Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Alan Asriants

Alan Asriants has started 96 posts and replied 1443 times.

Post: Why Class D/Section 8 returns are not as good in Real Life vs on Paper - Real example

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031
Quote from @Lucas Thomas:
Quote from @Stuart Udis:

@Mark Cruse As a landlord you can understand the tenant base, you can respect the tenant base, you can be a responsive. This can be met by a tenant who is responsible and respectful of the property where the live. Unfortunately even the perfect landlord and tenant can't solve dilemna of expenses disproportionately impacting lower valued real estate. For illustration purposes take my market, Philadelphia as an example and compare a duplex in North Philadelpiha (c/d neighborhood) to a duplex in Chestnut Hill (A neighborhood). Rental licensing and lead testing requirements cost the same, common utilites cost the same, snow removal costs the same, general libility insurance costs the same, tax prep costs the same and the list goes on. Also, rents may be 3X higher but the leaking sink doesn't cost 3x to repair, when the curb trap has to be repalced, it costs the same and similarly the list goes on. Yes I agree, there are many landlords who are scum and treat their low income tenants poorly but treating your tenants well alone does not translate to sustainably operating these properties. Most who oprate in this space succesfully are extremely hands on or reach scale to achieve efficiencies. Neither of which is the profile of 99.9% of the investors on BiggerPockets who purchase these lower valued property expecting to retire early off of their excel spreadsheet cashflow.

Well I disagree with this post whole-heartedly. Everything is cheaper on a low-income rental. The taxes are lower, the debt service is lower, have the tenants pay all utilities (Sub-Meter if necessary), and the maintenance/rehabs are always cheaper as you don't have to put anything nice in the unit and when you do,  you put the most durable stuff (make your properties into lil bomb shelters, LOL). You purchase used appliances for 25% of the cost of new, paint the counter tops with Food Grade Counter paint, paint the cabinets when the doors go missing so they all match, NEVER USE CARPET, etc. Etc. Etc. 

If you can't cash flow a rental, it goes back to my original point that you are just bad at being a landlord. 

 So you just provide a sub par apartment and low quality repairs? Maintenance and repairs not cheaper unless you are getting really low quality work and materials. And if you get high quality work then you are saving on materials. Which is its own issue. Also don't understand how cash flow makes you a bad landlord? So if I cash flow and defer items I am a good landlord but if I break even but have a solid home I am a bad landlord?

Like Stuart mentioned, toilet clogs, leaks, windows, etc will all cost the same on a class A rental or class D. 

Because of this, people who own in lower class areas, encounter more repairs, so they use cheaper quality work and materials because your money doesn't go as far anymore. Eventually this poor quality of material and labor will bite your wallet again. and the cycle continues. In class A areas you can more safely adopt the idea: put it in once the right way and forget about it. Tougher to do this when your house is worth 80k and your windows bill is 3-5k. So you go for the lowest bidder at 1k. Those windows barely last and now your window is leaking from poor installation. You try to call the contractor but he is dodging your calls.

Please explain to me how replacing a window in a class D area is cheaper than class A without forgoing material and labor quality? 

Post: Why Class D/Section 8 returns are not as good in Real Life vs on Paper - Real example

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031
Quote from @Yakir Aloni:

I read your post and I must to ask you how he had non payment?? Section 8 don't covered by the government?? I live in chicago and I want to Stat to donit also and now when I read your post I'm little bit concerned about it!! Ty fpr your post I


 Only the governments portion is guaranteed. The tenants portion never guaranteed. That portions is not decided by you but by PHA. Gov might only be responsible for 200 bucks - for example

Post: Why Class D/Section 8 returns are not as good in Real Life vs on Paper - Real example

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031
Quote from @Ty Canal:

This could be true for a not so savvy investor, an emotional investor that looks at dollar signs and not common sense. 

Over 30 years I have amassed close to 400 properties all rented through section 8. Rarely, and I mean rarely do I have tenants not pay their share (for the most part they owe $100-$200 per month for their portion at the max). 

it's all about how you screen your tenants, don't get emotionally attached and agree when you finally get someone with a voucher that wants to rent. If you screen correctly many of these issues won't happen.

