Bought the house in 2020 and have lived in since. Up to date on payments. Have lived in house since 2020. Conventional fixed rate mortgage which was sold to Fannie Mae shortly after originating. Wanting to turn into rental property. Have formed LLC and submitted everything to Fannie Mae to have the LLC become the holder of the mortgage. I am the sole member of the LLC. I am getting nervous now that I am not able to transfer the mortgage to the LLC or if I do, I will trigger a due on sale clause? Has anyone successfully transferred their mortgage out of their name and into the name of an LLC that they are the only member of?
You work in healthcare and are easy to find? What do you think is going to happen? The Tenant will discover who you are and then sue you for . . . what, exactly?
Even if they do sue, they have to win.
Even if they do win, insurance will cover it.
They have to win a judgment so large that insurance will not cover it. Why do you think insurance provides $300,000 - $500,000 in liability? Because they know that's enough to cover 99.9999% of all lawsuits. Most Landlords are sued over security deposit disputes, small enough to be handled by small claims court. If you had a large lawsuit for health issues from mold or a fall down some rickety steps with no handrail, you may be looking at hundreds of thousands but the vast majority of those are settled out of court for well below your liability limit.
This idea that Tenants are suing Landlords every day (and winning) is ludicrous. The best way to protect yourself is to obey the law and treat your tenants honestly and fairly.
Call your lender and ask them if you can transfer the property to an LLC. If they say it's OK, ask them to put it in writing and move forward. It's that easy.
@Hannah C Christie
Question I always ask when someone goes to do this is why?
1. You lose title insurance
2. You may lose tax benefits if you sell in next 2 years
3. LLC costs more $
Get an umbrella insurance policy and keep it in your name.
1. Why? Because every resource recommends doing so from a liability stand point and I do not want my name out there as the property owner. I am staying local to where the rental is, work in healthcare where I can be found reliably and with little security.
2. Tax benefits? I don’t plan on selling anytime soon which is why I’m going through this trouble. My interest rate is 2.875% which I do not want to give up and the house hasn’t changed too much in value to make selling lucrative. Additionally, I still like the house so if things don’t work out with my living situation (cohabiting with partner) I have some place to go back to.
3. I’m ok spending more if there’s some benefit to it- like privacy and being able to sleep at night.
I have a business banking account and a PO Box for the LLC, a property management company picked out for once the transfer is approved (so I can sign the agreement as the LLC and the LLC actually has the right sign) and a CPA that has helped me file and form the LLC. I took the advice to put the house in an LLC (or at least try to) from a prominent real estate maven in my area (she has about 40 properties).
FNMA will NOT transfer a mortgage to an LLC!
Who told you they would?
I don't know how credible it is, but a year ago somebody posted that Fannie Mae does allow this.
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/49/topics/1045626-trans... the snippet:
"Unless the previous borrower requests a release of liability, the servicer must process the following exempt transactions without reviewing or approving the terms of the transfer:
A transfer of the property (or, if the borrower is an inter vivos revocable trust, a transfer of a beneficial interest in the trust) to a limited liability company (LLC), provided that the mortgage loan was purchased or securitized by Fannie Mae on or after June 1, 2016, and the LLC is controlled by the original borrower or the original borrower owns a majority interest in the LLC, and if the transfer results in a permitted change of occupancy type to an investment property, such change does not violate the security instrument (for example, the 12 month occupancy requirement for a principal residence)."
1. Why? Because every resource recommends doing so from a liability stand point and I do not want my name out there as the property owner. I am staying local to where the rental is, work in healthcare where I can be found reliably and with little security.
2. Tax benefits? I don’t plan on selling anytime soon which is why I’m going through this trouble. My interest rate is 2.875% which I do not want to give up and the house hasn’t changed too much in value to make selling lucrative. Additionally, I still like the house so if things don’t work out with my living situation (cohabiting with partner) I have some place to go back to.
3. I’m ok spending more if there’s some benefit to it- like privacy and being able to sleep at night.
I have a business banking account and a PO Box for the LLC, a property management company picked out for once the transfer is approved (so I can sign the agreement as the LLC and the LLC actually has the right sign) and a CPA that has helped me file and form the LLC. I took the advice to put the house in an LLC (or at least try to) from a prominent real estate maven in my area (she has about 40 properties).
Problem is, your fingerprints are already on the title, conveying to an LLC will not remove them from the chain. It will take about two seconds to find the deed out of you and the subsequent deed out. In addition, I assume you'll want to pay the minimum in transfer taxes which will be a red flag that you are the LLC.
I meant to write " the deed out of you and the prior deed in".
