All Forum Posts by: Bart H.
Bart H. has started 11 posts and replied 1128 times.
Post: Odd Situation with Tenants (I am the landlord)

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Ronald Rohde:
Originally posted by @Aaron W.:
@Ned C. how does one get free rent claiming other problems with a house I would think this is only possible if there is a health hazard at the property but if they are claiming that then move out? Rent is not negotiable and contracted as such.
I am new to property management but common sense goes a long way.
Oh boy, you haven't had a professional scammer/tenant. these people know the rules and can live rent free for a long time.
There have been a rash of people who are trying to sell recently rented properties. Any chance that the new "tenants" are trying to "sell" the house?
I dont have the angle figured out, but it feels a lot like a scam of some sort to me.
Post: What happens after offer gets accepted

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Ben M.:
Hello, I am new and working on getting my first rental property. Wanted to see what anyone else's thoughts are but let's say I found a broken down house, contacted the owner, and got my offer accepted.
1) Where do I get a legitimate contract to give to him with inspection and financing contingency. Would it make sense to get a realtor involved even when I initially made contact with the homeowner?
2) How do I know there are no concerns with title or other legal issues...?
3) Are there any other big concerns that I may not have mentioned?
I guess these are some of the things keeping me from pursuing a property outside of a major wholesaler or realtor. It seems to me that the guidance and knowledge of realtors are invaluable especially with pursuing the first property..
I am late to the party, but get a realtor, have them walk you thru the steps for buying your first property.
A great investor minded realtor can help you find properties, help you put value on them, can do the leasing, and will have recommendations for things such as vendors, title companies, inspectors etc.
Originally posted by @Regina Davis:
Originally posted by @Bart H.:
Originally posted by @Regina Davis:
Hello BP! I have been lurking on this site for a couple of years and have enjoyed reading the various posts and listening to the podcasts, along with reading books and researching online. Now that I'm finished with grad school, I'm ready to take action and jump into getting involved with real estate. I'm interested in starting out with assigning contracts while I'm continuing to learn other exit strategies. I'd really like to find a mentor who is really knowledgable about the Dallas area and willing to work with a newbie like me. I know many BP members discourage paying for training when there is so much here for free. True, there is a wealth of information here, but for someone like me who works a busy full-time job and does not have alot of extra time, it can be overwhelming. It requires hours and hours of reading various posts on the site to try to distinguish the smart and good advice and recommendations from the bad advice. It would just be more helpful to me to have a succinct book, training program or mentor that could help put me on a track to begin the business quickly. I hope this makes sense.
I thought I had finally found an answer- there is a local investor here who has probably one of the most comprehensive training programs I've seen as far as the content, contacts and help provided to students. I was informed yesterday, however, that it costs $10K for the 6-month program, which I definitely do not have to spend. Are there any other more reasonable mentors (in DFW) or training programs anyone would recommend? Thanks for any suggestions and I look forward to connecting with more people on the site! :)
Don't start out spending $10K on a training class. Your money is MUCH better spent using that 10K as a down payment to your first deal.
I would find some local meetups to network, listen to the podcasts, read the books that are published on this site. In our case we found an investor friendly real estate agent and she helped us find some properties that have made us a lot of money.
