@Jennifer Walsh
(Hi Jennifer, please give us the best deal that you saw, where the numbers still didn’t work and see what we come up with...) But with that said...
I agree w/ Marcus Auerbach, the most important thing is to get started. I bought a primary residence and turned it into a rental after about 8 years of living in it.
As a rental, it was a terrible deal. PITI $350 and the rent collected used to be $300/mo, but now it's $450/mo. So once you add in the expenses that I have incurred for maintenance, that $1200/yr potential profit is always gone or nowhere near the $1200.
But... through owning it for 17 years, I’ve built up a significant amount of equity (maybe around $20k-$30k. So now that I know my niche, my target areas, my numbers and my overall goals, I can now sell that property and 1031 into something that takes that negative-to -$100 cash flow every month up to $500/mo positive cash flow on a higher value property closer to the city of Atlanta.
You should never buy a bad deal on purpose, but with that said, don't be afraid to buy something and learn how to manage it and see how to landlord. As you can see, that rental was a terrible cash flow deal, but the tenants paid down the debt for years and now I can cash that in with the new knowledge that I have and I actually feel blessed for keeping that property so long. So even a bad cash flow deal has a silver lining if you have enough cash from somewhere else in order to weather the storms that will occur (I only had a $350 mortgage which was easy to maintain with or without a tenant-if you are going to take on PITI of $800 or more, you may want to really consider wether or not you would be able to withstand 6 months of no rent for whatever reason).
Other ways to think about are
1. Go to real estate meet ups and see what and why other landlords are paying what they are paying and where they are buying (emulate other successful landlords even though they may have a different strategy because they are in later stages of investing-you still probably will be better off following the smart money)
2. Consider duplexes where the PITI is paid by one side and the other side has the maintenance, and profit (or triplexes or quads)
3. Consider higher cash flow markets within driving distance (1 hour at most-you can be an out-of-state investor with property management in place if you want, but if I were you, I would manage the first one myself just so I could see what the property manager is getting paid to do).
4. Always remember, the higher the cash flow, the lower class the property probably is, so look for that happy medium of a working class stable neighborhood
I hope this helps. Be blessed. You’re on the right track with real estate, so just keep moving forward and one day it will all make sense (and there’s still plenty I don’t know-but it still makes sense to buy).