For commercial a LLC is absolutely required for single family it's not. What liability do you have that is not covered by insurance?
In regards to your name on the property- your name is on the llc which is easy to find.
@Hannah C Christie
I will say DITTO to @@Chris Seveney on this.
The good thing is you made this post and the veterans are offering you a veterans perspective. I hope to take that into consideration versus a lot of other things you may have heard about LLCs. There is a big difference between experts/gurus and actual LL and owners opinions.
I'll make mine quick. Based on your OP, an LLC for your rental does not make sense. If you have multifamily commercial loans, then it's a MAY BE. If you have a loan and requires it to be and LLC, then obviously you need one. For conventional SFH type loans, it's not needed, nore neccessary, and it does really NOTHING to keep you name off. You own ths LLC, right?
And let's not go down the path of anonymity, WY, DE, etc... unless you have like over $20M of equity and net worth. For all other situations, get an umbrella policy.
This topic comes up often.
You work in healthcare and are easy to find? What do you think is going to happen? The Tenant will discover who you are and then sue you for . . . what, exactly?
Even if they do sue, they have to win.
Even if they do win, insurance will cover it.
They have to win a judgment so large that insurance will not cover it. Why do you think insurance provides $300,000 - $500,000 in liability? Because they know that's enough to cover 99.9999% of all lawsuits. Most Landlords are sued over security deposit disputes, small enough to be handled by small claims court. If you had a large lawsuit for health issues from mold or a fall down some rickety steps with no handrail, you may be looking at hundreds of thousands but the vast majority of those are settled out of court for well below your liability limit.
This idea that Tenants are suing Landlords every day (and winning) is ludicrous. The best way to protect yourself is to obey the law and treat your tenants honestly and fairly.
Call your lender and ask them if you can transfer the property to an LLC. If they say it's OK, ask them to put it in writing and move forward. It's that easy.
1. Why? Because every resource recommends doing so from a liability stand point and I do not want my name out there as the property owner. I am staying local to where the rental is, work in healthcare where I can be found reliably and with little security.
2. Tax benefits? I don’t plan on selling anytime soon which is why I’m going through this trouble. My interest rate is 2.875% which I do not want to give up and the house hasn’t changed too much in value to make selling lucrative. Additionally, I still like the house so if things don’t work out with my living situation (cohabiting with partner) I have some place to go back to.
3. I’m ok spending more if there’s some benefit to it- like privacy and being able to sleep at night.
I have a business banking account and a PO Box for the LLC, a property management company picked out for once the transfer is approved (so I can sign the agreement as the LLC and the LLC actually has the right sign) and a CPA that has helped me file and form the LLC. I took the advice to put the house in an LLC (or at least try to) from a prominent real estate maven in my area (she has about 40 properties).
1. Why? Because every resource recommends doing so from a liability stand point and I do not want my name out there as the property owner. I am staying local to where the rental is, work in healthcare where I can be found reliably and with little security.
2. Tax benefits? I don’t plan on selling anytime soon which is why I’m going through this trouble. My interest rate is 2.875% which I do not want to give up and the house hasn’t changed too much in value to make selling lucrative. Additionally, I still like the house so if things don’t work out with my living situation (cohabiting with partner) I have some place to go back to.
3. I’m ok spending more if there’s some benefit to it- like privacy and being able to sleep at night.
I have a business banking account and a PO Box for the LLC, a property management company picked out for once the transfer is approved (so I can sign the agreement as the LLC and the LLC actually has the right sign) and a CPA that has helped me file and form the LLC. I took the advice to put the house in an LLC (or at least try to) from a prominent real estate maven in my area (she has about 40 properties).
I assume you got a new policy when you switched it to your LLC, as the title companies I spoke with said policy is voided.
Note for those who are new: a warranty deed only says the seller is providing a warranty, it does not mean the title company is unless there is a valid title policy.
@Chris Seveney i would challenge that. Think of the scenerio of something bad happening at the rental.. the extreme case the property had a fire and a tenant was killed ,lets say the surviving partner is suing the landlord for liabilities in a hige amount say millions .Yes they can come after your personal assets to recover that amount ,your primary home,your bak account,your other stuff if you own because you didnot have an LLC in place.Just having an LLc is not gona prevent it but will limit the lawsuit to what is inside the llc.The llC should be done the proper way ,and if books of the LLC are in order it will be hard to pearce the corporate veil.But if books of LLC are not in order,there it self you lost every protection from the LLC structure.At least thats what my research taught me.So it is always imp.
