Glendale, AZ · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 238 votes
Hi guys,
I lived in a house from 2012 till Jan 2022.
In Jan 2022 I moved out and it became a rental...
My understanding, if I lived in the property for 2 out of the last 5 years I can sell it without paying taxes on the profit and without doing a 1031 exchange.
Do I understand correctly that if I sell before Jan of 2027 I am not going to have to pay any taxes on the profit I made?
Is it correct?
Dont want to sell it and then receive a bill from the IRS for half of the profit I made...
@Mary Jay@William Whitley I dont believe that you can use the exclusion because it is passed the time period. At Jan 2025 you had lived there 2 years within the last 5 years. In February 2025 you had lived there 1 year and 11 months out of the last 5 years. I dont think it is 5 years PLUS 2 years. It is 2 years within the last 5.
You could move back into the property for 2 years AND THEN use the exclusion when you sell. In fact the way the market is right now, I would live there a year and maybe 9 months and then put it on the market. Just close right after the 2 year period.
Moving back into the home to obtain 2 of 5 years does not end up being able to exempt all the gains. Consult your tax professional.
The rule you’re referring to is the home sale exclusion. Generally, if you have lived in the property for at least two of the last five years before selling, you can potentially exclude the gain up to the capped limits depending on filing status.
Since you have lived there from 2012 until January 2022 and then started renting it, it sounds like you should still fall within that five-year window. If you sell before January 2027, you would likelystill qualify for the exclusion, which means you probably wouldn’t need to do a 1031 exchange.
One thing to watch out for, though, is depreciation recapture. Because it has been a rental since 2022, any depreciation you have taken (or should have taken) is likely still taxable when you sell. The home sale exclusion doesn’t typically wipe that out, but it does generally cover most of your actual gain.
That said, every situation can be different depending on other factors like filing status and how depreciation was handled. I highly recommend you check the details with your CPA or tax advisor before you list it, just to make sure there are no surprises come tax time.
@Mary Jay@William Whitley I dont believe that you can use the exclusion because it is passed the time period. At Jan 2025 you had lived there 2 years within the last 5 years. In February 2025 you had lived there 1 year and 11 months out of the last 5 years. I dont think it is 5 years PLUS 2 years. It is 2 years within the last 5.
You could move back into the property for 2 years AND THEN use the exclusion when you sell. In fact the way the market is right now, I would live there a year and maybe 9 months and then put it on the market. Just close right after the 2 year period.
@Mary Jay@William Whitley I dont believe that you can use the exclusion because it is passed the time period. At Jan 2025 you had lived there 2 years within the last 5 years. In February 2025 you had lived there 1 year and 11 months out of the last 5 years. I dont think it is 5 years PLUS 2 years. It is 2 years within the last 5.
You could move back into the property for 2 years AND THEN use the exclusion when you sell. In fact the way the market is right now, I would live there a year and maybe 9 months and then put it on the market. Just close right after the 2 year period.
Moving back into the home to obtain 2 of 5 years does not end up being able to exempt all the gains. Consult your tax professional.
My understanding, if I lived in the property for 2 out of the last 5 years I can sell it without paying taxes on the profit and without doing a 1031 exchange.
Do I understand correctly that if I sell before Jan of 2027 I am not going to have to pay any taxes on the profit I made?
You missed the window, sorry. You needed to sell before Jan 2025 to benefit from this rule. Right now, you owe capital gain taxes, unless you do a 1031 exchange or implement some other tax deferral strategy.
My understanding, if I lived in the property for 2 out of the last 5 years I can sell it without paying taxes on the profit and without doing a 1031 exchange.
Do I understand correctly that if I sell before Jan of 2027 I am not going to have to pay any taxes on the profit I made?
You missed the window, sorry. You needed to sell before Jan 2025 to benefit from this rule. Right now, you owe capital gain taxes, unless you do a 1031 exchange or implement some other tax deferral strategy.
Thank guys!
What kind of other tax deferral strategies are there, sir? Besides the 1031 exchange...
No! As @Michael Plaks said, you've missed your deadline. You must have lived in it for 2 out of the five years immediately preceding the sale. That means that you had until Jan of 2025 to sell it and still have lived in it for two out of the last five. You would have qualified for the exclusion on the sale—except for depreciation recapture.
However, since the property was converted to investment, you are able to do a 1031 exchange and defer all of the tax and depreciation recapture and reinvest it into another investment property/properties.
