Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Stuart M.

Stuart M. has started 14 posts and replied 111 times.

Post: Our first tax return, make sure we are doing this right

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Lionel Li:

Originally posted by @Stuart M.:
Originally posted by @Steven D.:
Originally posted by @Stuart M.:
Originally posted by @Jeff Filali:

I'm not a CPA, so not giving real tax advice... But I would think tools purchased to work on your rental property would qualify as business equipment and qualify for section 179 deduction.  But you really need to consult a CPA.

 I mean...I'm tryin here...

 I'm sorry but you are trying to get answers from a forum, not a qualified CPA. Yes there are very valuable resources here and qualified CPAs but they don't work for free. Get a reccommendation for a great real estate CPA in your area, sit down and have a chat with them. They will be able to answer your questions more accurately in an hour then hundreds of posts from a mix of amateurs to experts on a forum can do for you. 

 I think this is a pretty weird response to get on an open forum where thousands of people are sharing their knowledge on a diverse range of subjects for free but thank you for taking the time and contributing.

Would you give that answer to someone who asked about the 203k program? I mean, they could just read everything written by the FHA and figure out all the answers on their own, but its a shortcut to ask people who have already done so. And I guess people could say "I could tell you but I think you should pay someone to tell you instead" but i personally don't think that is the most friendly of responses.

I think people are just overwhelmed by accounting and the IRS, but I am not.  I just don't have the time to read the entire tax code to get answers to these relatively simple questions, just like everyone else here is doing with mortgage brokers, investors, etc.  I take time and answer questions, should I be charging people to share my knowledge and experience?

I don't think his response merits paragraphs about how much we're charging for advice but, that's really all you're getting on a forum, advice. Tax & Legal questions involves professionals who can tailor your situation to advise you, professionally. I think Steven gave you the right advice to seek a professional..also..I wouldn't compare investor or mortgage questions with tax questions. I'm an accountant but, I go to my CPA when I have my tax issues. Dealing with the IRS when it's not just a simple Income Tax Return is always a pain, hope you figure your situation out, people are just trying to steer you in the right direction.

 I don't think asking how to account for improvements to an asset in one year before it was placed into service the next year is really that complicated of a question for your average CPA.  But I guess I could be wrong, now I'm getting concerned that I'm going to have to find a top of the line CPA because this is way beyond what average CPA's seem to understand.

I was aware that I could pay someone for the answer, thank you for taking the time to respond.

I guess when I get the answer I will share it openly so that anyone in this situation can have the information they need.

Post: Our first tax return, make sure we are doing this right

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Steven D.:
Originally posted by @Stuart M.:
Originally posted by @Steven D.:
Originally posted by @Stuart M.:
Originally posted by @Jeff Filali:

I'm not a CPA, so not giving real tax advice... But I would think tools purchased to work on your rental property would qualify as business equipment and qualify for section 179 deduction.  But you really need to consult a CPA.

 I mean...I'm tryin here...

 I'm sorry but you are trying to get answers from a forum, not a qualified CPA. Yes there are very valuable resources here and qualified CPAs but they don't work for free. Get a reccommendation for a great real estate CPA in your area, sit down and have a chat with them. They will be able to answer your questions more accurately in an hour then hundreds of posts from a mix of amateurs to experts on a forum can do for you. 

 I think this is a pretty weird response to get on an open forum where thousands of people are sharing their knowledge on a diverse range of subjects for free but thank you for taking the time and contributing.

Would you give that answer to someone who asked about the 203k program? I mean, they could just read everything written by the FHA and figure out all the answers on their own, but its a shortcut to ask people who have already done so. And I guess people could say "I could tell you but I think you should pay someone to tell you instead" but i personally don't think that is the most friendly of responses.

I think people are just overwhelmed by accounting and the IRS, but I am not.  I just don't have the time to read the entire tax code to get answers to these relatively simple questions, just like everyone else here is doing with mortgage brokers, investors, etc.  I take time and answer questions, should I be charging people to share my knowledge and experience?

 This was a response after multiple people, including a CPA from Florida said that you should consult a CPA. I would suggest that someone looking to use a 203k program should read the material about the 203k program yes. If there is something they don't understand then they can ask but the documents provided or people certified in the industry are the best source of information. If you make a mistake and an IRS auditor says why did you do take this deduction? Will a good answer be "Someone on a forum said that I could do it", or have the CPA you had assist with you handle any situation that arises. 

 What are you looking to accomplish here?

Post: Our first tax return, make sure we are doing this right

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Dave Toelkes:

@Stuart M.

You said that you did all the labor yourself.  Unfortrunately, you cannot include your own labor in your make ready costs.

 Drywall labor was other people i paid, i know i cant include my own labor. 