You are talking about 2 different things here:
1. The actual (deed)
2. The loan to your lender/bank
You can do what ever you want with the deed-- its your property (deed) and you can move it anywhere to anyone. An LLC is a passthrough that is in your name. So there is no reason you can't put the deed in an LLC. As long as you are paying your Loan the lender can't do anything about it because they are the lender on the note.
They don't need to know, no reason to tell them. Now if you are wanting to put the loan in your LLC that will require a refi or re-casting of the loan. No reason to do that if you are locked into a good rate- just wait and do it if/when rates drop.
*You still get the same tax benefits whether it is in an LLC or not.
*asset protection isn't guaranteed in an LLC either. Its just another step of protecting from curious eyes and separation as a business.
(This is all opinion and not tax advise).
@Chris Seveney i would challenge that. Think of the scenerio of something bad happening at the rental.. the extreme case the property had a fire and a tenant was killed ,lets say the surviving partner is suing the landlord for liabilities in a hige amount say millions .Yes they can come after your personal assets to recover that amount ,your primary home,your bak account,your other stuff if you own because you didnot have an LLC in place.Just having an LLc is not gona prevent it but will limit the lawsuit to what is inside the llc.The llC should be done the proper way ,and if books of the LLC are in order it will be hard to pearce the corporate veil.But if books of LLC are not in order,there it self you lost every protection from the LLC structure.At least thats what my research taught me.So it is always imp.
can you share an example or lawsuit where this was the case on a single family rental? Your primary residence is protected in most states by homestead. It goes back to as noted as being a good landlord. Also most people have no clue how to run a LLC. For example acting as the property manager completely nullifies the LLC. Transferring it by deed and keeping your name on the mortgage again nullifies the LLC.
If you want to run it as a business then do so, but most do it half-a$$ and are wasting money when doing it.
So I'm just trying to put the mortgage in the name of the LLC and use a property management company to handle all things rental. I'm waiting to sign the property management agreement with the company I've chosen until the mortgage has the LLC's name on it so that the LLC is making the contract with the PM Co and not myself.
1. Why? Because every resource recommends doing so from a liability stand point and I do not want my name out there as the property owner. I am staying local to where the rental is, work in healthcare where I can be found reliably and with little security.
2. Tax benefits? I don’t plan on selling anytime soon which is why I’m going through this trouble. My interest rate is 2.875% which I do not want to give up and the house hasn’t changed too much in value to make selling lucrative. Additionally, I still like the house so if things don’t work out with my living situation (cohabiting with partner) I have some place to go back to.
3. I’m ok spending more if there’s some benefit to it- like privacy and being able to sleep at night.
I have a business banking account and a PO Box for the LLC, a property management company picked out for once the transfer is approved (so I can sign the agreement as the LLC and the LLC actually has the right sign) and a CPA that has helped me file and form the LLC. I took the advice to put the house in an LLC (or at least try to) from a prominent real estate maven in my area (she has about 40 properties).
If you want to limit your liability by transferring the property to an LLC, then you will also need to get a new commercial insurance policy and refinance to a commercial mortgage. You will typically also pay your local/state transfer and recordation taxes on the transfer.
Short of doing those things, then the LLC will not actually limit your liability, and could potential increase your liability. If your tenant falls and breaks their leg and makes a claim on an insurance policy in your personal name, and the insurance company sees you no longer own the property.....do you think they are going to pay out the claim? No they wont. So many people who move their property to an LLC essentially have no insurance on it....and dramatically increase their liability with the LLC transfer.
@Hannah C Christie, I have also hear about Fannie or Freddie allowing a transfer of mortgage into a wholly owned company, but don't know the details. First yes insurance is the first line of defense, but LLCs have a lot of protection as well.
Maybe do a Pro and Con check.
Pro, get the added protection of an LLC in addition to the insurance. By using a property manager you actually limit your liability a lot. You do not lose LLC protection just because you form an LLC and put a property you own now into it. Every LLC has to have partners put in capital in order for them to get started.
Pro, you are ready to buy another property and already have an existing LLC to put it in.
Con, even if Fannie allows the transfer will they let the interest rate stay the same? Maybe.
Con ,you need to buy new title/mortgage insurance to cover the property in the new name.
Con. if you decide to sell you lose the $250 tax exemption if it was your primary home for 2 out of the last 5 years.
Also the homestead exemption laws vary wildly. I don't know how they work in OK. If you move out you normally lose the homestead exemption since it is not your primary home anymore.
Just my thoughts.
@Russell Brazil
Change insurece policy to llc name after the property moves to llc and have the landlord as added person of interest That solves the issue ,doesnt it?