And then pick a couple of neighborhoods maybe a 2 mile be 2 mile block, walk/drive them and get to know what the prices are. Know that chosen neighborhood better than anyone else including the real estate agents.
Then when a deal comes up, you can buy with confidence.
Most guru's act like there is a magic formula that only they know, I just don't think that is the case, and even the ones that do provide value are probably best suited to someone who has done a couple of deals on their own in the first place.
Just my two cents, best of luck to you.
I don't know your situation, but I always recommend people house hack their fist investment. buy a 2-4 unit property and live in one of the units. See if being a landlord is for you, and there is a lot more margin for error on a long term buy and hold. IF you overpay a little on a buy and hold, the return might be a little lower, but over time you will pay down the mortgage, rents will go up and you will have capital appreciation. And you should do ok.
Best of luck to you!!!
Hi Bart,
Thanks for your feedback and well wishes. I'm actually starting off by assigning contracts. I felt more comfortable going that route since I do work a full-time job and want to slowly learn about the other exit strategies. I've read Anson Young's book and I just order Brandon Turner's "No Money Down" books to start reading as well. I'm starting my yellow letter campaign this week, so excited about that. Now I'm getting busy trying to build my buyers list to have some investors to sell these properties to! :) I see that you are in the Dallas area. Do you mind if add you as a connection here? Thanks!
You can definitely add me.
May I suggest something, dont worry at all about the "Buyers list", I wouldnt spend any time on it. If you find a great deal, there are a ton of buyers that can easily be found.
Originally posted by @Olaf Stieber:
Is wholesaling a viable career ? Do you enjoy Wholesaling full time ? I work as Software tester right now and I have an awesome opportunity to study and get into web development. Problem is that I do not like sitting in front of a computer all day.
What has attracted me to wholesaling is the harder you work the more earnings ( In theory). You are essentially creating your own sales job. You are not in an office all day dealing with politics. No matter how hard I work as a web developer I am still an employee and make a certain dollar amount per hour unless I take on freelance gigs.
I also plan on investing in real estate if I go into wholesaling or not as a by and hold investor. So I was thinking instead spending all that time learning web development I could do spent it growing a wholesale business. I could Wholesale part time until I gain traction and then quite my job. Wholesaling would be great in order to be able to source and cherry pick my rentals as well. I am willing to work my butt off to make it happen. I guess I just have to jump in ..Maybe it is fear but I just want to know that Wholesaling is not a pipe dream. I see people saying that 97% of wholesalers don't make it ( Not sure where they get these numbers ?!) But that is concerning...
MY sense is that it is arguably the hardest part of real estate to get into and make a full time career. You have to routinely be able to find properties no one else can find, convince the seller to sell it to you cheap enough to where you can sell it to another investor who can fix it up and make money on the other side.
ITs possible, but you have to know what a property is worth better than an agent, and you have to be able to sell complicated transactions to distressed sellers.
And it seems as though the best wholesalers, ie those who really do it as a fulltime job are those who have invested over time to build mailing lists, personal contacts and have the ability to do very large mailing lists.
I think the easiest way to get into real estate is via house hacking. IE buy a house rent out either other units or other rooms in the house. and then move up from there.
Wholesaling might have the lowest barriers to entry, and you could do it as a side hustle until you decide if it is for you. But I don't think I would go all in with no experience wholesaling being my only income from day one.
Post: Taxing a flip as a rental by leasing the unit prior to sell?