We make a great deal of net cash flow even after expenses/PM/T&I. It gives me the freedom to do what I want when I want, everybody's investment strategy is different as it relates to the individual. 

We can take your same example on that $300k home with rent n it backed by the government - tenant one day says I don't want to pay, now you're out a hefty mortgage. The appreciation is better on the more expensive home no doubt but as I mentioned everybody's investment goals are different. 

What you might think isn't good, many people have found massive success in. 


 I think class A/B investing would be more about making a calculated and risk averse financial decision. 

Why do most people spend $15k on a course on Section 8 investing and those who invest in A/B real estate don't sign up for such stupidity. 

Emotions. Class D investment is literally someone ONLY looking at the numbers and not taking in other important aspects of the investment that are not financially related.

The savvy investor understands the value of location, the value of high quality real estate and does not put himself into a position of increased risk. 

There is a reason why credit scores exist. Default rates get higher and higher as you go down in score. Why would you risk your money ? Thats convincing yourself that the numbers on paper will play out in real life. this is when you get burned.  

Post: Why Class D/Section 8 returns are not as good in Real Life vs on Paper - Real example

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031
Quote from @Derek Robinson:

I used to own 3 Section 8 rentals in the Spartanburg, SC area.  The areas were not the best, but I had professional management and never had any trouble.  Two of them came with Section 8 tenants when I purchased them.  My plan was to increase rents to get the tenants to leave, do a lite rehab, and re-rent.  Well the rent increase was mostly paid by the government so the tenants never left.  I think they only had to pay $50/month while the government covered $500-$600.  We rarely had maintenance requests, tenants paid on time, and the annual inspections showed average wear and tear.  I pivoted at the time to mobile home parks and sold all three at a profit.  So, made money monthly and sold at a profit.  Super hands off with a great manager.  Tenants were mostly young adults with multiple kids.  One thing I did spend a lot of time on was driving the neighborhoods before I purchased.  You could drive down one block with run down houses, people hanging out in the yard during the day, dogs chained up in the front yard, etc.  Then the next block over would have clean houses, sense of ownership, etc.


If you were making decent money why did you sell? What was your ROI on sale?

Post: Why Class D/Section 8 returns are not as good in Real Life vs on Paper - Real example

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031
Quote from @Austin Wolff:

What about what this previous BP podcast guest has to say about Section 8? I don't do Section 8 but my summary of the interview was that this investor made his rental an A-class property (I don't remember what type of neighborhood it was in) to attract an "A-class" Section 8 tenant.


 Class A section 8 tenants exist, but its needle in a haystack. for one property/unit its fine but to find it for many units will be a challenge. Also if you're in an A/B class area, why the need to go for Section 8? You have options in your tenant pool already. Its possible you can squeeze a little more from the government for rent but I think that its just so much more effort, and you're looking for something that is already really hard to find. 

You need to get licensing, extra inspections, work with leases on PHA terms, etc and on top of that you want to find a super star section 8 tenant. Seems like more of a headache than finding a decent tenant in your area... 

Just to give you perspective. In my class B rentals I have 50 contact for a listing. 45 were not qualified, 3 were decent, 1 backed out, and 1 was a good applicant. And this is considered a healthy market. For that section 8 search your number will be even less favorable

Post: Driveway Repair Required?

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031

Yeah that looks pretty rough. You should take care of it. Thats a potential lawsuit waiting to happen.. 

Post: Which location to buy Real Estate for Investment and how much to invest

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031

Hey Ravi, the bucks county area is a great place to invest and close to the NJ/PA border.  Most areas here are class A/B and I personally invest here.

Its a solid place for appreciation and tenant base is strong. Finding a Mulit Family property is tough, but possible. You will need to be very competitive. There are nice townhomes here as well and a good amount of demand for them on the rental side. If you are looking at this area feel free to reach out anytime. 

