All Forum Posts by: Crystal Smith
Crystal Smith has started 65 posts and replied 2753 times.
Post: Looking to purchase my first multi-unit and property. Should I change my approach?

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Ropo Sanni:
Hello, I'm new to real estate and I'm looking to purchase my first property in Chicago . I want it to be a multi-unit preferably 3 units. I have about $100k available for down payment, closing costs and I'm hoping to have some left over for reserves. The goal is to make passive income and build generational wealth. I'm hoping to purchase something that is move in ready with little work required to make it more appealing to renters while charging max rent. Currently, the properties that seem to meet that criteria, don't work with the numbers I'm working with. Any advice on how to approach this? I'm looking to re-evaluate my approach.
Thanks!
If the goal is to build passive income and generational wealth then the approach you may need to change is considering what kind of sacrifice are you willing to make in the short term to realize the long-term goal. Possible approach changes and sacrifices you may have to make:
Expand your search to properties that are not move-in ready where you can utilize a Renovation Loan (such as an FHA 203K) o improve the property. If you plan to live in the property then the short term sacrifice you may have to make is to live in an area that is gentrifying in lieu of an area that is already fully developed. Find a property, develop it, live in it, rent it out and then repeat.
Another approach, which I believe may have already been mentioned is to find a mixed use property in lieu of just focusing on a 3plex
Another approach is to find something near one of the universities and run your rental analysis as if you are renting by the room at dorm like prices in lieu of renting each unit individually. When school is out then turn the apartments into an STR.
Another approach since the goal is to build generational wealth with passive income is to build up your current cash reserves through a few fix and flips, then use the cash to purchase and hold.
Post: LLC for rental unit

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Sweta Jain:
Hi,
I just started reading some books on real estate investing and wondering about the pros and cons of having a LLC for rental/investment property. Is it recommended to have a LLC and who can help creating a LLC (tax consultant or lawyer)?
Please share your opinion on this topic.
Thanks
Pro- An LLC can provide some anonymity protection, but in my opinion, it's not enough. Depending on where you incorporate your name will still be recorded on the public record with the Secretary of State. If your goal is anonymity then you have to choose a state where your name is not recorded. You can also purchase inside of a LandTrust for additional anonymity
Pro- Legal protection; combined with the right type of insurance
Con- Traditional bank will not lend to an LLC with no track record. You can start it, get a track record of at least 2 years and then maybe....
Pro- Hard Money lenders who can only lend to a business will lend to a new LLC, but you will still be personally guaranteeing the loan.
Post: Looking to learn techniques to apply in a downward trending economy.

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Michael L.:
Show me something BP Fam Bam🧠😎! How would I analyze a deal in a market where the rents are capitulating and is unsure how much or how long it will continue to do so? Of course buying right is always the key, but is there anything else I can do to help navigate the turbulence?
Not sure what market you are in where rents are going down dramatically, rents have been going up in the markets where we do business. Unless of course, you are referring to commercial rents. If you are referring to residential rents then you have answered your question- "Buying right"
But buying right is too simple an answer. I recommend to "navigate the turbulence" in your market do a deep dive on rent trends over the last 15 years. Why 15? The last real downturn was around 2008. If you examine the data you'll be able to see if rents in your market have rebounded since then or are they still depressed . If the rents have rebounded or are way above the last major downturn then whatever you are experiencing is most likely a short term blip and you should "buy right" and ride the wave back up. If the data shows that there's been no recovery since 2008 then.....
Post: Use FHA or conventional if you just started investment but you have enough downpaymen

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Jaekwan Lee:
Hi, I just start getting to know investment after reading a house hacking book and I really want to begin the journey of expanding rental real estate. I am married and my family size is three (me, my wife, and 3 yrs daughter). Since I need to think about sending my daughter school in a couple of years, I want to start with duplex. I have enough savings for down payment 20% but I also hear that you have one chance of using FHA loan. So here is my confusion. Is still better to get FHA loan with 3.5% when I have 20% down payment for the duplex? Since I feel I see two options I can think of.
- Buy duplex with FHA 3.5% and look for another property like fourplex
- Buy duplex with conventional loan 20% down and wait until gain another downpayment
Because I don't know the price points in your market along with what you can get for rent it's impossible to answer the question about whether or not it makes sense to buy with 3.5% down or 20% down and still positively cash flow a duplex. I recommend you do some market research on the price points to purchase and what you can get for rent to answer the question yourself.
Regarding a 3 to 4 unit, If you decide to use an FHA loan make sure you research the FHA self-sufficiency guidelines.
Post: Am I being too greedy with my asking price or impatient?

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @David Minaya:
Good day BP and Happy Father's Day to all the Dads!
I'm currently in the process of selling my first property. It is a 1500 sqft 3 bed 3 bath condo about a 5-minute walk to the beach. I live in Southern California and my property is currently listed at $1.05m. It has been on the market for about 45 days and has received modest interest from buyers. The property is part of a large condominium and is located on the backside of the building (i.e., it does not have an ocean view). My agent informed me that comps in the area are selling between $840K-985K, however those properties are not as near to the beach as mine. I should also mention that properties with an ocean view in my condominium have sold between $1.2m-1.3m but also have less square footage and less bedrooms and bathrooms. It was with that consideration that I listed the property at $1.05.
Considering the circumstances, I would really appreciate your opinions on whether I am being greedy with the listing price or whether I should be patient, keep the selling price as it is, and wait for a serious buyer.
Have any condominiums in your building with an ocean view sold between $1.2-1.3M in the last 6 months. If not, then your price may be too high and your agent may be right. What has your agent told you about the average days on market for recently sold listings? If the average is much less than 45 days then you are overpriced. If the average is around 45 days then don't panic yet.
Post: Wholesaler Licensing Requirements ? Good or bad

