Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Scott S.

Scott S. has started 10 posts and replied 77 times.

Nice work, Jon.  Talk about maximizing value!  Very detailed outline and one of the best success stories I've read on BP.  The "rent by the room" model really is a win-win situation for the tenant and the landlord.

I think more high cost cities will follow Portland's lead with the tiny house parking (hoping anyway).  

Post: Recession, Market Crash, Bubble ??

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Nik Moushon:
Originally posted by @Scott S.:
Originally posted by @Nik Moushon:

@Jay Hinrichs I have not heard of Bruse Norris before. I will be looking into him. 

Since we are talking about media is posting their torches and pitch fork articles everywhere I came across this one this morning. 

https://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-bubble-era-h...

I don't know enough about mortgages to argue either way for this article but I thought it brought up some interest facts. The residential market might not cause the next crash, but if this article is right, it could effect the SFH market. And of course, like everyone one else, he throws out his timeline for the apocalypse.

 Wow, that is some serious hyperbole writing.  I see Mr Jurow has been claiming there is a serious "shadow inventory" crisis looming since 2010.  That millions of Here is an article he wrote for Business Insider in May of 2012.  Here is a direct quote from the article:  

My advice to homeowners in nearly all major metros is quite simple. Get an appraisal from a professional appraiser to find out what the market value of your home is. Seriously consider putting your home on the market within the next six months. You will have a chance of selling it.

He states that mortgage servicers around the country had discontinued foreclosing on millions of delinquent properties (non-agency securitized mortgages) and that millions of people are basically "squatting" and living for free.

Can you imagine how frustrated and foolish you'd feel if you took his advice 7 yrs ago?

Here is a look at the foreclosure filings and foreclosure rate:

Source:  https://www.attomdata.com/news/most-recent/2018-year-end-foreclosure-market-report/

 Scott, I wasn't linking the article for people to take advice from it. This thread is about media hyping up things and this article came across my news feed that same morning. Just from my experience in my own local market I could tell this was an over inflated piece of hype. Maybe it hold more weight in other markets but I find it hard to believe its anywhere near the extent that this guy makes it out to believe. 

 Nik, I know you weren't buying into it or linking it for advice.. I'm just kinda shocked how a guy with a PhD. can write this stuff.   ;)  

I guess all those clicks and views pay the bills.

Post: Recession, Market Crash, Bubble ??

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Nik Moushon:

@Jay Hinrichs I have not heard of Bruse Norris before. I will be looking into him. 

Since we are talking about media is posting their torches and pitch fork articles everywhere I came across this one this morning. 

https://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-bubble-era-h...

I don't know enough about mortgages to argue either way for this article but I thought it brought up some interest facts. The residential market might not cause the next crash, but if this article is right, it could effect the SFH market. And of course, like everyone one else, he throws out his timeline for the apocalypse.

 Wow, that is some serious hyperbole writing.  I see Mr Jurow has been claiming there is a serious "shadow inventory" crisis looming since 2010.  That millions of Here is an article he wrote for Business Insider in May of 2012.  Here is a direct quote from the article:  

My advice to homeowners in nearly all major metros is quite simple. Get an appraisal from a professional appraiser to find out what the market value of your home is. Seriously consider putting your home on the market within the next six months. You will have a chance of selling it.

He states that mortgage servicers around the country had discontinued foreclosing on millions of delinquent properties (non-agency securitized mortgages) and that millions of people are basically "squatting" and living for free.

Can you imagine how frustrated and foolish you'd feel if you took his advice 7 yrs ago?

Here is a look at the foreclosure filings and foreclosure rate:

Source:  https://www.attomdata.com/news/most-recent/2018-year-end-foreclosure-market-report/

Post: New investor joining BP from Wenatchee, WA

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Jon Latorre:

Little late to the thread here but I can verify that Chelan WA is one of the best vacation rental destinations in the Pacific NW! I'm continually blown away by how well many of our properties there perform. Especially the waterfront ones. If you have a waterfront 4+ bed home, you'll have 100% occupancy during the summer (with fixed turnovers!), mainly from large family groups coming from Seattle.

 Couple of questions:

Lk Chelan is great during the summer months but what is the vacancy rate like during the rest of the year?  I've been going to Chelan for 40+ yrs but I've only once stayed during the winter months and I wouldn't do it again (Leavenworth has much more appeal during the winter season).

Also, the fire season has been trending worse over the last decade or so.  Have you seen bookings increase for the June/July months to avoid the dreaded August fires and smoke?

Post: I lose $20k/year - help me w/ my strategy!

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91

Is most of the $500k in yearly income all from a job?  If so, there is huge risk in that part of the equation.  What if something negative happens to the employer and they can't afford that salary?  Can you easily find another $500k salary to replace it?  Life events happen as well.  I have a friend who was hit head-on by a careless driver.  Now they are unable to work.  

Unless that $500k yr income stream is guaranteed income, there is heavy debt involved with the current losses that you might find yourself in a very tight spot if circumstances go south.

Post: Loan for large acreage land

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Nik Moushon:
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

So Nik any other word on banks willing to fund your deal?? 

googel Scottman Guide then check out HML and there is a good matrix and will tell you who does land deals.

Seattle funding might look at that deal.

 I've heard back from 1 of the 3 that actually said they would look it over and get back to me. In short they said that we could probably figure something out. They said they would need more detailed info on both me and my partner on this before its a firm yes but at least I got a potential yes. 