Post: 1980’s duplex too old for 22 yo investor? Large market surge?

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031

1980's is fine. In my market 1980's is considered brand spanking new for Multi Family. What I'm more concerned about is why you want to buy in class C/D areas.

The 3 rules are location, location, location.

Focus on A/B

Might need to save up more, but dont buy a property for the sake of buying it. Buy a solid property. 

Good luck!

Post: Out of State investing does not work. With very few exceptions.

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031
Quote from @Ryan Fox:

@Marcus Auerbach- I have to say I don't entirely agree.  I've been investing in the Midwest from the west coast since 2017.  I have high quality tradespeople who do work at low cost.  My tenants are high quality.  When I need a contractor, I have my real estate agent bring in a contractor she's worked with before and trusts.  They can be more expensive but it's not always the best idea to get the cheapest contractor.  

Maybe I say this because I'm lucky to have partnered with an agent who is trustworthy.  There are certainly agents out there who only want to earn a transaction and do not want to build a business relationship.  My agent has brought forth several connections that have been valuable over the years.  I've bought several properties through her sight unseen.  

The advantage of investing remotely is that it creates far less of a time commitment on my part.  I can still work my W-2 and don't have to go out visiting several properties.  Rather, my agent checks out the property, provides about 40 pictures, and a rehab cost estimate.  I then make an offer based upon the data I have.  

I do agree with you that OOS investing only makes sense if you live in an expensive area and are investing in a much less expensive area.  If you buy a $1MM property in your expensive local market and something goes seriously wrong with it, that's a much bigger deal that something going wrong with a $150k property OOS.  And buying in good neighborhoods OOS is important as well.

 I have 2 clients who constantly buy out of state and I have referred them great contractors and even check in on their properties from time to time. 

The reason this relationsip works is becasue:

1. they have an agent that actually cares, has experience, and will point them in the right direction (didn't mean to pat myself on the back too much, but you get the point)

2. I do not advise them to buy crappy real estate. They buy B class RE, that is not overdue on cap ex - unless the values make sense to do such a large scale reno. 

3. they have family in the area that also help out and know the areas - also can check on contractor work 

What you likely have is combination of some of those things in your OOS strategy. What Marcus is alluding to are the countless of newer investors who just finished a $15k course about buying the crappiest section 8 rentals in brimingham AL. that is a recipe for disaster. 

Its hard to find an agent to trust, and knowing the area really helps you understand if the person you are speaking to is just spewing BS or giving you good advice. Awesome good luck making sure that the contractor is doing a 100% solid job. I'm ready to buy a good amount of money that they cut a bunch of corners. 

If you used to live in a more affordable area and now moved to a more expensive one, maybe you have enough connections to go back to that market. 

Post: Investors Thoughts !

Alan Asriants
Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Posts 1,458
  • Votes 1,031

Please do not chase cash flow when looking to purchase property out of state. Low purchase price and high rents can be attractive but there's a lot more to RE investing than numbers. 

Most investing is meant to be a passive strategy that not only brings you cash flow but also brings you wealth through appreciation. The strategy of buying a property in that price range immediately cut you from any sort of major appreciation gains in the future unless the area changes incredibly drastically. This is also called gambling. 

Typically in these price points and these attractive rental ratios, you will find yourself buying property in class D may be class C - at best - locations. 

It's important to note that this tenant class typically has high turnover rates. Higher eviction rates, higher property damage rates, and so on. Many investors who start in this type of real estate class don't survive very long. They are also the types of investors to start selling you a course, because the headline "How I made $50,000/m through section 8 rentals" is way more attractive than "Real estate investing - the long term game."

Not only is it risky to invest in these kinds of asset classes within your own local area, but let alone doing it out of state makes it even more difficult. There are plenty people here they can back me up and provide the real experience of the struggle. 

Also, when your rehab costs are more than 50% of your property value, you leave yourself no room for forced appreciation. It costs the same amount of money to rehab a property in a class A area and a class D area. 

As others mentioned before. If you want cash flow - buy a business.

Good luck