All Forum Posts by: Joe Schaak
Joe Schaak has started 30 posts and replied 104 times.
Post: Any Way to Make This Work?

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
Okay, real estate gurus. I have an owner of a 3/1 down and 2/1 up duplex (he lives in it) that wants to move down to Florida. He's asking $220k and arrived at that number this way : $110k current mortgage, $100k down on FL home, and $10k moving expenses. Monthly rental income would be $2150.
As a straight cash purchase, it doesn't work. Is there any creative way to approach this that may help? Looking for ideas or just straight "no's"
Thanks!
Post: Project Mgr vs General Contractor

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
@J Scott @Valerie Hiscoe Thanks for the tips. I was inquiring about General Contractors. Sorry for the typo. J., great info and very helpful. And, Valerie, sorry for that experience and thanks for the forewarning
Post: Project Mgr vs General Contractor

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
I'm looking for opinions on using a General Contractor vs a Property Mgr managing a team of subs. I have a fairly large rehab with roof, windows, kitchen, bath, and opening walls. Looking forward to your great thoughts!
Post: INPUT WANTED : Duplex purchase

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
Thanks, @Michael Hayworth. Yes, I agree that the $135k option is best for me. I do have a relationship with a portfolio lender. And, you're right, I would do the $135k with a loan off the bat.
The options are really for the seller. I expect that A and B are the ones that will be considered seriously because C doesn't allow him to pay off his current mortgage.
Post: INPUT WANTED : Duplex purchase

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
I'm speaking with a gentleman that owns a 3down/2up duplex with current rental income of $2500/month (he lives in the lower unit so rent rate is based on comps). He owes $110k on the property and his present payment is around $1000. The present value is $180k. He wants to retire to Florida and walk away from this property. He also said he would be willing to carry a $100k mortgage on his new Florida home which he thought would cost about $130k.
I would like to be able to help him work this out. I would like to present 3 scenarios and would love input on them.
A.) $135k cash purchase with closing on his schedule.
B.) $150k purchase structured as $115k cash and $35k seller financing (monthly payments of $291.66 for 10 years).
C.) $180k purchase seller financed as 164 payments of $1097.56.
Thanks in advance for your insights and feedback ~ JS
Post: Advice needed on potential PML

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
@Wayne Brooks @Jay Hinrichs @Charlie Fitzgerald All great comments and extremely helpful. I had asked for his guarantee to be tied to his personal residence. If that doesn't work, perhaps I should ask him to put in a some percentage, maybe 10-15%. What are your thoughts on that?
Post: Advice needed on potential PML

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
Hoping to get some feedback about a potential lending opportunity:
$130k used as downpayment and rehab funds
4pts and 15% interest only for 8 months
2nd lien position with signed personal guarantee
30% of profit on sale of the property - roughly $30k
The rehabber has done 20+ projects and has a good reputation. He's a good guy and I believe in his ability. That said, you never know what can happen.
Thoughts?
Post: Rental Calc Questions

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
Perfect! Thanks for the link, @Brandon Turner!
Post: Rental Calc Questions

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
I'm not looking for a loan. I just want to check the way that I'm using the Rental Calculator here on the BP site. Is there a manual or video that explains how to use it? I'm concerned that I'm not entering my data correctly and that I'm not getting accurate results.
Post: Rental Calc Questions

- Investor
- Stillwater, MN
- Posts 106
- Votes 44
The Rental Calculator looks like a great tool but I don't think that I'm using it correctly. How do I input the numbers if I'm using a 6-month bank rehab loan at 5% with 1 point for 75% of purchase + rehab costs? Lets assume purchase is $75k and rehab is $25k. Help me, please!