Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Justin B.

Justin B. has started 19 posts and replied 651 times.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Kyle Hipp:

Justin, I think the point people are making is that even though the property is occupied now does not mean you don't have to include a vacancy factor when describing your analysis. Lots of folks do rent -P&I - T&I = net income and it does make a good story but being a real estate investing site, most enjoy the nitty gritty more. The biggest one I see is that you have not replied regarding Capex. You state that the majors really in good shape but you know that it is unrealistic to not plan to replace the furnace, water heater, roof, ect ect. Those go into your numbers to show your realistic returns. The purchase price of a property is different when there is a new roof compared to a 20 year old roof or a kitchen and bathroom from 1983..

Now that I have 10 properties, I don't factor in capex expenses into my monthly numbers. I handle that by keeping a minimum balance in my bank account for my portfolio in case major items like that happen. I also don't plan on replacing big ticket items for every house, nor do I expect more than 1 or 2 at a time if they do happen. Also, we don't buy properties that need "majors" replaced soon. Our strategy for SFR's is only a few more years (5-7 tops). We don't ever "plan" on replacing them ever for the SFR's, so I think it's very realistic to not plan to replace all the majors during the life of the investment. If I planned to replace all you mentioned on every house, I'd go bankrupt. If we inspect and find out that any of the major's are due to be replaced within our scheduled investment window, we either have the owner replace it, adjust our price to compensate, or walk away.

Also, I've mentioned before (in various places) that my first property that I bought in April of 2010, the air conditioner went out in August of 2010 and we had to replace it.  All in all, it was around $4k.  It sucked but we kept going.  Outside of that, in 9 properties over 5 years, we haven't had any major's replaced on any property, however, if we do, we are fully prepared for the expense.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Mel Jeffrey:

@Justin B. congratulations and keep up the great work.  I have a great relationship with my banker and get favorable terms as well.  Please keep posting.

Mel, any chance you want to share your story on what you're relationship with the bank is, how it got started, and what you currently get on average for terms?  When I tell people about my relationship with the bank, I always get a variety of "I hate you" looks and I keep saying it's the same relationship that anyone can build over time.  It would be nice to have others in the same boat to help encourage the many that are frustrated that there is hope, it just takes time.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @J Scott:
Originally posted by @Justin B.:
Originally posted by @John Thedford:

I see a problem with the numbers as well. Until you calculate vacancies, maintenance, CapEx, etc you don't have a true picture of your returns. Also, as other mentioned, what about closing costs?

There is no problem with the numbers. This is an SFR, so when it goes vacant, it's 100% vacant. Again, I could put an estimate of vacancy but I chose not to because it's currently rented and not vacant. When I first evaluate properties (what I call my 5 minute analysis), I use 10% as a vacancy rate, $50/month per $1,000/month rent (Over the years I've found that to be very accurate). All the other expenses I have (Taxes, Insurance, PM) are pretty easy to get accurate up front. Even at that, the numbers still blow me away.

I think John's point was that you're leaving several expenses out of your cash flow equation. When you are inaccurate with your cash flow, your cash on cash return is going to be inaccurate as well. Your true cash flow, and resulting cash on cash return, will be lower once you factor in things like vacancy, maintenance, Capex, etc.

Not factoring in longer term expenses into your cash flow and CoC is like claiming that your meal is free because the waiter hasn't brought you the bill yet.

I agree.  There are always ways to play with numbers.  Like I said in a previous post, I'm not using vacancy because it's already rented and we've already seen the place and know we have no upfront or deferred maintenance.  all the "majors" are in good shape, etc.  Of course something can always happen.  When I ran my initial numbers, I used my standard 10% vacancy and $50/month misc to cover maintenance upkeep.  My cash on cash return using those numbers is still well over 100%.  The normal cash on cash return we look at is around 40-50% on average so even with that in there, I'm double what I'm use to so I'm happy :)

Plus, Cash on Cash is just the sexiest number.  Saying I bought a property for $350/month (the most important number to me) cash flow isn't near as sexy of a title :)

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Joel Owens:

Over the years on here I have heard many posts about buying houses cheap in OK areas.

What I hear very little to almost zero posts about is future update posts how they have owned a bunch of those houses for five years and they are still throwing off tons of cash flow with no issues.

I will never be sold on low income tenants and ok areas but that is just me. I want to buy the crappiest property in the best area. If a shift happens in an OK area to bad you could lose the whole investment.  

Understood.  The majority of the houses we own are $70-$100k and rent for an average of $1,000/month.  However, this property and a couple of others we have are a third of the price and cash flow better.  No matter what you do in real estate, there is always risk.  This one just happens to be a risk we're comfortable with.  We done a lot of analyzing and another thing that keeps the risk low is that we're experts in the area we invest.  That doesn't mean something bad won't happen, but again, it's a risk we're ok with.  And keep in mind, I wouldn't necessarily call this low income for MS.  $750/month is not bad.  MS has a VERY low cost of living.  I know the "low income" areas well and I wouldn't be caught dead in the them....actually, I probably would be dead if I was in them.  They typically are the $200-$350/month range and are being bought and sold for $10k or less.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

@Justin B.

  I also learned all about Yazoo clay in Jackson ... !! 

And bought a bunch of new construction for go zone bene's .. I am now selling them all off they are in Madison,  Patrick farms, Brandon.  I am in Jackson 4 times a year

 Yea, that's pretty much why basements don't really exist in MS.  The effort and cost to put one in is prohibitive among other things.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

@Justin B.

  our post jumped over each other.. your description of the deal makes total sense now.

