All Forum Posts by: Moe Sidd
Moe Sidd has started 1 posts and replied 85 times.
Post: Choosing a market

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
Quote from @William Breymann:
Hey all, looking for thoughts as I hone in on a market. I had basically settled on Ohio and was between Columbus and Cleveland, but also looking at Dayton. I had connected with a couple RE agents through bigger pockets and they were sending me deals which looked great compared to my home market in Western MA. After I started digging into crime stats and school ratings and looking at street views they didn't look so great though.
We were just in Saratoga, NY and walked a beautiful house that we were talking about partnering on with a family member. It turned out they aren't serious and I'm not ready to take on the risk and work required to manage a hybrid STR/MTR that I believe it would take to make it viable, and also don't want to put the majority of our HELOC into one property. Anyway, I've started looking at spots that actually get me excited. For me this isn't large cities and bars and nightlife but lakes, mountains and beaches and outdoor destinations. Around me in the Northeast, I've been looking in Warwick, RI, Burke, VT, and upstate NY, particularly Saratoga and Lake George areas. All small markets and expensive. Not cash flowing with my financing unless you STR or MTR.
I'm currently considering targeting more affordable metro areas but looking at areas close to parks or natural attractions but also hosptials to open up the option for STR but more so MTR to traveling healthcare folks. I work in healthcare and have met and know many travelers. Currently looking at areas outside of Raleigh, NC (have a family member close) and have moved back to Cleveland as it has Lake Erie which I like.
Anyway, long story just to ask your thoughts on whether I'm thinking too much about the locations and whether I like them vs if they make financial sense. Have had people tell me I won't be spending time there and it doesn't matter which I know is true. On the other hand having a place that we could potentially visit if there were vacancies or could make into a vacation while checking in on it makes sense too. Appreciate any thoughts and curious how you settled on your market, especially if it was out of state
From my experience, the people in the market matter a lot more than the city itself — your tenants, contractors, realtors, and property managers will make or break your success. Focus on building a solid team first, then dive into neighborhoods and numbers once you’ve got reliable boots on the ground.
If you ever want to chat about how that plays out in different markets like Toledo, Detroit, or Dallas, happy to share what’s worked for me and my investors and what to look out for.
Post: Investing in a property in Mexico

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
Quote from @Amy Karony:
Quote from @Moe Sidd:
@Amy Karony, I ran the numbers myself looking into STRs in Cancun, Playa Del Carmen, Tulum, etc. and found I could get better cash flow returns in the Midwest long-term SFH investments. In Mexico, there are luxury properties that you'd want to target, with high vacancy, and the property managers will eat most of your profits. Not to mention how much easier it would be to manage a LTR vs STR property manager.
Happy to chat more about various out-of-state investing strategies that have worked very well for me over the years!
Thank you for your input. We currently live and invest in the Midwest and are looking at Mexico as a sort of vacation destination/investment for our family.
I know it would be less hassle to invest near home and although it may be true that profit margins are higher as well, that is not our only priority. We are, however, looking to maximize profit margins in Mexico, wherever that ends up being. Ideally the place we choose just doesn't lose money - it can pay for itself, and also provide us a fun escape as a family once or twice a year.
Totally get what you mean. Every time i'm vacationing i'm just thinking should I just move/buy there. Let us know how it goes if you choose a spot!
Post: Investing in a property in Mexico

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
@Amy Karony, I ran the numbers myself looking into STRs in Cancun, Playa Del Carmen, Tulum, etc. and found I could get better cash flow returns in the Midwest long-term SFH investments. In Mexico, there are luxury properties that you'd want to target, with high vacancy, and the property managers will eat most of your profits. Not to mention how much easier it would be to manage a LTR vs STR property manager.
Happy to chat more about various out-of-state investing strategies that have worked very well for me over the years!
Post: Has Anyone Achieved Significant Success Investing Hundreds or Thousands of Miles Away

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
I’ve learned a lot over the years from both successes and mistakes with out-of-state investing. It definitely comes with challenges, but with the right team and systems in place, it can work really well. It really boils down to where you can find the best people (and numbers) to work with. The location you choose should have a solid tenant base, reputable realtors, experienced property managers, and reliable contractors. This can make or break your investment, so please dont look at numbers alone.
Happy to share specifics if you’re interested in markets like Toledo, Detroit, or Dallas, those are areas I’ve had solid experience in and can break down what’s worked (and what hasn’t).
Post: Investing in duplexes and fourplexes, worth it?

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
@Jakub R., I started with SFH and still exclusively deal with SFH. Often, the numbers are better in SFH deals than in Multi-Family. For example, I often see duplexes listed for more than 2 SFH would cost combined! But this may be just in the markets I deal with, so your mileage may vary based on which states/cities you're looking into? I have heard many apartment complex owners liquidate and go all in SFH because the numbers were better. Many people get caught up in the notion that more is better when it comes to multi-family housing, as it sounds so appealing.
Looking back, I think I'd do it the same way, especially starting out. Even with several years under my belt, I feel multi-family can make things more complicated, and I like keeping things simple and less risky. Having your wealth spread across multiple properties is a form of diversification. My suggestion is doing what's less popular might actually win the race over time, so don't fall into the hype.
Post: Purchasing from Property Management

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
Quote from @Jeanette Land:
Is it ever a good idea to purchase a rental property from the property management company that you are using?
Hi @Jeanette Land, it could be a great opportunity if they are already managing the property, given that they already know the ins and outs, and it would be a seamless transition for everyone involved. Often, their investors may be selling or downsizing their portfolios, so they help facilitate the sale. I'd still conduct the same due diligence that you would when buying any property on the market.
Post: Looking to start a new journey of real estate investing

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
Quote from @Jordan Swift:
Thank you all for the welcome and replies. I def, want to gain as much knowledge from you all as possible. My goal is to hopefully obtain my first property within 12 months time. Yes, having 2 universities close are a plus, but they are private Christian colleges. There is another much larger state university within 30 minutes from me. However, I went there and know what happens to those rentals! LOL. What are the best resources to see rental data? I know of some like AirDNA, beyond pricing, zillow, etc. Again, thanks and look forward to learning from you all.
I usually just use Zillow or Apartments.com, keeping in mind there are a lot of landlords who put higher prices out there for rentals, so I would use those numbers conservatively.
Post: Reality check - investing out of state

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
@Mark Bennett totally agree! It's almost like they wanna scam us as soon as they find out we are out-of-state. It's definitely a people business and while there will be many bad apples out there my goal is to find the few good ones and work with them exclusively!
Post: New to Real Estate

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
@Marco Solis, what do you think this property would rent for given the market rents currently?
Post: Real Estate Investor Looking to Grow Knowledge

- Investor
- Toledo-Detroit-Dallas
- Posts 87
- Votes 46
Welcome back! With your experience, you’re in a great spot to take real estate full-time. If you want income you can manage from anywhere, look at turnkey rentals in strong Midwest markets, ones that are already renovated, rented, and managed. It’s an easy way to start building cash flow while scaling without getting stuck in day-to-day management.
Happy to share some examples or run through how out-of-state investing works for me and my investors if you’re interested.