The terms they laid out is what has got me in a bind atm. Basically I got kicked out of the residential land dept. and sent over to the commercial dept. They laid out a 65% LTV, 15 yr am, 6.5% (min.), & a 1.5% bank fee. Now I know I'm new to these type of land deals, so I guess I shouldn't be surprised at this, but a 35% DP is WAY bigger than I was originally thinking. My mind was in the 20-25% DP range, not anywhere close to 35%. So at that point my DP would be ~$130k, if the sell accept my current offer, which is way more than I have and really at that kind of cash makes me wonder if I should spend that elsewhere in a different investment. If I could have a lot sold at closing then I could have that kind of DP no problem but thats a big IF and I doubt the seller would keep pushing back closing till I could have a lot sold. So I'm still go to hold out and see what the other two banks have to say and try a couple others I got from other people today but I'm sure they are all going to be something in that ballpark of a figure.

 Wow, only 35% down payment for a land deal like this is pretty good.  Most banks want to see at least 25% down on a second home or investment property.  So for a non-producing $$ piece of land like that is quite surprising.

My family had some agricultural land in that area (Peshastin) and sold it via owner financing and the terms were 50% down payment.  This was a long time producing orchard and was sold to a farmer that had many years of ag experience and managed other orchards in the region.  Even with his farming experience it's still a risk and 50% DP were the terms.  No way would the same deal have been offered to some newbie.  All cash or bank financing.

Like Jay mentioned, I think you are underestimating the amount of cash you are going to need just to get this ready to sell the lots.  And the fact that it's owned by a logging company and they aren't taking this route speaks volumes.  Have you asked them whether they would consider selling half or maybe a quarter of the total land to you?  So it's more manageable to you and less $$?

Post: How to manage 4 Flex 1h45 mins away without property manager?

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91

Have you confirmed the condo in Capitol Hill allows short-term rentals?  Do they have a rental cap in case you have to rent monthly? 

Seattle isn't exactly the most AirBnB friendly city and things could change at anytime and make it more challenging.  Also, King County home prices are starting to really soften (down 11% in last 6 months) .  I don't see any indicators that this trend is going to reverse anytime soon.

I personally think the Tacoma 4-plex is a better investment but only if the numbers pencil out including a property manager.  Trying to manage a single family house from 2hrs away is one thing but the multi-family is going to have many more moving parts to handle (higher turn-over, typically worse tenants, tenant drama between the units, etc).

Post: Sell vs renting out my house

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Tess Robinson:

You know your house, @Mike Bales. You need to take into account any future capital expenditures (capex) that it will need (roof/water heater/furnace).  What types of routine or emergency maintenance will it need (water leaks / exterminator / smoke & CO2 detector maintenance / air filters / gutters / outside maintenance / paint / flooring / refresh between tenants, etc.). Will you mow the lawn yourself, or hire it out? Will you manage the property yourself (and take calls at 3am) or hire it out? You should set aside some money every month (from the rental income) to account for these items. These are called variable expenses, and as the name suggests, the cost will vary. Wildly, sometimes! Some investors use a percentage of the rent (10% for capex / 10% for Property Management / 5% each for maintenance & vacancy). You may use different numbers -for example- if you just replaced your roof.

You've already accounted for your mortgage payment. If that payment doesn't include taxes and insurance, you need to add that into your monthly expenses, as well. You'll want to pay your water/sewer/trash (don't leave that to the tenant), so count that as an expense as well. These are fixed expenses.

Then take your total income less your fixed & variable expenses:

$2200 - Monthly Rent
(220) - Capital Expense (roof, etc.)
(220) - Property Management Fee (you could do it yourself)
(110) - 5% Vacancy (money set aside each month to cover future vacancy)
(110) - 5% routine/emergency maintenance
(150) - Water/Sewer/Trash (I pay ~300 every other month in Tacoma)
(1600) - Mortgage (hopefully includes PITI)
(210) - Negative Cash Flow/month.... 

There are great calculators on here... and I'm literally GUESSING at your numbers, but this is what you need to be analyzing. There are tons of variables involved, so use your best judgement. Look over the calculators on BP, and find some like-minded people at Meetups, etc.

Good Luck!

Tenants are typically responsible for all utilities (water/sewer/garbage/power/gas) for single family homes.  Even for apartments the trend here in Tacoma and Seattle area has been to at least add a flat utility fee to the rent.

If he is willing to self-manage the property could be cash flow positive at this point.

Post: Sell vs renting out my house

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Mike Bales:

Thanks @Thomas S. We purchased the home for $220,000 about 8 years ago and it's currently valued at $360,000.  We still owe about $190,000 on it.  Does the 1% rule apply to purchase price or current valuation? 


I got the $600 positive cashflow based on our monthly payment of $1600 (principle, interest and taxes) and being able to rent it out for $2200. If my math is missing something please let me know.  Appreciate it!

 $1600/mo payment seems a bit high on $190,000 loan.  What is your current interest rate?  Might be able to refi and get that payment lowered.  Not sure what your property taxes look like but the mortgage should be able to get under $1,000/mo.

Post: recession proof cash flow level

Scott S.Posted
  • Tacoma, WA
  • Posts 77
  • Votes 91
Originally posted by @Bettina F.:

I lived in Tacoma for 30 years and know that market well.

I would not worry about Port Orchard.  You are protected by the demand driven by the naval base.  The investors that need to be worried are the high flyers investing in luxury apartments in Seattle.  They will be the first and hardest hit.  (It is already happening in San Francisco).  If Boeing or Microsoft were to leave, the high flyers,  who lose their jobs, would move down INTO your apartments while the leaving the luxury properties vacant.   Class B multifamily did well during the '08 crash.

FYI, Microsoft just announced last month they are planning a major, multi-BILLION dollar expansion and renovation of the Redmond campus.  Also will be adding 8,000+ jobs over the next few years.

https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2017/11/28/investing-grow-right-home/