@Amy Haas - your experience is not too unusual here and underscores the importance of having a good realtor AND a good inspector. You can often find a big difference when the home is self-managed versus with a legacy area PM - in my experience. Self-managed homes are usually better but that is not written in stone.
@Ryan Lauretta - with higher prices, I would adjust that 2% monthly gross downwards a bit; perhaps to 1.5%. But that depends on the property (type, location, condition, size, etc.). As for time, you will spend some time getting setup, but if you use a mgmt platform (e.g. iGMS, OwnerRez, others) you can automate a lot of the process. Add a good cleaner and a handyman to that and it can be even better. Taxes are not difficult, but using a service like Avalera for $20/property per month can take that off your plate as well. As for realistically buying, it happens all the time so the answer is a resounding YES -- if you have a good agent.
@Patricia Watson - Julie McCoy is correct, but there are exceptions. Condos in certain areas here can return better than homes, especially if they have indoor pools in the complex. HOA or PUD fees here are becoming more common as new developments and resorts come online, so they are an issue regardless. BUT...be sure to research the HOA of any condo/home as many were not run properly for a long time and have had financial and legal issues that may not be resolved yet. HOA/PUDs around during the 2016 fires may also be artificially high due to special assessments from fire damage be sure to check that as well. A good realtor should be able to help with that, but Google can also be your friend. Ultimately, it is your responsibility as buyer to perform due diligence on the property and anything connected (HOA, PUD, etc.). Last thing, some condos, and even some cabin resorts, REQUIRE that you use their rental services and you cannot rent on your own. Be wary of that.
@Jeremy Guidry - For insurance, try contacting Tony Watts at Birchfeld Overlay in Sevierville. He is widely considered by locals to be "the man". During the 2016 fires, he had hundreds of buildings that were damaged and knows which companies stepped up and which ones gave owners a hard time. Foremost is the biggest underwriter in the area, but more rurally located homes may need a different carrier. Farmers is once again writing policies here (they pulled out after the fires) and supposedly have good rates. As for taxes, lots of people use Avalera, but I don't get it myself. Its not that complicated and I have always done my own for 4+ properties. There is a monthly submission to TN for sales taxes (later can change to quarterly if desired and TN approves), and a local submission for lodging taxes. In general, you only need 2 numbers for each property - Gross (rent + required fees) and AirBNB rent+fees. For sales tax you enter the Gross, then enter the AirBNB # as an exemption and TNTAP tells you your tax owed. On local lodging tax, you just report Gross. (Being in city limits adds a little depending on which city). Note: Sevierville is also a city, as well as a general postal "area".
@Jeff Piscioniere In talks with other local owners, trend to AirBNB and away from Vrbo seems to be across the board for the last 6-8 months. Not sure why, but AirBNB does a lot more advertising. of course, direct booking is the holy grail as you get to keep more $$ and stay in control of how you handle your property. AirBNB has become very "bossy" and threatening in the last few months, adding new requirements and penalizing search placement if you don't comply. Meanwhile, Vrbo is terrible. Site is incredibly slow, customer service for owners and guests is bad, booking fees are high.