You can move back in January 2026, live there for 2 years and sell January 2028. I believe this would allow you to take 12/16ths (75%) tax free (10 years 2012-2022 plus 2 years 2026-2028 as primary and 4 years as a rental.) BUT! Check with your CPA to make sure those first 10 years don’t get disqualified. (Resulting in only 2/16th tax free (12.5%)) Then you can choose to do a 1031 with the reminding 25% or pay the taxes.
If this is hundreds of thousands in taxable gains and you like the house it might be worth moving back in if you do qualify for 75% tax free. Ps. You could sell your current primary tax free before moving in to it as well.
If you are single, you may exclude up to $250,000 of gain from the sale of your primary residence. If you are married and file jointly, the exclusion increases to $500,000. Any gain exceeding these limits is generally subject to long-term capital gains tax, provided the property was held for more than two year out of five.
Hey! Yeah, this one is a bit tricky. Under Section 121, if you owned and lived in the property as your primary residence for at least 2 of the last 5 years before selling, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain if single or $500,000 if married filing jointly.
Since you moved out in January 2022, your 5-year window ends in January 2027. Selling before that date would still allow you to claim the exclusion.
Just keep in mind that the time it was used as a rental is considered non-qualified use, so you’ll owe tax on the depreciation taken (or that could have been taken) during the rental period. The rest of the gain should still qualify for the exclusion if you sell before January 2027.
However, as many mentioned above, even if you did miss your window, there are a few other options. With a 1031 Exchange, You can defer the gain by swapping it for another investment property. An Installment Sale can help spread the gain over several years so you don’t get hit with a big tax bill all at once.
It’s worth connecting with a CPA to help you run the numbers.
Hey! Yeah, this one is a bit tricky. Under Section 121, if you owned and lived in the property as your primary residence for at least 2 of the last 5 years before selling, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain if single or $500,000 if married filing jointly.
Since you moved out in January 2022, your 5-year window ends in January 2027. Selling before that date would still allow you to claim the exclusion.
Just keep in mind that the time it was used as a rental is considered non-qualified use, so you’ll owe tax on the depreciation taken (or that could have been taken) during the rental period. The rest of the gain should still qualify for the exclusion if you sell before January 2027.
However, as many mentioned above, even if you did miss your window, there are a few other options. With a 1031 Exchange, You can defer the gain by swapping it for another investment property. An Installment Sale can help spread the gain over several years so you don’t get hit with a big tax bill all at once.
It’s worth connecting with a CPA to help you run the numbers.
Based on her dates it sounds like she missed her window. She would have had to sell by January of this year in order to meet the requirement. Someone else already mentioned it but there is some mechanism of regaining some of it by moving back in for two more years, but with the rental time frame deducted.
The rule you’re thinking of is the home sale exclusion. If you lived in the property for at least two of the last five years before selling, you can usually exclude the gain up to the IRS limits (depending on your filing status).
Since you lived there from 2012 until January 2022 and then converted it to a rental, you’d still be within that five-year window. So if you sell before January 2027, you’d most likely still qualify for the exclusion—meaning you wouldn’t need to use a 1031 exchange just to avoid capital gains taxes on most of the profit.
The main thing to keep in mind, though, is depreciation recapture. Because the property has been rented since 2022, any depreciation you’ve claimed—or should have claimed—will be taxable when you sell. The exclusion doesn’t wipe that out, although it does cover most of the regular gain.
Every situation can differ depending on filing status and how depreciation was handled, so it’s best to double-check the details with your CPA before listing, just to avoid surprises when tax time comes.
I'm perplexed why we have contradicting opinions stated on this thread. You do not have a 5-year window after moving out. You have a 5-year lookback, and two of these 5 years you needed to live there. So you only have a 3-yr window after moving out, and that window expired in January 2025.
At this point your options are: - pay the tax if it's manageable, and sometimes it is the best option - 1031 exchange - a couple of tax deferral alternatives similar to 1031 exchange - move back for 2 years to earn a partial exclusion as described by @Bill B.
Can’t believe everything ChatGPT says. Even if it comes from a CPA. Two cpas have it wrong in this forum. It’s super clear for the 250k/500k exclusion. 2 or the last 5 years primary residence.
Living there November 2020 through November 2022 and selling today = good. Living there since Jesus was born through October 2022 or anytime before = bad. (For section 121 exclusion)
Good luck and seek professional advice when 10s of thousands of dollars of taxes are at stake. There actually are some exceptions if you got divorced or other specific things, but above is the normal rules.