All Forum Posts by: Stuart M.
Stuart M. has started 14 posts and replied 111 times.
Post: Price to rent ratios - where to find?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Sam Shueh:
You are asking information that does not exist. Actual rents are not reported if it is a hot housing area, there is still some room for haggling. You must narrow your search to places you know. Cap Rate is what professionals use.
In hot urban area like both coasts, it is less than 2%, middle west you are lucky to get 4-6% these days. Good luck.
Rents are reported by agents to the mls in my area, I know not craigslist listings, but i thought that was standard. Plus price to rent maps used to exist...
Post: Price to rent ratios - where to find?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
I’ve always used the map tool on Craigslist. You can zero in on any neighborhood you want and see what the rents are.
I can also do that with realtor, zillow, etc, but I'm still back to hundreds of manual calculations.
I can't believe this information isn't available anywhere, already calculated. What I need is like, average rent at any given lat/long point (within X ft around that point) or neighborhood, and avg sale prices too. I want to sort for areas instead of having to look at 500 houses, one at a time, each day.
Post: Is Section 8 Housing as bad as people say?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Ola Dantis:
@Matthew Zorn I think it's all about the tenant screening process at the end of the day.
Let's not forget that these people are just people too looking for shelter for themselves and their family. Do we hear a ton of horror stories about Section 8? Absolutely, but are they great Section 8 tenants out there, of course. Realistically, this is the general rule for people around the world (good and bad).
So, vetting your tenants should lead you to secure a decent tenant.
Hope this helps. Good luck. Thanks! - Ola
The worst horror story I've heard recently is that youtube kid who rents a house in Beverly Grove for 14k a month and totally destroys the place.
Never heard of a Sec 8 person causing damage to a multi million dollar property.
Post: Any High W2 earners out there?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Buy art, get it appraised for more, donate to a museum. If you get it appraised for at least triple it will save you on taxes. (Example, $1 mil spent, $5 mil "donation," 37% = $1.85 mil reduction in taxes.)
Or did they close that loophole?
Bonus: free admission to museum.
Post: Any High W2 earners out there?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Yong Park:
Originally posted by @Bilal A.:
@Laith Ali I agree with you. Why most of my colleagues are OK with giving away half their hard earned sweat money (Spending endless hours away from their young families and giving up sleep) is beyond me!
Great thread. Very relevant to me. I too am a high W2 (and high K1) earner. I am very grateful to be in this situation. I have been driving all of my friends and my accountant crazy by pestering them about how to reduce my taxable income in the coming years.
I will be paying $30k more in taxes next year compared to the prior. The 20% pass through deduction does not apply to my wife and me.
I too have maxed out our pension plans including a Defined Benefits program which allows me to put away more than 120k a year.
So far, I have been unsuccessful in finding a way to reduce my tax burden.
I am a newbie to real estate investing, sadly. But not for long. My wife is reluctantly willing to become a "real estate professional" after I have nagged her about it for a year. So my goal for 2018 is to buy either a small manageable Multi-family property or a few SFH's. I preference is to buy out of state because it is virtually impossible to buy anything around here in Orange County CA that will not be cash flow deep negative without putting down a boatload of money. It is just very difficult to be a "real estate professional" with only out of state properties ( I think?).
So I feel your pain. Again. I am very thankful to the good Lord for being in this position. But I too am looking to make some strategic moves for 2018.
God Bless and Happy New Year!!
Yong
Got rich in high tax Orange County CA, complains about high taxes (oh the pain!)....gotta love it!
Could you imagine if you lived in a high tax country?
Post: Any High W2 earners out there?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Bettina F.:
The ultimate answer is to vote for political candidates who believe in smaller government.
But he got rich in a country that voted for people that believe in larger government, isn't that what you're implying? Maybe he should vote for even larger government people and get even richer!
Why can't people leave politics off here?
