Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew Paul

Matthew Paul has started 166 posts and replied 6752 times.

Post: Replace roof and HVAC?

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Matthew Paul:
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Dan Frehmeyer:

I am currently rehabbing my primary at the moment with plans to rent out this fall. I am doing mostly cosmetic fixes to a SFH currently.

I am looking for thoughts on whether I should be proactive with replacing a 20yr+ old roof (missing shingles, multiple layers, looks terrible) and a 25yr+ old hvac. The water heater was replaced a few months ago.

I have access to very cheap money so my thought is to be proactive with those major expenses before I turn it into a rental. The property will still cash flow with the extra cost of these expenses. Additionally, the house will likely appraise very favorably after as well with a cash out refi a big possibility

Thoughts?


 YES replace the roof, about 250- 275  a sq depending on pitch. YES replace the furnace, 1800ish, ASSUMING is about 1k- 1500 sq ft house


 Boy things are cheap where you are . roof is $450 to $600 a sq depending on pitch here in Maryland 


 I know I paid $550 a sq  ( 55 sq OUCH) when I lived in SC, total rip off, Material cost them about 100 bux a sq, 450 a sq profit for two days, Not a bad gig. 


 Materials are more like $185 a sq . Labor is not cheap , workers comp for roofers is crazy high , add in dump fees .   Profit to the company after all that is around 20% .   Not 450 a sq

Post: Replace roof and HVAC?

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Dan Frehmeyer:

I am currently rehabbing my primary at the moment with plans to rent out this fall. I am doing mostly cosmetic fixes to a SFH currently.

I am looking for thoughts on whether I should be proactive with replacing a 20yr+ old roof (missing shingles, multiple layers, looks terrible) and a 25yr+ old hvac. The water heater was replaced a few months ago.

I have access to very cheap money so my thought is to be proactive with those major expenses before I turn it into a rental. The property will still cash flow with the extra cost of these expenses. Additionally, the house will likely appraise very favorably after as well with a cash out refi a big possibility

Thoughts?


 YES replace the roof, about 250- 275  a sq depending on pitch. YES replace the furnace, 1800ish, ASSUMING is about 1k- 1500 sq ft house


 Boy things are cheap where you are . roof is $450 to $600 a sq depending on pitch here in Maryland 

Post: Rehab simple contractor agreement

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513

The contractor usually provides the customer with a contract 

Post: Replace roof and HVAC?

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513
Quote from @Dan Frehmeyer:
Quote from @Matthew Paul:

If you have shingles missing , thats probably from wind or storm damage . Have a roofer give you their opinion , and make a claim on insurance . 

I have had multiple roofers say that insurance will replace the whole roof due to that damage. My concern is that I am putting myself in danger of being uninsurable moving forward if I go that route. Am I being unreasonably cautious?

 Thats what insurance is for .  i have 2 properties that had wind damage , Both were covered , both same insurance company and this was 4 years ago and rates didnt go up much at all .  If you are not making claims all the time , you are fine .

DO NOT sign a contract with the roofer until its approved . 

Post: Replace roof and HVAC?

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513

If you have shingles missing , thats probably from wind or storm damage . Have a roofer give you their opinion , and make a claim on insurance . 

Post: Things must be slow for real estate agents

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513
Quote from @Shervin Golgiri:

At the end of the day it's all about the Value you bring to the table.

There are many great agents out there, that worth their weight in gold and I promise you they're not the ones who willing to list a house for 2%.

a great agent can bring more traffic and more offers on table and smoth transaction. But yes I agree, it's a very tough career,  and that's why 83% of people who do become agent quit withing the first two years.


 Thats exactly what they all say , that they bring " Value"  to the table . Well at the end of the day its all about the $$$ . The first time you hear it , it sounds great , when you hear it 80 times , its a BS  sales pitch . A sign of being desperate . 

Post: Things must be slow for real estate agents

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513

I now believe things are much slower for agents than I thought . First , there are only 3 houses for sale under $700K in my zip code  21146 . I am still getting 10 calls a day from agents , even as far away as 75 miles . They all are willing to be my savior . Tops in the industry . And all have buyers looking for a house in my neighborhood . 

So I tell them good , bring your buyer by and I will kick in 1% for a full price cash non contingent contract .  Then the explanation of ALL the HARD work they have to do and they need at least 2 % . So I tell them then tell the person you represent , who hired you to pay you . You work for them not me .  1% of something is better than 3% of nothing . And if things are so great go show your buyer the other 3 houses for sale , especially the 1 on the main highway , or the other thats a foreclosure and needs a full renovation . 

Sure I get it , Agents are in sales , and you have to get a deal to close . But I have had no less than 85 different agents try to get my listing .  Too many agents going for  too little inventory . This puts a seller in the driver seat . 

When they ask "  Is this about the commission ? "   I tell them straight up , " Of course it is at 6% of $670k  thats close to 40 Grand . Sorry but thats not happening . You or any other agent isnt worth that , especially in a market with no inventory .   Yes its  about  money , you wouldnt be calling me if it wasnt would you ? 

Post: When do you tear down vs Renovate in a house currently rentable?

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513

If its constantly rented , then keep renting it , keep the cash rolling in . Do the repairs nessary to keep it going . There will be a point in time when it is beneficial to tear it down and go better . When is that ?  You will figure that out , but now is a bit risky .  I had a similar situation , I kept the house clean , neat and liveable for 10 years , when the last tenant moved out , full gut down to the studs rehab , everything new .  Those 10 years of rent more than paid for the improvements 

Post: Knob and Tube

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513

Bite the bullet and just replace it . get it done and over .  Tenants will plug in what ever they want .

Post: Home Sale advice

Matthew Paul#2 Contractors ContributorPosted
  • Severna Park, MD
  • Posts 6,921
  • Votes 7,513

Odd that its not selling . There is little inventory in Anne Arundel county in the nice areas . You say Annapolis , but Annapolis zip codes go out very far into the county , like Cape St Clair is an Annapolis zip . If its not selling its , location , price , or condition or a combination of all 3