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Matthew Morrow:
There’s new legislation being proposed in Pennsylvania that may require wholesalers to obtain a real estate license. I can see the arguments from both sides and am curious to hear how others might adapt their business practices if such a law is enacted in your state.
Interestingly, South Carolina just implemented a similar requirement last week, and it seems like more states may follow suit soon.
What are your thoughts! https://www.parealtors.org/blog/realtors-advocate-at-capitol...
For investors that treat Real Estate like a business, and a part or all of their business is wholesaling, then a change in the laws is a good thing for a good business person. The good business person will adapt and the bad ones will drop out of the business.
Post: Agencies that also invest in rental properties - should I care?

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Connor Hailey:
Hi,
I live in TX and I'm looking to buy a rental property. I'm finding that a lot of real estate agencies also own rental properties/invest their own money. It seems like there could be a conflict of interest (e.g. the agency's investment arm finds the best deals/properties for themselves and pushes properties onto clients that their investment arm has already passed on).
Is this an issue or is there something I'm missing that makes the conflict of interest uncommon?
The answer to the question- should I care? If you have the right systems and people in place to facilitate due diligence on a property independent of the seller/owner or broker representing the seller, then no, you should not care if an agency that owns & purchases rentals is also selling properties. The part of the agency that purchases properties may have investment criteria that certain properties do not support, so they sell them because they may meet another investor's criteria. The properties may meet your criteria. I'd focus on making sure you have the right people in place for legal and property condition due diligence.
Post: Sell now off market or wait 10 months?

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Alex Todd:
Quote from @Crystal Smith:
Quote from @Alex Todd:
Hey BP - we have a SFH that has been a LT rental (only 2yrs) but with same tenants, who are asking if we'd be willing to sell off market, in the next 90 days.
Their current lease extends to April 2025, which at that point we were planning on selling.
Why sell in the first place? ROE is so low (.6%) that at this point in our RE journey, we believe our $$ can do more for us elsewhere and we still sit within Sec121 exclusion to avoid some CG tax.
Any strong positions to waiting? Moving forward? Things we should look out for, lobby for, strategize on?
Thanks!
Alex
While there's not enough information in your original post to provide advice here are some things to consider:
1. With a .6% ROE and a current inflation rate of 3.3% year over year, you are losing ground unless the projected appreciation rate of your property is high enough to overcome these negative numbers. If the projected appreciation is high enough to overcome these numbers then you hold. If not then you sell.
2. A strategy you may consider is selling is using either a 1031 or a structured installment sale to delay taxes. You can talk to @Aaron Hickey to see if a structured installment sale would work for you.
3. If you decide to sell then having a tenant who wants to buy is perfect. Before signing a contract with the tenant request a Proof of Funds if they are paying cash or a pre-approval if they are going to get financing. Don't commit to a contract until you know they can close.
Thanks Crystal! Good call on proof of funds.
Were straddling between doing a 121exc and 1031 or just selling straightup with the 121exc and paying the remaining CG taxes to have some flexibility on where to reinvest v forced timeline of the 1031.
Make sure you talk to @Aaron Hickey about using the structured settlement approach. It removes the forced timeline associated with 1031 while providing the same tax delay benefits.
Post: Sell now off market or wait 10 months?

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Alex Todd:
Hey BP - we have a SFH that has been a LT rental (only 2yrs) but with same tenants, who are asking if we'd be willing to sell off market, in the next 90 days.
Their current lease extends to April 2025, which at that point we were planning on selling.
Why sell in the first place? ROE is so low (.6%) that at this point in our RE journey, we believe our $$ can do more for us elsewhere and we still sit within Sec121 exclusion to avoid some CG tax.
Any strong positions to waiting? Moving forward? Things we should look out for, lobby for, strategize on?
Thanks!
Alex
While there's not enough information in your original post to provide advice here are some things to consider:
1. With a .6% ROE and a current inflation rate of 3.3% year over year, you are losing ground unless the projected appreciation rate of your property is high enough to overcome these negative numbers. If the projected appreciation is high enough to overcome these numbers then you hold. If not then you sell.
2. A strategy you may consider is selling is using either a 1031 or a structured installment sale to delay taxes. You can talk to @Aaron Hickey to see if a structured installment sale would work for you.
3. If you decide to sell then having a tenant who wants to buy is perfect. Before signing a contract with the tenant request a Proof of Funds if they are paying cash or a pre-approval if they are going to get financing. Don't commit to a contract until you know they can close.
Post: wholesaling and Realtors

- Real Estate Broker
- Chicago, IL
- Posts 2,814
- Votes 1,750
Quote from @Wesley Tripp:
I have found someone interested in selling their house using wholesaling but they have already started talking to a realtor. I would like to work with the realtor to get the job done but previously realtors have ask me how they will be paid. What would be the best option to make sure realtors will be paid in a wholesale transaction (listing or buying agents)? Thank you.
You get the property under contract direct with the seller. Make sure your contract provides you with permission to market the property, which includes marketing on the MLS. You sign a contract with the realtor to market the property at a price higher than what you have committed to the seller. You then have to decide if you want to assign your contractor to the new buyer or double close. The realtor gets paid commission from the sale. The seller gets paid what you committed to on your sales contract. You get paid the difference.