Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Crystal Smith

Crystal Smith has started 65 posts and replied 2754 times.

Post: wholesaling and Realtors

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Wesley Tripp:

I have found someone interested in selling their house using wholesaling but they have already started talking to a realtor.  I would like to work with the realtor to get the job done but previously realtors have ask me how they will be paid. What would be the best option to make sure realtors will be paid in a wholesale transaction (listing or buying agents)? Thank you.


You get the property under contract direct with the seller. Make sure your contract provides you with permission to market the property, which includes marketing on the MLS. You sign a contract with the realtor to market the property at a price higher than what you have committed to the seller. You then have to decide if you want to assign your contractor to the new buyer or double close. The realtor gets paid commission from the sale. The seller gets paid what you committed to on your sales contract. You get paid the difference.

Post: Need assistance with landlord I'm leasing an arbitrage property from in Glen Ellyn, I

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Tara Sonnabend:

My company leases a property from a private landlord in Glen Ellyn, with permission to sublease. A leak from the wax ring of the toilet was recently discovered and reported. I notified the landlord immediately upon reporting by the tenant, on Saturday, May 25. I asked for it to be addressed as soon as possible, but the landlord stated she would hopefully attend to it the next week, that the damage was already done and it could not be attended to over a holiday weekend. A plumber was scheduled for a service call on May 31, but the call was rescheduled to June 1 due to an emergency call. Remediation arrived today and will put dehumidifiers in the space. After the space is dry, they explained that part of the floor in the bathroom will need to be replaced. Now I have to relocate the tenant, pay for hotel accommodations and the home is not habitable. 


The landlord stated she believes we are responsible for the leak because when we started the lease in November 2022, the leak was not present. She has stated that she will not file an insurance claim and instead expects my company to be responsible for the cost of repairs. I explained that this type of routine maintenance issue is not damage and is not our responsibility, but I can see that I will need help ensuring that she as the landlord is instead held responsible.

Any advice on an attorney/organization to talk to in order to get a letter from an attorney to get the landlord being reasonable or similar instead of turning this into an expensive legal battle?

Thanks in advance!


 My advice is not to hire an attorney but to modify your business practices. This means treating the property you leased as if it's your own.  You have a choice when doing an arbitrage to be responsible for little to nothing when it comes to maintenance and repairs or budget for maintenance and repairs as if it's your property (keeping your tenants satisfied).  I recommend changing your business practice and doing the latter.   It will cost you less to modify your business practices so this does not happen in the future than it will to hire an attorney and fight this.  That is if you can even get an attorney to take this on.  

Post: Private lender equity structure for flipping

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Tripp Wylie:

Me and two other partners are flipping houses locally and are using a local individual for the financing. We’ve done a few deals to prove things out and so far so good.

The structure has been we are loaned the money at 0% but the lender is getting a big chunk of equity. Deal #1: 70%, Deal # 2: 50%.

The lender is using a line of credit at 8%, so he does have interest expense, but not passing that on to us.

Really my question is, what’s a long term structure that makes sense for both sides?

Lending at 0% is great but is 50-70% too much equity per deal?

Is there a structure that makes more sense?

Should we offer preference and less equity?

Thanks!



Now that you have proved things out and have a track record you should be establishing other sources for your loans. In my opinion, you should have at least 3 potential lenders. With the other sources in place you may be able to negotiate a better deal with your current lender.  Don't start negotiating with your current lender until the others are in place.

Post: For those who invest remotely and scaled their business, how do you do it?

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Diana Tran:

@Crystal Smith Wow thank you, your response is very thorough and helpful indeed. When you first started, did you have a mentor/business advisor that help guide you through your journey? What helped you with decision making? We know how to run numbers and do as much research, but when it's in the scheme of things and dealing with real people, negotiating...it's high pressure and gets overwhelming especially since we're new to this world.