Many community banks are precluded from lending to anyone who does not live within 100 miles of the asset.. so your Dad living there checks that box. And with MS dual action deficiency statues the PG's in that state are very strong.. and since there is no equity in the deal the deal was made almost like a unsecured LOC they just happen to tie an OERO to it and they can do that with some latitude.. I had a very large line of credit back in the Day with Community bank based out of Hattiesburg.. they have branch's in Jackson.. But at the time I was the largest HML in Jackson and had a very large presence there even though I did not live there.. Plus the financial strength ... Too bad we did not meet a few years ago I would have sold you 50 of my Jackson OREO's all with no money down and Zero interest !!

The person who we work with the most actually used to work at Community Bank back in the day. My first car loan when I was 16 was done by that bank. I don't even know if they still exist anymore. Eventually we want to be out of SFR's and into MFR's but in MS and TN, the pickings are just too good right now for SFR's. It's hard to turn them down especially since we've been looking for MFR's for quite a while and just aren't finding deals that are any good.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

@Justin B.

   now that your actually describing your TRUE relationship with this bank,,, your characterizations that investors can find 5% down bank financed deals is a tad misleading :).. .. So you have a long track record you lived in the community and you obviously have financial strength and you add that up and put your PG in there and yes you will get deals. I am sure many locals get the same..

from your first posts it looked like you live in Maryland and just happened to stumble in the the great state of MS and found this increbible leveraged bank deal.. that's why every one wanted to know how you did it.... Good job though take the deals that you have earned. its all about track record and performance

I wouldn't classify anything I said as misleading.  I was just stating what I got.  The post was all about the deal, never "how" I got my terms.  It looks like people focused in on the 5% down so I elaborated and answered questions.  How I got started and they way I do things I've never hidden.  I unfortunately don't have time to lay out my life story every time I post.  That's why I have the blog :)

I will say this though.  My relationship with our bank is nothing that every single person out there can't eventually get.  My "personal" history with the bank is that I have financed a couple of cars through them.  I never even had a mortgage with them and when I moved to Maryland 12 years ago, I ended my personal banking relationship with them all together (closed my account and went with BoA up here).  My brother and father do still use them as their personal bank.  If you have a bank you hold a car loan and mortgage with, then you have the exact same relationship I had with our bank in 2010 when we went to them for our first loan.  In fact, they didn't even want to finance our first property because we had no business history with them so we had to do owner financing to start.  All they knew us for was personal items.  They did finance it 6 months later in a re-finance type scenario.

So the personal relationship (again, nothing more than anyone else has with their current bank), several years of payment history, and several properties later, we have a great relationship and we get great terms, but we earned it.   I do think relationships like this can only happen with smaller banks.  If you currently bank with BoA, Wells Fargo, Regions, etc, then I doubt very seriously you'd be able to garnish a relationship that would get you the terms we have.  You may be stuck at "normal" terms forever unless you're a big dog financing buildings in major cities.

Also, we did find one property out of state that we considered purchasing at one point.  When we went to the bank, they said they would require 40% down because they don't do a lot of business out of state.  So even our relationship has it's limits.  If we wanted to buy up here in Maryland, I'd be in the same spot as many of you.  I'd be lucky to get 20%from a local bank here.

On the topic of 3 of us, yes, we have 3 people that can personally guarantee loans but again, that's 3 people.  3 people that have to split everything we get.  So it takes a lot longer to get to a goal with 3 people than it does with 1.  The good definitely outweighs the bad in my opinion.  We've got 3 people looking towards this income to retire on instead of 1.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

@Justin B.

Are you buying in Jackson ?  Jackson has some of the best rent to purchase price ratios for a state capital in the country...

 You are right on.  Jackson, MS and Memphis, TN are some of the best markets in the country right now for buy and hold properties.  There are others as well but we're interested in buying where we have a presence.  When we're all full time doing this, I'm sure we will venture out.  We're buying sub $100k properties and cash flowing hundred of dollars a month even with low % down payments.

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

@Justin B.

  cool are you buying in Jackson ?  or someplace else.   those are very favorable terms however I am going to go out on a limb and say that PG is what is carrying the transaction.

But for someone who does not live in MS to get a local bank to finance you that is very rare.  The local MS banks will finance locals though in these asset class's.

And if you ran into me 2 years ago I would have sold you some of my MS OREO with same down and ZERO percent financing :)  but I am all out of them now... !!

 We actually own in Jackson, Brandon, and Hattiesburg.  This particular house is in Jackson.  And I'll be clear.  If you read my blog or my profile here, you'll see that I grew up in Jackson, MS (first 23 years of my life), then moved to Maryland after that.  My Dad still lives in the Jackson area and my brother now lives in Memphis, TN (he was in Jackson when we started this business), which is where we own a few properties as well.  So I don't want to put a false illusion that I just up and started purchasing property in MS and found a bank who was willing to give a guy who lives 1,000 miles away 5% down on properties.  another reason may be that all 3 of us personally guarantee these loans as well.  I'm guessing the bank feel pretty well covered in that respect and I'm sure that contributes to the favorable terms we get, but I'll take it :)

Post: 170% Cash on Cash Return! THAT JUST HAPPENED!

Justin B.Posted
  • Investor
  • Gaithersburg, MD
  • Posts 659
  • Votes 441
Originally posted by @Jeff S.:

Personally don't place value on cash on cash because you can play games to get big numbers @Justin B.That is ok though because there are plenty of big players that do.

What is important IMO is the return on the entire investment because you can go negative equity in a heart beat.

Understood.  That's why I put about 20 different numbers in my post.  Different people look at different things.  Cash on Cash is not my #1 number.  Cash Flow per month is my main number that I care about.  I don't even care about equity.  As long as I can rent it and meet my goal of cash flow per month, that's all I care about.  Once cash flow reaches a certain point, that's when I can retire and do this full time.  I'm on a mission! :)