Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Henry Clark

Henry Clark has started 209 posts and replied 4079 times.

Post: What’s an asset that grows 12% a year ?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Erik Henneman

Cash on Cash= $1,100,000 / $30,000= 3,667% return in 6 months. In a year, lets call it 7,200% COC return. This doesn't include the actual operational revenue, just the asset appreciation in 6 months.

Do you have $30,000 in cash or collateral? Do you live anywhere near Roanoke, VA?

See the post I did for @Nicolai Grebencio.

Now, its truly not this easy.  We have done a lot of analysis and are on our 8th location and have ran a ton of analyses to build or buy.  Plus made a ton of mistakes and learned a lot.  At some point we got to where we could "SEE" a deal.

Start small and Make Your Big Mistakes Early.

Post: Should I Consider Self Storage Being New to Real Estate?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Nicolai Grebencio

Says you have an IT background.  I'm an ex auditor.  Probably have flowcharted 40 different company's systems.  Payroll, AR, AP, Sales, cost, etc.  I understand Linear or process oriented thinking.  Critical thinking.

If you were ever hesitant about picking a Real Estate investment to get into due to your background, it should not be Self Storage. There are some nuances, but basically the financing, management, site/location selection, cost, offer price are all Linear and process oriented. SFH/MFH, you can say the same thing, but there is a lot more to learn, nuances, grey judgment areas, interpersonal skillsets required, hidden issues, etc. On a level of learning and risk; Storage is a 2 and SFH/MFH is a 10. Both in getting into the unit and the follow up management.

Your real lucky.

Look on Loopnet self storage Virginia.  There is a "DOG" of a property for sale in Roanoke.  Personally I love the place from what I can see.  Their asking $435,000; you offer $250,000.  Cleaned up this location is worth about $600,000 from a cost standpoint, from a revenue standpoint at 90% occupancy about $1,100,000.  You will probably need to put in about $50,000 into paint, replace some doors, electric, security system, general cleanup.  Lot of clean up, but what makes this property a winner, is it is in a great location relative to customers and geographically; low competition.  Also your entry point is relatively low for Storage and your potential LOSS is relatively low.  SBA loan at 10% down, would be $300,000 x 10% equals $30,000 down.  Low entry point.  Even if the buy in is higher, it still works.

Its not on sparefoot, thus not marketed.

Its in the middle of a Storage desert, in the middle of neighborhoods.

With this location you will learn about 90% of what you need to know about storage. From there, if you have a greater appetite; Self storage is a cookie cutter business. Very easy to replicate. Its actually more of a Financial investment, than a true REI as noted above.

It is better with experience.  You could get a part time job with a storage location helping to cover nights, days or weekends.

I can't attach excel files on Bigger Pockets, but below are some checklists.  Basically a process list.

Way at the bottom for some reason is a cost analysis worksheet.



Storage Startup Checklist 101


Response to Zagreb, Croatia startup
1 Why Do Storage?

2
Why Storage? Why you? I’ll do a separate Topic. Don’t know your financial’s, but you will outstrip your collateralization fast. Develop a relationship with someone you trust and bring them along for the ride. Preferably an Apartment developer. They don’t have to invest in the first project, but you will need them later. Make sure this a solid relationship, otherwise they will cut you out once your successful.
3 Market/Demand:

4
Market size See post, if your the “first”, then you don’t care. You have more than enough Market, in a 800,000 Pop city.
5
Outside or climate controlled? Let your search and “deal” decide. Look for both an outside Land acquisition or an old industrial building. If you get a large enough building, finish it out in stages.
6
Market location Seek your higher income areas first. Pick along the A2, A3, A4 corridors first. Stay away from the mountains. Do several small locations, no smaller than 1 hectare. Once you have the experience and Financial support, go for a Climate controlled location in an old neighborhood that is high income or rebuilding itself.
7
Zoning See post
8
Site location Have several searches and deals going at once, most of them won’t pan out for the price you are willing to pay. This way you “can walk away”. This gives you negotiating power.
9
Site acquisition
10 Financing:
See “Topic”
11
Financing-construction Find a banker who knows Apartment building construction
12
Financing- rent up stage Same as above. You want “interest only” and not principal for a portion of the rent up period.
13
Financing- long-term If your going to grow, unless you have significant capital at your disposal, find a future business partner.
14
Business Model I’ll clean up and post one of my spreadsheets later.
15 Construction:
Use local knowledge/availability
16
Permits
17
Building type
18
Building manufacturer
19
Contractor
20 Day to day:

