Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Cherish D.

Cherish D. has started 1 posts and replied 9 times.

Originally posted by @Richard C.:

Sell.

But in the meantime...

"Even at this price I'm getting problem people applying for example... one person who wanted to use it as a daycare. "

I really hope you know your obligations and a tenant or prospective tenant's rights when it comes to in-home day care in California.  If you prevent people from doing it, or refuse their application because of it, or charge a higher deposit, the fines you will get will make your current financial challenges look small.

 I hired a property management company that dealt with the applicants and they had refused them because of multiple problems, poor credit, saying there were 5 people and then only applying with 2, etc. 

Originally posted by @Allan Rosso:

Have you looked into whether you'd be allowed to keep renting on AirBNB if you lived there? That may be a possible loophole worth looking into, but only if you'd be comfortable living at the property while guests transit through there on a regular basis.

 The city decided not to allow that either so it’s just as illegal. We tried it for a while when we thought they would pass the law for it and it was very different from renting the whole house. Guests expected to pay a lot less and  needed a lot more attention and service. Because we were there they thought they had full time service staff. Of course there were exceptions but I wouldn’t recommend that option. 

Originally posted by @Natalie Schanne:

Cherish Delgado - As previously mentioned, can you increase your length of stay and still make enough / have enough bookings?

What about renting the place by the room, like 5 bedrooms with each person paying you $1000/mo? I’ve rented to working professionals, “my relatives” on 6-12 mo leases and gotten much much more than the house could rent for by itself. (I offer 3 tiers mo-mo, 6 mo, 12 mo and have different prices for each.) In DC 3500 plus utils vs 2000-2500/mo

Where do you advertise? Do you run into problems with people sharing rooms? What is your occupancy rate? 

My father had wanted to do a senior care facility in my home because of its size but I’m not sure he can get it together while running his other business. Also would the city even permit it? They have crazy strict rules for simple things like garage sales. 

Originally posted by @Sean Walton:

Usually there is carve out for rentals of 20 days or 30days and longer. Since it is already furnished you could try setting that as your minimum. Not sure there are many traveling nurses or doctors looking for that large of a place but it may get you closer to cashflowing but I would probably sell and try and 1031 exchange into a new property or 2

 I have a friend with properties in Long Beach and she sets her min stay at 30 days and gets plenty of traveling nurses but all her properties are 1 bedrooms. For 5 bdrm it’s difficult long term to keep occupied. Thank you for reminding me of the 1031 exchange, I was concerned about capital gains. 

Originally posted by @Brianne H.:
I would also say sell. However you mentioned 2 of the rooms don't have closets, so it's technically a 3/2. If you could add closets in the other 2 rooms for a nominal cost, could it then be listed as a 5/2 and could you get more for it?

 Yes, I have contemplated adding closests. One of the rooms used to be a formal dining room and the other an office so it just depends on how the next family wants to use it. For Airbnb I had more use as bedrooms.

Originally posted by @Josh Dillingham:
sounds like a no brainer to me. even if you could refi, spending $6k up front with a $200 monthly reduction in mortgage it would take you nearly 2 1/2 years to break even on the refi and on top of that you would still be negative cash flow once you consider repairs capex, ect.

all that being said it sounds like you are still in a good position considering you could sell and have a nice pay day to reinvest.

don't think twice, sell.

and when it comes looking for another air bnb just remember you could be going through this all over again in a couple years when the new city you buy in shuts down air bnb as well. make sure the next place you buy will cash flow as a long term rental as well as a short term rental that way you won't find yourself in this bind again.

 Yes, good point to make sure the next one cash flows as a long term rental just in case. Thank you for your input!

Originally posted by @Sam White:

Don't you love massive government intervention.

It’s the hotels mainly the Hilton and Marriott. They are paying off senators and city council members to pass laws to eliminate short term rentals and not just in California because they know they can’t compete with Airbnb. The New York Times did a spread on it. 

Yes, I was trying to consolidate both loans into one since the second is adjustable.

So I purchased my first home as an investment short term rental near Disneyland in Anaheim CA. I've owned the property for 2 years and now the city has changed the laws and no longer allows short term rentals. The neighbors contacted the city, the city has sent me fines and gave me a notice to shut off my utilities (since they are city controlled). So I cancelled my bookings and now I am left with a negative cash flow situation. I tried to refinance and can't because there were complications and I was not approved.

I might be able to go to a friend and he said he would push a refi for $6k closing costs. That seems high but he knows I'm in a bind. 

Without refinancing these are my expenses. T market rate to rent my home seems to be $2,995

1st Mortgage- $2,646.29

2nd Mortgage adjustable- $287.95 = $2,934.24

Property tax- paid from mortgage

Supplemental Tax- $1,289.36 / 12= $107 per month

Insurance- $560.08 for the year / PAID FROM MORTGAGE

gardening- $60

= $3,101.24

Notice this is not even including repairs and the roof will need to be replaced soon. The A/C might need repairs as well. 

If I am able to refi it would reduce my total expenses by $200 a month to $2,900.00.  Also the 2nd mortgage on my home is at an adjustable rate and if I pay $287 per month I am making interest only payments. 

Before when it was an Airbnb I was making plenty of money and had money to send extra to the 2nd to pay it off early, now I am in a bind. 

Also renters don't seem to like the unit, even though it is very large at 2,400 sq. ft, 2 of the rooms don't have closets so it's technically a 3 bedroom/2 bath. There isn't a driveaway for parking outside the garage and there is a train that goes right by the house on a busy street plus the school district nearby isn't good.  I've lost some months rent looking for a tenant until I've dropped my price to $2,995. Even at this price I'm getting problem people applying for example I found one person who had recently purchased a bunch of grow room supplies and one person who wanted to use it as a daycare. 

The house gets good appreciation at 5% per year. Plus with Disneyland adding Star Wars land in 2 years I'm wondering if the home value will go up even more? 

Selling fees are about 7%. Could sell anywhere between $620-$650 and I only owe $450 on the property.

I am really torn between renting vs. selling. I could use this money to buy in an area that allows Airbnb and make more $. Also I'm currently living with family and do not have my own home as I'm young and still and don't have a need for my own place.

What do you guys think? Rent or Sell?