Investor · Mooresville, NC · Member since 2015 · 3 posts · 0 votes
We have a tenant who wants us to allow them to add a new permitted occupant to their lease that has an emotional support dog. Since the permitted occupant is not our tenant what rules do we need to follow in this situation? Any help is welcome.
An emotional support animal has to be treated like any service animal, which means you can't discriminate against them any more than you could a wheelchair or crutches.
You could say, "I'm sorry but we don't allow pets." This is a tricky way of scaring off scammers because they won't know enough to push back and they will disappear.
If the service animal is legit, the applicant will tell you, "This isn't a pet; it's a service animal." At that point, you can apologize for misunderstanding the situation and have them apply. You can still disqualify them for any reason you would normally disqualify someone (credit, criminal, lack of references, etc.).
Are emotional support animals the same legally as service animals? I know they're not covered under most laws as they're just untrained dogs that anyone writes up a BS cert saying they're necessary, but I don't know the laws as far as tenants go
Thats a bold ask... "I want to add another occupant to the lease and oh you have to also take their emotional support chihuahua." I agree with others. Tell them all adults have to apply before they are approved to move into the property, take their application, and find a reason to deny from your criteria. This year I had a tenant move in, acquire a cat shortly after move-in, then get a service animal letter from their therapist after I sent them a violation notice to remove the cat. PM consulted the attorney who said there was nothing to be done. FML.
An emotional support animal has to be treated like any service animal, which means you can't discriminate against them any more than you could a wheelchair or crutches.
You could say, "I'm sorry but we don't allow pets." This is a tricky way of scaring off scammers because they won't know enough to push back and they will disappear.
If the service animal is legit, the applicant will tell you, "This isn't a pet; it's a service animal." At that point, you can apologize for misunderstanding the situation and have them apply. You can still disqualify them for any reason you would normally disqualify someone (credit, criminal, lack of references, etc.).
Let's be specific here. The OP called the animal an "emotional support animal"; subsequent posts have morphed this into a "service animal." Those are two very different things under the law. If it truly is an ESA, then make sure you do your research on it before you respond.
Since your tenant is asking for a modification to the the existing lease (adding an occupant), I think you'd be able to deny that modification if you'd like and they would be bound by your current agreement until expiration. I wouldn't even mention the animal in your denial letter.
If the ESA owner is already a permitted occupant, I think you need to treat the situation as you would for a tenant.
I have a service animal and the rights for service animals and emotional support animals vary greatly. I will tell the big difference in these two is that the animal has to perform tasks. I think it is a minimum of three under the law. It is legal to ask what task does your animal perform for you. This is what I educate every business I can through my travels. It helps us a ton to educate everyone and have everyone ask the right questions. Each state varies on service dogs in training as well. In my state service dogs in training have the same rights as service dogs. So be careful there as well. In that case you can still ask what tasks the animal is being trained to perform or what’s organization they are helping. Please ask questions!
Be very careful dealing with this issue as you can easily wind up in hot water. If it were me, it would depend on the type of occupant and, of course, the landlord/tenant laws. My rule is that any occupant over 18 years of age must pass income/credit/background on their own -- income unless they can show they are a legal dependent of Tenant/Applicant, credit/background on all. So if it's an elderly mom moving in who is now a dependent of current tenant, for me that would be a different decision than current tenant asking if an unrelated roommate can move in. ESA is not a consideration as if they have proper paperwork, you have to allow it if you allow the extra occupant. If it's not a dependent situation, I'd suggest they find a qualified tenant to replace them and let them out of their lease once they do rather than allow extra people after the lease is signed, and my lease specifically states no other occupants except those listed in lease.
Ignore the fact that there is a support animal, it has nothing to do directly with the request. Simply deny the request since you are not obligated to accept an additional tenant.
We have a tenant with an emotional support dog. So far, she's been a good tenant.
Be mindful of how you handle this situation, as you can quickly find yourself slapped with a violation of the rights of individuals with disabilities if you are not appropriate with your actions.