@Mark Updegraff Sure! When I was managing the property myself I had no issues. 5.5 hours away, and I was still able to manage the property with no issues. However, the real estate agent that helped me purchase the property said that she could take over the management, and I trusted her. That was my bib mistake. She put bad tenants into my property. The area wasn't really that bad. In fact the address was 153 Norton St. which is near Irondequoit.
I would tell her not to accept a tenant unless they had 1 months rent and the security deposit, but she took whatever they had to offer. Then DSS screwed me! The tenants would lose their benefits, and I would not get any notice. I eventually receive a letter stating that they didn't need to inform landlords when benefits changed, i.e. if the tenant needed to pay a part of the rent, or if they lost their benefits.
The next thing I knew, all my tenants lost their benefits, and I was stuck with a non-performing property. Now, I will say this... I do know plenty of investors in Rochester that had no issues. However, the real estate agent I hired to manage the property jumped in an made things worse. She put a tenant into the property with no security deposit and that tenant abandoned the property and allowed drug dealers to move in. Then, when I told her I wanted to dump the property, she found other investors and put the property under contract, by forging my name, and took all their deposits. But wait, it gets worse!
I had a burnout property I was going to rehab and she took 10k of my money and never got the contractors involved with the project. A couple of them called me to find out if I was still going ahead with the project. Then she took all the deposit money, kidnapped her kids and ran away to Houston TX. Meanwhile, all the investors who she took deposits from started contacting me to find out why I wasn't selling my property to them and started demanding that I return their deposits.
I finally had to dump both properties. I ended up coming out of pocket 23k, and with all the other expenses I lost over 50k. Talk about the school of hard knocks!
This was my first step into real estate investing and that was back in 2004. I finally sold both properties in 2008, and I have been recovering ever since. Now here is the kicker! Around the time I got out of Rochester, they started to revitalize the area. Rochester never experienced a real estate crash and had remained pretty consistent in sales and vacancy rate. No boom, no bust! So, one would think that it was the perfect place to invest. But I just ran into the wrong person, and later found out that she didn't even have a real estate license.
Sorry for the long rant, but to make a long story short, this was the worst experience I encountered and it was the best experience I encountered. Now I mentor new investors to not make the mistakes I made. Way worth it.
I will conclude by saying this. The agent who helped me sell my properties told me not to let that experience discourage me, and that real estate was a great vehicle to invest in. I let those words sink deep down and built up my cash and jumped back into investing. I could write a book on the things I learned. And honestly, I would invest in Rochester again, but Atlanta seemed to be a better value.