 I started my real estate career working for a large real estate developer in Chicago.  I watched and learned.  As I progressed I established multiple relationships with business people inside and outside of Real Estate.  I've never really categorized them as mentors but advisors.   I then partnered with someone and we complement each other. 

Post: First Flip - Trying to Avoid a Huge Mistake

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Shelby Van Horn:

Hi there,

My partner and I are trying to find our first flip.  Although I have been following and learning from BP for years, we are both brand new to this, and I think we may be about to pull the trigger on a mistake, and I was hoping to get advice here before I cancel our offer.

The property is in the 30349 area of Atlanta.  

It is a four bedroom, two bathroom, split level house needing approximately $20-30k of repairs.

The purchase price is $177,500.  We tried to get it for closer to $160, and the seller wouldn't budge more than ~ $2,500.

Our realtor sent comps and has been assuring us that relisting for a minimum of $250k is realistic and creates a good profit margin.  Our offer was accepted yesterday, and our five day due diligence is supposed to start tomorrow.

From what I have thoroughly studied on the comps, they do sell within a decent time frame and for much higher than the purchase price, although the majority of comps are slightly larger in sqft. (They are all selling in the $260-285k range).

I'm sitting here trying to learn and absorb everything, and working on the rehab budget.  While we plan on doing a lot of the work ourselves, we are realistic with our limits and will need to hire much of it out.  After using a couple of deal analysis tools, I feel sick to my stomach that this may be a big mistake.  

We are using a hard money loan at 9.9%.  After analyzing the deal further, estimating holding costs, realtor fees, monthly costs on hard money, estimating the worst case scenario of it taking three months to sell (average time here is 43 days), rehab costs, insurance, etc., I am pretty sure we need to pull out.  I feel stupid for not realizing this in the first place, because if I did the 70% rule correctly, we would have to be *negative* $2,500 in repair costs to make it fit.

Am I missing something here?  Is this somehow a good deal and I am messing up the numbers, or should we run?

Thank you.


Here's the deal.  Numbers do not lie.  If the numbers say you should pull out, then pull out or ask for a price reduction.  

Post: Advice on comps

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Conrad Legé:

Hello,

I am currently in my search for my first fix & flip. I have found & recently looked at a property that I feel has potential. I’ve been reading the BP book on Flipping Houses by J Scott as a guide. I recently had my broker run some comps for me however there are limited SOLD comps to work with however there a few strong comps that are currently “contingent.” Would like at least 3 solid comps to work with.

My question is, is it good practice to use comps that are contingent or pending or should I stick solely with comps that have SOLD? 

Thanks,


On one of our first fix and flips we had a great property in a great neighborhood in Orlando. The recently sold comparables supported the ARV we needed, but we did not pay attention to pending or contingent. (There were no pending/contingent) We completed the renovation, and put the property back on the market but the sold properties we used to justify the purchase were now too old. We set the price based on our original assumptions but the offers we received were all well below what we needed. So while you can't use contingent/pending comparables to determine what you can potentially sell your property for, you should pay attention to the data. The contingent/pending show that there's good market activity.

Post: Advice on where to start

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Miles Dirmann:

Hello, I just graduated college (in 3 yrs) with a finance degree and am finally ready to go all in on real estate investing. The thing is I don't quite know where to start especially in today's economy. I have read a number of bp books and have built up a solid amount of business knowledge especially in marketing as I have helped with a number of marketing oriented projects at my church. Also, I have about $8k in cash and no debt at all!  I'm going to start looking for a few meetups each week to go to and analyze properties daily.. I don't have a job at the moment aside for working at my church on the side. Any thoughts, suggestions, etc.?? Thanks all


 Get the W2 job. Continue to study and network with other investors.  Start building a list of local  lenders (private and traditional)  contractors, handymen, realtors, wholesalers,  syndicators,.....  with an objective of having your network in place when it's time to pull the trigger on a deal.  

Post: What are strategies you would recommend for someone starting out with limited funds?

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Sarah Ali:

Hello BP Pro!