21
Rental Contract Post a “Topic” on this Forum and ask for some copies sent to you.
22
Rental Rates Zagreb’s GDP per capita is $19,132 versus where I live $60,246 metro area of 1mm. Thus if I say a 10 x 20 “Foot, not meter” unit is $120, then yours would be around $40. Making this simplistic. Get on Sparefoot and pick a US city similar to Zagreb and pick out prices for 10 x 20/15/10/5. Then take 1/3 of that for your price in US $, then convert. Recommend you don’t use this as your starting prices; go after a richer neighborhood and charge higher prices.
23
Auction rules Post a “Topic” on this Forum and ask for some copies sent to you.
24
Security system Situational, work with your local security firm.
25
Fencing situational
26
Self Service or manager situational
27
Management software Since the world is internet based, see if you can use one of the Storage management softwares in Zagreb. Do not do this on a spreadsheet or paper. You need to develop a system to grow with.
28 Marketing:

29
Website check ClarkstorageLLC, and others on this forum. Take the best from each and make a template, for a better one.
30
SEO management Since your the only one, you just need Google Map Pins and build up your google ranking under key words.
31
Marketing Software Sparefoot or similar in your market area. If none exist for Storage, seek out Apartment, home, AIRBNB, Craigslist sites. If you have Craigslist, put an add out there with your offering and price. Different sizes and prices. Get feedback.
32
Marketing Something you probably already know.
33
Social Media Something you probably already know.
34 Insurance:
Leave to you for local knowledge
35
Business
36
Renters

Sundry:
Leave to you for local knowledge


Property taxes


Legal system

Way at the bottom for some reason is a cost analysis checklist.





























































































































































































































































































































































































































































This is an example, for discussion only.














A. Project Cost estimate from ground up.






B. P/L revenue stream






C. Valuation Buy/Sell






Adjust all of the above to your local market and situation.















A. Self Storage Project Worksheet






Drive up Storage
















Notes:



Land $200,000
4 acres at $50,000/acre



Survey $7,000
Site, elevation and building layout



Fence $30,000
Black chainlink



Gate system $25,000
Automated rolling 20ft



Engineer

if needed; $30,000 to $60,000



Dirt work $15,000
Slight roll, no dirt brought on site



Building demo

if needed, $15,000 to $60,000



Electrical- site $7,000
building lighting and office if needed, LED.



Electric poles

if needed; $2,000 per pole. First is free if nearby.



Security $10,000





Storm drains

if needed; $50,000 to $150,000



Water

if needed; $5,000 just plumbing



Water line

?? if an extension could be $10,000 up to $150,000



Fire Hydrant

if needed, $3,000



Sewer

if needed: $5,000 plumbing



Sewer Line

if needed; $10,000 up to ????











Buildings $1,180,800
Phase 1 2 acres



Office

if needed, plain storage unit 20x30; $25,000 insulated.



Office setup

if needed, $5,000- computers, printers, HVAC, frig, cabinets, etc



Footings

if needed. ??????



Roads






Gravel

if needed, ?????



Asphalt

if needed, ?????



Concrete $676,133
6 inch Cubic yards, framed, poured, sawn,



Retention Pond

if needed, part of dirt work cost, less land for buildings



Landscaping $5,000
I like trees and bushes. Less sterile



Road Sign $15,000
For highway 55mph billboard sign



























Total $2,170,933





































































































































































































































































































































































































































































This is an example, for discussion only.














A. Project Cost estimate from ground up.






B. P/L revenue stream






C. Valuation Buy/Sell






Adjust all of the above to your local market and situation.















A. Self Storage Project Worksheet






Drive up Storage
















Notes:



Land $200,000
4 acres at $50,000/acre



Survey $7,000
Site, elevation and building layout



Fence $30,000
Black chainlink



Gate system $25,000
Automated rolling 20ft



Engineer

if needed; $30,000 to $60,000



Dirt work $15,000
Slight roll, no dirt brought on site



Building demo

if needed, $15,000 to $60,000



Electrical- site $7,000
building lighting and office if needed, LED.



Electric poles

if needed; $2,000 per pole. First is free if nearby.



Security $10,000





Storm drains

if needed; $50,000 to $150,000



Water

if needed; $5,000 just plumbing



Water line

?? if an extension could be $10,000 up to $150,000



Fire Hydrant

if needed, $3,000



Sewer

if needed: $5,000 plumbing



Sewer Line

if needed; $10,000 up to ????











Buildings $1,180,800
Phase 1 2 acres



Office

if needed, plain storage unit 20x30; $25,000 insulated.



Office setup

if needed, $5,000- computers, printers, HVAC, frig, cabinets, etc



Footings

if needed. ??????



Roads






Gravel

if needed, ?????



Asphalt

if needed, ?????