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Eamonn McElroy:
@Bart H. Tax fraud....not mortgage fraud.
(1) You're documenting and treating the property as an investment, while in the back of your mind you know it's going to be a flip. Deception is involved.
(2) The reason you're doing (1) is for financial gain.
That's classic fraud.
I'm not trying to be harsh, but there is a difference between tax evasion and tax avoidance. As a practitioner I can never advocate for the former.
No, I think you are jumping the gun a bit on what I am saying
Its point 1 that I don't agree with. IF my business model is to buy and hold most properties, where at best its a coin flip that we will flip it, I don't know how the IRS can determine tax fraud with we don't actually know what we will do.
Our, and I am sure there are other like us, entire investing model is to target properties where there are multiple means to exit. BRRR, sell to developers, develop ourselves, sell to other investors, live in it etc. I don't see that as tax evasion if you don't really know the exit.
Post: Taxing a flip as a rental by leasing the unit prior to sell?

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Eamonn McElroy:
@Bart H. "Why wouldn't you always set your intent to buy and hold and then decide afterwards to sell it? and wouldn't you have more leeway to avoid the self employment tax ?"
Well it's pretty much textbook tax fraud. Reason number one.
In our case we buy and hold the vase majority of our investments. although we throw a flip in on occasion. And on almost everything we buy we do a fair amount of rehab. Our intent is to BRRR, so why would that be mortgage fraud if we got an out of the park offer on one of the properties we planned to buy and hold?
I mean we, and I assume a lot of investors, look at every property every year to see if the original investment thesis is still in place. If the value has gone up enough on one of our rentals, we'd sell it in a heartbeat.
I don't understand why that would be a classic case of fraud. Honest question, I am not trying to play loose with the law.
Post: Taxing a flip as a rental by leasing the unit prior to sell?

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Eamonn McElroy:
@Jeff Copeland "If one's stated intent is "I'm going to buy this house for investment purposes, hold it (vacant) for two years while I fix it up, then sell it". If that is indeed what happens, why would that not qualify as a long term capital gain? Where does the IRS state that you have to rent it out? And why would they care?"
They care because they would like to argue the income is ordinary income subject to self-employment taxes. You would like to argue it's long-term capital gains. Tax treatment is very different.
There's a large body of case law that establish only two things matter. (1) Original intent and (2) all the taxpayer's facts and circumstances. You're describing a situation where the original intent, right out of the gate, was to resell the property for a profit, not to hold as a long-term investment.
Can a property that's sold 6 months after acquiring be called a capital gain? Yes. Can a property that's sold after 2 years of renting be called a flip? Yes.
Document intent for the property on day one. File it away with your company's docs.
@Dave Toelkes "You need to be very careful with your terminology. If you "buy a flip" then the implied intent is to sell."
Exactly.
Why wouldn't you always set your intent to buy and hold and then decide afterwards to sell it? and wouldn't you have more leeway to avoid the self employment tax ?
Obviously wouldn't work for high volume flippers, but if you are a low volume investor who does both flips and buy and hold wouldn't it benefit you to classify everything at buy and hold?
Post: Is this really the reality of property management?

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Skye Anderson:
Love all that you shared @Joel Owens!
I am definitely considering Austin... and that's where I originally started looking... yet I felt like I couldn't compete. It felt very overwhelming.
The team who sold my home here in Austin recently has a team in St. Louis and there were so many opportunities there that I decided to start there. It somehow felt less intimidating.
I haven't closed on my first deal yet (I have two under contract), but I've already learned a ton that I could have never learned from any book, seminar, etc. I now feel much more prepared. And I imagine by the time I close on these two properties I will feel even more confident. At which point I will be pursing opportunities in Austin. :-)
Thank you for all of the info to consider and for helping me feel encouraged! :-)
Kindly,
Skye
May I ask, do you know much about St. Louis?
I thru the years have loved the city. But honestly, its a city with some major major issues, especially downtown. Its a city with some pretty major crime issues, a decaying manufacturing base etc.
in 1970 Stl, Had 622K people, it is at 319K in 2010, and hearing it might drop below 300 in the next census.
I just don't think its a place I would want to be investing without being experienced in the city. But more importantly, I really don't like investing in areas that are losing population.
Originally posted by @Mark Wood:
I like to buy and sell houses that a teacher or a cop could buy. Those properties will always be in demand. As soon as your go to 1.5x or 2x that type of property, it takes longer to sell and the sales commissions take a bigger portion of your profit on each deal.
I am right there with you, we like properties we can make money (or at least break even) around $1,500-1,800.
Post: Why is my lender saying im supposed to occupy for 2 yrs

- Dallas, TX
- Posts 1,165
- Votes 744
Originally posted by @Cisco Hood:
I think they will, but I honestly dont know what % down they will require on a duplex. The only time we house hacked a duplex it was back in 2013, and the standards were really tight at that time. Doing it from memory, but I seem to recall we put 10% down.
To be fair we had another property we were going to end up renting out behind us, with at that time no landlord experience, so our numbers on DTI, cash for a down payment etc were all really tight. The lenders at the time wouldnt look at any potential rental income to help us get approved for the loan. So we werent really in the market for any smaller of a down payment than 10%.
A good mortgage broker should be able to help you out there, they will have access to multiple lenders and be able to provide more flexibility on loan products.