I'm new to RE investing and have signed up for the bootcamp as well as classes at my local JC to learn as much as I can. One thing I've noticed is that of all the things needed to start out, money is definitely high on the list. 


Are there strategies or options you can recommend to someone like me, who is both just starting out and has limited funds (worst combo ever?)?   


 My recommendation if you are starting out with limited funds is while you are saving start networking with people in your local market. Find out who is doing deals, what kind of deals and what kind of deals they are involved with.  Do they do all their deals on their own or do they partner?  If they partner- how do they structure their partnership?  Your objective at this point is to learn, learn, learn and grow your network. No promises but what you may find yourself in a deal  with limited $ because you learned what your network is looking for or someone in your network allowed you to participate in a deal.  

Learning all you can now will then help you when you do not have limited funds.

Post: For those who invest remotely and scaled their business, how do you do it?

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Diana Tran:

@Crystal Smith Thank you for your thorough response. Can you elaborate a bit more on this part "Another part of our strategy is to invest with someone at a local level. which meant we became local through our partner...."?

Making sure I understand correctly on this other part. It sounds like first you meet your team in-person to create a relationship with them then you work with realtors to find property you would eventually put an offer in (unseen) then once you're under contract that's when you get the remaining team to check everything. At what point do you travel there? Is it when the inspection/records/finances are all in a good place...giving it a final look before closing?

Also, how do you find reliable realtors to work with? We worked with a few realtors and all were good in their own way however, there were some gaps. For example, the first realtor viewed the property for us but missed out major damages until I flew in myself and saw the property. The 2nd realtor doesn't have any investment background, didn't have advice on best rental property and the 3rd couldn't find any properties while the 1st realtor found plenty that matched our criteria. With that being said, we had a challenging time finding a realtor who specializes in investment and can be more detailed/open with us.

About the pre-inspection, we'll have to factor in the cost. But it's a bit less than full inspection. This was a suggestion by another investor. I guess this would another layer of protection before committing to a contract that will cost more money. I get what you're saying about timing though.



I"m going to do my best to answer all of your questions but before answering I need to provide you with some context. When my partner and I decide to go into a market and look for projects we are volume bidders.  We are usually looking for more than one project or it may be one big project. So our expectation of how we establish relationships and the roles of realtors, inspectors,....  may be different than yours.

Can you elaborate a bit more on this part "Another part of our strategy is to invest with someone at a local level. which meant we became local through our partner...."?- We rarely invest on our own. We establish partnerships to invest and we always look for someone locally to be part of the partnership.  That local partner can then become our eyes and ears who has skin in the game with us. (Note: It doesn't always work out finding a local partner but that is our objective)

At what point do you travel there? Is it when the inspection/records/finances are all in a good place...giving it a final look before closing? 
We rely on our local financial partner(s), realtor and/or GC for final walkthroughs to make sure the condition of the property has not changed. Since our business objective is multiple projects we do not travel to give a final look before closing

Also, how do you find reliable realtors to work with? - 
We look for realtors that already have a network of  architects, lawyers, GCS, handymen, property management, other investors... that they can refer either right on the phone or within 24 hours. Our other expectation of realtors is to be able to quickly run numbers and make lots of offers.  We do not expect realtors to walk or view properties unless it's an off market property and there are no pictures.  If we have a local financial partner we'll ask the partner to go walk an off-market property, not the realtor.   Or we may ask a GC to walk/view a property. If we ask the realtor tor a GC o walk a property we pay them.  You've heard the saying- "You get what you pay for"  If you are asking them to work for free then the results you get reflect what you paid for.

Post: Out of state investing

Crystal Smith
ModeratorPosted
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 2,815
  • Votes 1,750
Quote from @Jerell Edmonds:

Looking to connect with a friendly agent that knows the Ohio market well. Looking to invest in MFH And SFH .


 Try biggerpockets agent match: https://www.biggerpockets.com/agent/match