Concrete $676,133
6 inch Cubic yards, framed, poured, sawn,



Retention Pond

if needed, part of dirt work cost, less land for buildings



Landscaping $5,000
I like trees and bushes. Less sterile



Road Sign $15,000
For highway 55mph billboard sign



























Total $2,170,933








Post: What’s an asset that grows 12% a year ?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Erik Henneman

Hello from a former fellow CPA.  As you know you can make the same number look good or bad, its just a matter of perspective.

To help narrow down the above great inputs, if you could give us your perspective:

a.  Why do you want 12% in todays economy?  Beyond the obvious, its big.  What is your personal/financial objective?  More importantly how much risk are you willing to take on?

b.  What is the magnitude of both financial and sweat equity investment you want to invest? $xx,xxx

c.  How much are you willing to lose?  $xx,xxx

Example of returns and risk:

1.  We bought 8 acres for $200,000 ("off market" about to be on market the next day at the realtors office and he said hey, take a look at); not in the best location.  Bought it in one hour after looking.  Took a chainsaw in the middle of the winter and started clearing trees on 3 acres.  Rented a skid steer and mulcher to clear trees.  Hired some bulldozer work.  Put a free firewood sign out front.  Two years later per the appraisal, its worth $100,000 per acre.  No it didn't cost $200,000.  Lot of sweat equity and about another $20,000 in clearing costs.  But what is the return over a two year period?  Loss potential- $50,000

2.  On that same property we did Self Storage.  Used the equity above in a 10% SBA loan.  Built a $1.6mm location.  Appraisal came in at $2.4mm just for the storage on two of the acres, two years later at 30% occupancy.  Still in the rent up phase.  What is the return?  Loss potential $400,000.

3.  Everyone has this same story, just a different version.  Bought 48 acres for $485/acre in 1993.  Subdividing and selling for $40,000 per acre today.  Was that planned, no.  Partially yes, but not to those levels.  Loss potential- $0; its where we live; just don't need that many acres anymore.  We bought this location both to live, but also I could see the value of the location increasing over time.

1 and 3 above, if it was a business, you have to keep replicating.  These don't happen and come along everyday.  Plus you have to be able to "see" them and act on them

Item 2, we have $200,000 cash in.  Once 90% occupancy we will be cash flowing about $200,000 per year.  On a 20 year term amortization; although we will probably try to pay off in 10 years.  So during that time "we" don't get any cash, but we build $200,000 equity every year.  On an original $200,000 investment.  Not counting what we plan to do with the other 6 acres.  This is a planned investment.  This is our 7th location out of our final 8th buildout/purchase.  So it didn't just magically happen.  A lot of errors and mistakes along the way.

Start small and Make Your Big Mistakes Early.

If you can answer A, B, C above, the above group can get you into a 12% return. 

It could be a $20,000 trailer that you put $2,000 rehab into, and rent out for $800 per month, net of the lot fee of $500 for $300.  What return is that?

Or, a $3,100 cargo container; that you rent out for $90 per month on rented ground of $30 per month.  Net $60 or $720/year on $3,100.  What return is that?

The above scenarios are in my world.  The people above have tons of other options, with varying risk factors.

Literally while typing this post, my realtor just called and we have an offer of $87,500 on one of our 2 acre $100,000 listed lots.  Its all about putting your efforts into "forward" motion.

Post: How Did You Learn How To Analyze Properties?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Carlos Ptriawan

This is for Florida.  Google  Daycares4sale.com  There are other websites doing this.  Most of these are selling the business and not the real estate, but contact the real estate owner.

There are other ones out there.  Also look up schools for sale.  You can buy these cheap and make MFH.

Post: How Did You Learn How To Analyze Properties?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Jorge Ydlibi

Since you are starting out and are not tied to a specific type of investment.  

Look at Daycares.  This industry has gotten clobbered.  Lot of people still staying home with kids.  Shots are still a ways out.

No, don't get into the day care business.

No, don't rent to day cares.

See if you can find a building for sale that was a daycare and then do value add.

See if you can find a daycare business for sale, that the building is being leased.  Contact the building owner to buy.  They are probably hurting for a tenant, but you buy the building.  Knock on 25 doors and someone is going to sale to you.

Everyone else is looking for SFH or MFH. Go to a different market and value add back into MFH.

Post: How Did You Learn How To Analyze Properties?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Jorge Ydlibi

Our background is self storage but I will apply what we have learned.

1.  Everything everyone has said.  But lets move on to an analysis.  You need to join a group or get with an experienced person to go over your analysis.

