Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Patrick M Nichols

Patrick M Nichols has started 0 posts and replied 109 times.

Post: Had anyone heard of Cogo Capital?

Patrick M NicholsPosted
  • Attorney
  • Boston, MA
  • Posts 109
  • Votes 63

Cogo is a total scam... lots of fees on the front end. They're also happy to commit to whatever your closing date is and blow right through it. Hope you don't put down large earnest money deposits... these guys will make sure you lose them!

Post: Investing while in chapter 13 bankruptcy year one fha

Patrick M NicholsPosted
  • Attorney
  • Boston, MA
  • Posts 109
  • Votes 63

I do not know the answer to your question, but it sounds like you have done some research with regards to FHA. I think your next step should be to find a local lender that offers FHA loan products, talk through your situation, and see what is realistic. Non-FHA financing is likely out of reach for the time being, but it never hurts to ask.

Originally posted by @Willie Cedillo:

@Patrick M Nichols I'm not sure if it counts as evidence but about 5-6 Planks of the bamboo flooring is going to have to be replaced. Two of them (the closest to the dishwasher) popped up and it's extremely visible, you would trip over the area. The couple others will be replaced because you see a big circle wet spot reaching them. 

Thank you for your response!

It might make sense for you to run it by your tenant and take the temperature of the situation. If he agrees to the charges (or maybe even split them), then you are probably on solid ground. It is tough to know without seeing the damage and understanding the surrounding facts of the tenancy.

Originally posted by @Nathan Gesner:
Originally posted by @Patrick M Nichols:
Originally posted by @Nathan Gesner:

@Willie Cedillo the clock starts upon termination of the lease, not the day they hand you the keys. If he is responsible for rent through the month of February, then you terminate the lease at the end of February and then start the clock.

This actually is 100% not true in my state, so check the local laws. Surrendering of keys in MA and acceptance of them by the landlord (although not the law in every state) evidences the end of the tenancy. It does not prorate the rent, but it starts the clock. Not following this would give a housing court judge grounds to award the tenant treble (triple) damages.

I'm not an expert on every state but what you're saying doesn't make sense. According to you, the lease terminates when the tenant hands in their keys. If that's true, a tenant could submit their 30-day notice on March 1, meaning they are responsible for rent through the month of March, but then they could hand you the keys on March 2 and be free of any obligation for March rent. Here's what the MA law says:

(g) fail to return to the tenant the security deposit or balance thereof to which the tenant is entitled after deducting any sums in accordance with M.G.L. c. 186, § 15B, together with interest, within thirty days after termination of occupancy under a tenancy-at-will agreement or the end of the tenancy as specified in a valid written rental agreement;
 

The thirty days starts at the point of termination based on their notice given or the termination point in a written rental agreement. I don't see anything in the law that says they're excused from this requirement if they turn their keys in early.

I would love to see something in writing to support this.


I'm not really following your interpretation. There are two issues:

1. Tenant owes rent through the end of the written term of the lease, but landlord must mitigate their damages (i.e., find a new tenant).
2. The clock starts for the return of the deposit as soon as the landlord accepts the surrender of the keys.

It is illegal discrimination everywhere, however there are exceptions if you live in the building or if an elderly person does. There is also a distinction between rejecting someone with children privately during your screening process and how you advertise. 


Here's a good resource:

https://www.masslegalhelp.org/housing/lt1-chapter-7-forms-housing-discrimination-article

Originally posted by @Nathan Gesner:

@Willie Cedillo the clock starts upon termination of the lease, not the day they hand you the keys. If he is responsible for rent through the month of February, then you terminate the lease at the end of February and then start the clock.

This actually is 100% not true in my state, so check the local laws. Surrendering of keys in MA and acceptance of them by the landlord (although not the law in every state) evidences the end of the tenancy. It does not prorate the rent, but it starts the clock. Not following this would give a housing court judge grounds to award the tenant treble (triple) damages.

I agree with @Erik W., this will vary by state. In my state of MA, wrongly withholding any of the tenant's deposit can expose you to treble damages, so landlords either don't bother with the deposit or they err on the side of caution. The fact that the keys were returned to you though and that you accepted them likely evidences the termination of his tenancy regardless of what the lease says.

As far as cleaning fees, your lease may address this. In my experience the standard is usually leaving the unit "broom clean," as in the tenant is not responsible for making your unit fully market-ready for the next tenant. You're generally expecting to eat the cost for shampooing or replacing old carpets, freshly paint the walls, etc. I would typically charge if there is either trash left behind or if the place is filthy.

As for the dishwasher and in my personal opinion, it doesn't really sound like you have sufficient grounds to withhold any of his deposit here. Do you have evidence that he would have or should have known that it was broken/leaking?

Post: Out of State LLC in another state

Patrick M NicholsPosted
  • Attorney
  • Boston, MA
  • Posts 109
  • Votes 63

Generally, yes, you can. You'll have to register your entity as a foreign corporation in the state first. Your entity will be subject to that state's tax laws as well.

Post: What is the process for a mailbox?

Patrick M NicholsPosted
  • Attorney
  • Boston, MA
  • Posts 109
  • Votes 63

Do you have an HOA? You should be able to have your own mailbox or forward it somewhere temporarily. Sometimes talking directly to the mail carrier helps too since that is usually the person who will return your mail to sender if they don't see you on the nameplate.

Post: Forming a LLC for CA investors

Patrick M NicholsPosted
  • Attorney
  • Boston, MA
  • Posts 109
  • Votes 63
Originally posted by @Sameer Jain:

@Katie Lepore thanks for your detailed response it is helpful . I did not understand what you meant by saying if you incorporate in CA you will have to register LLC as foreign LLC where you buy the property .

If you buy properties in different state is it a good idea to keep them together under one CA LLC or you should have multiple LLC for different states . Although that will involve lot of paperwork and extra expense to maintain these LLC .

A corporation (or an LLC) can do business in the state in which it is incorporated (or organized). In order to do business in a state other than its native state, the corporation would have to register in that state as a foreign entity. A lot of times the cost of doing so is the same as if you just incorporated/organized in that state from the start.

EDIT: I would have to slightly disagree with some of what Katie is saying though. I think a lot of that is unnecessary and overkill that will just cost you a lot more money. Some lawyers will recommend all manner of complicated options when a simple umbrella insurance policy will suffice. Again, retain your own legal counsel because I cannot give you legal advice.