So a tenant is suing us...

10 Replies

Good Afternoon. I am not sure if anyone has experienced a tenant lawsuit but supposedly a tenant fell at one of our properties and hurt their ankle. We are located in the Florida, the property is in an LLC and we have coverage on the property plus a personal umbrella.

Any words of wisdom from someone who has experienced this before?  This is new and I am not sure what to expect or next steps or the costs.  This is after discovering another tenant moved out and left dog poop all over one the bedrooms.  There are days that a mutual fund sounds like a better choice.

We reached out to our attorney and notified the insurance broker.  Sigh

@Christopher Gingras

You did right. Insurance should handle it from here-they will give you an attorney to represent you so continue living and enjoying life. It is a part of doing business and dealing with the public. I also make my tenants get renters insurance that may also take effect-you should get a copy of the policy each year and the LLC be an additional insured.

Do you manage these yourself?  Was the area that the tenant fell a known hazard they had warned you about or that you should have known about?

I agree with the other poster, I think you will be fine and just keep on enjoying life.  Sorry that you are having to go through that!

We just switched to a property management firm but there was no notice at all of a hazardous condition.  Nor did they notify us after the incident.  When I visited to take photos recently there is a small deterioration to the walkway at the end but its no different than any other crack you might see on a city sidewalk.  It really does seem like a perfect walk way.  Oh well.  Thanks for the thoughts.  Hopefully the insurance company fights the claim.

The lawyers don’t want your portfolio or your residence or even the money in your account . They want the insurance company to pay them . It’s scary but keep a cool head and listen to your attorney


Unfortunately, we live in a very litigious society. I deal with this xxxx all the time. Let the attorneys handle this one. My only suggestion and hope is that you did a thorough walk through with photos or video prior to them moving in.I find that this type of system helps to alleviate some of this craziness that comes your way. Good for you on the umbrella policy. I have that too over all my own properties

Don’t worry about it. That’s why you have insurance.

It’ll take a long time. Months minimum.

Good luck. It’ll be all good.

Surprisingly, we have not received any additional information.  We passed on the information and my sense is that the attorney discovered there was no merit to the lawsuit or the insurance company is negotiating behind the scenes.  As mentioned in the responses it was a frustration but it has really been handled entirely by the insurance company.