2.  As mentioned above start your own spreadsheet.  Once you have done that, then look at the calculators and others. Go check out 2 or 3 locations and improve your spreadsheet.  As to do a ride along with an experienced investor and then afterwards ask what they saw.

3.  Go to loopnet miami apartments.  Pick 439 NW 59th ter.

4.  Picked a "clean" project.  Something easy for you.  No apparent major repairs.  Figure out if or if not, value add can occur.

5.  Start an excel list and list every component of a house or apartment.  Roof, floors, sub floor, walls, stairs, attic, fire exits, kitchens, sinks, bathrooms, laundry, HVAC, fireplaces, pools, garages, parking, landscape, mold, water damage, Sewer, water lines, flood plain, flood insurance, insurance, ADA, etc.  Put into groupings.  As you analyze a property save it.  Keep each property you analyze as a separate file and keep improving your list and spreadsheet.

6.  Read the Executive Summary.  Something is wrong with this property.  Non permitted wall.  You just learned something from them.  Add to your list, Permits?  Walls, stairways, parking, etc.

7. For your first deals start non complex. Not big money makers. Become a specialist in Landscaping and bathrooms. Or Kitchens. Don't do any huge BRRRR's. You want to get started and not get clobbered. You might become the Pet pee stain expert or drug house specialist. Then start to branch out to harder fixes.

8.  Look for the value add items that aren't being discussed, that are of value to you.  Example:  2,730 sq ft unit on a 11,000 sq ft lot.  Can you add more parking.  Can you add more attached units?  Close to bus terminal or highway?  etc.

9.  Love the Steel front door.  Either easy fix, or a selling point.  Check the neighborhood out and adjust to it.  If rough neighborhood add security cameras and barred windows as selling point.  Put a visually enclosed fence so they can let their pit bulls run in.  Key point, is look for value add items.

10.  This looks like a clean unit, so there isn't much "meat" left on the bone for you.  Check out added value. 

11.  7% sales commission.  If you go to flip, how do you avoid this, or build into your checklist.

12.  Determine your financial metrics.

13.  Determine your financing capabilities.  What dollar figure is your asset category.  No point wasting time on assets that don't fit your numbers.

You can learn a lot of things, but you will forget them, even if your experienced.  Keep adding to your checklist.

Do about 10 of these on your own and keep building your list.  Then either join a group or find an experienced investor in your same category to go over things with.  You need to add value to that person.  Don't ask for free advice from them.

Post: Getting Hammered on Property Taxes

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

@Jake Dotson

An option for the future is to add in a "Non compete" agreement.  Move more dollars away from the unit.  Plus the "Non compete" can be amortized or expensed quicker than the building.

Post: Can someone give me some ideas about how to find a good deal?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

Define what is a good deal to you?  Also how often and how fast are you wanting to find those deals? 

If this is your first deal, don't look for a "Good" deal.  Just do a deal with low risk to get started.  It will be a great investment in learning.

We only do Self Storage, thus the following are worthless to us.  But the point is, there are deals out there.  All of these come from my network.

Off market, do you want a house in probate?  One sitting right next to my office.

Off market, do you want a 60 room motel?

How about 50 to 60 SFH/MFH over the next 5 years or sooner as two old guys 85, start to reduce their holdings? How do you find those two old guys? Look on your cities GIS map. Start looking at the type of properties you like. When you find one, look down at the bottom and see "related" properties. Look for someone that has a bunch of related properties and call them. Give them a solution. How do they start to wind down if they are 80?

Is there snow on the ground where you live?

Drive around and see which houses didn't clean up the snow in their driveways.  Make a list and start hammering them.

Look for "Coal" and make diamonds. Look for MLS or Commercial/Industrial property that are dogs and have been on the market a long time. Value add them.

Post: When is it ok to buy a depreciating asset?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

Go rent a similar car for a week or month.  Don't worry about the car itself, but see how you feel or appreciate it.  Have a Toyota Corolla with 360,000 miles, with dents on three sides, for my day car.  We rent a nice vehicle whenever we have a trip.  Then decide to buy or not.

I could say don't do it, but hey.  My son and I rebuilt my wife's family's original farm truck.  It mainly sits.  Cost a lot to rebuild.  But its a lot of fun and worth it.

Post: RV Park Analysis: Good or bad deal?

Henry Clark
#1 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
Posted
  • Developer
  • Posts 4,155
  • Votes 4,129

Also there is a big gap between the rental income and the NOI. Audit the Rental income hard. Look at what the operating costs are, should not be $60,000. If this includes Depreciation, back it out of your cash flow calculations. Something is off. Just audit the numbers.

Biggest numbers should be.  Management- you said zero.  Property Tax should be little ???,  Mowing, Electric, Water, Insurance, etc.