score and money that you're injecting into the deal. They are temporary loans to get you to Conventional/FHA, DSCR/Rental Loans, or to sell it as a flip.

The advantage of Conventional/FHA over DSCR is that the rates and fees tend to be a bit lower. The disadvantage is that you can't scale with it. You can also close in your LLC's name with DSCR where you can't with Conventional/FHA. My advice, if you're OK with the loans in your own name, do Conventional/FHA for the first deal or two until you hit your head against the DTI ceiling, then switch to DSCR or a similar style loan to scale upward. I hope this helps you out a bit.


 Doug, 

That really helps. 

Taking out a loan with a lower down payment for the first couple of deals definitely makes sense for my particular situation. I just graduated from college and I need to pay down some debts to get my DTI (stupid student loans) in a solid position for next year.

I will look into DSCR and then see if it makes sense to implement when I'm ready to scale.

Thank you! 

Post: Having Multiple Loans in Your Portfolio

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576
Quote from @Randall Alan:
Quote from @Benjamin Sulka:

Hey BP! 

I'm looking to purchase a multifamily in the summer of 2024 as my first deal and do a house hack. I'd like to take out an FHA loan and live in one side of the property for a years time.

After this, my goal is to purchase 20 rentals within the next 10 years. 

From a lending perspective, what advice do you have for building a portfolio and being able to have many loans at a single time? What issues have you run into and how did you weather them? 

I'm grateful for any advice and I'd love to connect and add value however I can. 

All the best,

Ben Sulka, aspiring real estate investor


 The basics are that you can have up to 10 Fannie Mae owned loans at any given time.  Most lenders want to sell their loans to Fannie Mae which then get packaged up as securities other investors buy.  

Suggestions - look for properties that have multiple 'doors' (rentable units) on one parcel of land.  I have 2 properties that each have 2 duplexes on them.  This gave me 4 doors for 1 loan.

If you run out of Fannie Mae 'slots', you can switch to commercial financing to continue to build our portfolio.  We used a commercial loan to consolidate 4 Fannie Mae loans (that had higher interest rates) into a lower interest rate commercial loan; but the caveat is that commercial loans usually don't have fixed interest rates for 30 years... usually they reset every 5 years to the current interest rate, and they typically have shorter amortization times... like 20-25 years.

As you build up your loan count, Fannie Mae raises the lending requirements... you get into reserve requirements like, you need 6 months of cash reserves to be able to pay for the mortgages".  I ran into one that said that I had to be listed on the deed for my own house (ie use up one of my slots) even though when my wife and I purchased the house, she was the only one on the deed.

One smart move is to only buy properties in one person's name.  So if you are married, you don't put both you and your wife's name on the loan.  That way you have 10 loans, and she has 10 loans.  

You can also google "Fannie Mae Lending Guidelines" and you can pull the requirements right up... their main process is called desktop underwriting. 

Check their website out here:

https://selling-guide.fanniema... 

Hope it helps!

Randy


 Randy, 

I'm grateful for your response and I appreciate you discussing your experiences. 

Cheers! 

Post: Having Multiple Loans in Your Portfolio

Benjamin Sulka#5 House Hacking ContributorPosted
  • Cleveland, OH
  • Posts 811
  • Votes 576

Hey BP! 

I'm looking to purchase a multifamily in the summer of 2024 as my first deal and do a house hack. I'd like to take out an FHA loan and live in one side of the property for a years time.

After this, my goal is to purchase 20 rentals within the next 10 years. 

From a lending perspective, what advice do you have for building a portfolio and being able to have many loans at a single time? What issues have you run into and how did you weather them? 

I'm grateful for any advice and I'd love to connect and add value however I can. 

All the best,

Ben Sulka, aspiring real estate investor