Post: Our first tax return, make sure we are doing this right

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Steven D.:
Originally posted by @Stuart M.:
Originally posted by @Jeff Filali:

I'm not a CPA, so not giving real tax advice... But I would think tools purchased to work on your rental property would qualify as business equipment and qualify for section 179 deduction.  But you really need to consult a CPA.

 I mean...I'm tryin here...

 I'm sorry but you are trying to get answers from a forum, not a qualified CPA. Yes there are very valuable resources here and qualified CPAs but they don't work for free. Get a reccommendation for a great real estate CPA in your area, sit down and have a chat with them. They will be able to answer your questions more accurately in an hour then hundreds of posts from a mix of amateurs to experts on a forum can do for you. 

 I think this is a pretty weird response to get on an open forum where thousands of people are sharing their knowledge on a diverse range of subjects for free but thank you for taking the time and contributing.

Would you give that answer to someone who asked about the 203k program? I mean, they could just read everything written by the FHA and figure out all the answers on their own, but its a shortcut to ask people who have already done so. And I guess people could say "I could tell you but I think you should pay someone to tell you instead" but i personally don't think that is the most friendly of responses.

I think people are just overwhelmed by accounting and the IRS, but I am not.  I just don't have the time to read the entire tax code to get answers to these relatively simple questions, just like everyone else here is doing with mortgage brokers, investors, etc.  I take time and answer questions, should I be charging people to share my knowledge and experience?

Post: Our first tax return, make sure we are doing this right

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Jeff Filali:

I'm not a CPA, so not giving real tax advice... But I would think tools purchased to work on your rental property would qualify as business equipment and qualify for section 179 deduction.  But you really need to consult a CPA.

 I mean...I'm tryin here...

Post: Your experience using 203k loans

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Andre Wilson:

Hello BP,

I'm currently searching for a 3-4 unit in the Rochester, NY area and will going through ways to finance my first purchase I came across the 203k loan.

I've done some research on this particular loan and it seems like it has many great advantages that may work well for me, but I would like to know from previous experiences, what are you guys opinions.

if anyone has used one before how was your experience? what are some things I should be aware of? pros and cons? will you use again and is it a smooth process?

Thank you!

Look at HomeStyle mortgage instead, when we looked at both last year with the higher rate and PMI terms of 203k it made financial sense to go with HomeStyle instead, there might have been other reasons I'm forgetting too.

If I remember correctly, HomeStyle was 5% down, 203k was 3.5% down but 1.75% added to the loan one time PMI you will never get back, and you have to pay PMI monthly on it still, and its crazy expensive, something like $70 per 100k per month instead of $35 per 100k per month on the HomeStyle. I'd rather take 1.5% off the principle than lose 1.75% to the bank. And your payment ends up the same or worse even if you get a better rate!

I mean, if you can't come up with 5% instead of 3.5% you can go with it, but you're getting killed forever.

Post: Dumpster prices in your area?

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45
Originally posted by @Peter S.:

$225 for a 20 yard in Central Florida. As long as it doesn't go over the height limit and isnt filled with concrete, its flat fee.  Looks like I'm getting a great deal compared to other parts of the country.  

 SWS used to drive all the way to central florida to dump its trash from south florida.  That's why waste management bought them out.  What competition?

Post: Dumpster prices in your area?

Stuart M.Posted
  • Boca Raton, FL
  • Posts 111
  • Votes 45

$725 for 30 yd, but you're going over the weight if you fill it.  Had a $1500 once.  South Florida.  Waste Management bought everyone up, they got that monopoly pricing going on now.

BTW - anyone want to be a millionaire? Start a rolloff company in south florida.  Sell to WM.  Rinse repeat.

Originally posted by @Peter S.:

Im in Miami, so I cant speak about furnances. But I can assume that Miami's AC can equate to Michigan's heating. 


 Heat is way more expensive in MI than AC in Miami.  One quick shortcut, look at government recommended mins for insulation.  Also, we have aluminum framed windows down here.  That's crazy talk up north with the heat loss.

Not sure how your building is set up, but did you increase attic insulation?  That was insane how much I saved.  If I knew then what i know now, I would have filled my entire attic (save a small space for air circulation) with blown in insulation up north.

Wait, $500-$800 TOTAL, not per unit?  In Michigan?  I remember $200-$300 gas bills in the winter in PA and WI.  On one house.

Say you get elec units installed, 14 of them at 2-3k each (cheapest I can imagine.) Whats your yearly gas bill?  How long will it take to get your money back, if you're assuming no one leaves, no rent reductions for adding $100 to each elec bill, etc?  Seems insane.

How wouldn't it be cheaper, if you were dead set, to get meters put in for each gas line?  Is that impossible?