Post: Any High W2 earners out there?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Bilal A.:
To the High W2 earning BP members out there, what strategies have you used to decrease your W2 taxable income? Depending on what state you earn your wages, income tax rates of 40-50% are unreasonable. Most of you likely don’t qualify as real estate professionals and won’t unless you quit or dramatically reduce your regular work hours so what tax planning strategies (particular to real estate investing) have you used besides taking depreciation and mortgage interest deductions? I realize that with enough properties, you can eventually replace your W2 with passive income and deduct losses against it. Do you massively leverage your high income to get loans and build your portfolio fast? Paying multiple three figures in taxes plus FICA is simply ridiculous. Thanks in advance!
Don't feel bad, my rich Canadian friends assume 50% off the top of everything they make goes to the government, its pretty standard worldwide in highly developed countries, actually a little cheaper here.
FICA tops out at 8k for W2 workers. If you're making 500k+ that's a rounding error. It's worse when you're making exactly the 127k limit!
Post: Price to rent ratios - where to find?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Brian Garrett:
You have to study the neighborhoods and areas you are interested in.
See what properties are selling for and what they are renting for.
Then just run the numbers and analyze the deals.
I think you'll quickly find that South Florida is not really a cash flow market though.
Price to rent ratios are horrible and properties sell quickly and at premiums!
Yes, this is what I've realized, which is why I'm looking to find the "least worst" rent to price ratios to concentrate my efforts. South Florida seems too big to be an expert in every area and analyze every house, I'm trying to narrow it down.
The problem is finding average rents, not average listed rents; then you analyze one deal, which might not be representative of the area, you're back to square one. So I'm trying to find better data so I can run a lot of deals all at one time, or find someone that has. There used to be "heat maps" on the internet of price/rent ratio, and they release the figures for the entire MSA down here, but no one has smaller areas calculated...
What are your investment strategies down here?
Post: Why is cash flow important to many here?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Jason D.:
Wow, where to?
I moved from PGH to MIA.
But in any case, we love it down here and we couldn't change locations if we wanted anyways, so that works out. But South Florida home prices...yikes. It's hard enough to find House 2 down here, House 1 is a leprechaun...and if caught, someone has already written a cash check for it, you have no time for financing and any of that nonsense.
BTW, my PGH RE taxes were much lower than MIA RE taxes due to no income tax down here. Like a comparable house in a comparable neighborhood is not only 2x as expensive but 2x the taxes! Total tax burden was the roughly the same.
Post: Why is cash flow important to many here?

- Boca Raton, FL
- Posts 111
- Votes 45
Originally posted by @Cara Lonsdale:
So when do you intend to sell propert # 2? What if you are at the point of retirement, and need to cash out to get that equity, and it is 2008.....and now your property is NOT worth $905K, but rather $290K, and you are at a loss.
THEN what if NOT ONLY do you have no cash flow, but now it is NEGATIVE, because not only the RE sales market tanked, but also the rental market tanked, and you are paying OUT $1,250 per month just to hold on to the property that isn't worth the money you paid for it years ago?
Cash flow is important for many reasons. However, it's required in order to bridge the gap between market waves. When appreciation becomes depreciation, cash flow is what will get you through to make sure that your decision to sell is based on a favorable choice, not a requirement.
A smart investor will buy and sell in any market condition, but will shift to accommodate that condition.
I know it is easy to put pen and paper to calculate a perfect scenario. However, there are alot of unknowns out there that make your calculations irrelevant. I am a Realtor (since 1997) and a seasoned investor (since 2002) with a portfolio of properties, and I would take that $100K property over the other every day and twice on Sundays.
BTW, the"what if" example I gave you above....true story. It happened.
I'm trying to isolate a few variables here, not throw some more on the pile.
But it its 2008, the stock market cratered even more than the average house price, so what if all that money you made from investing your cashflow for House 1, 640k, is suddenly cut in half, but my home value has only declined 40%? What if there is a plague and half of everyone dies, how does this effect home prices and rents? What if we get into another housing bubble and I sell all my homes at the peak for millions and y'all are collecting 1k "cash flow"? What if... We could play this game all day. I chose a 2% conservative appreciation because that is what I expect inflation to average and house prices have tracked that over the long run. It could change! If we are in a recession the exact year I want to retire, I will go on SS, go live in a shack and wait it out. We're talking about 3 decades from now.
Rent prices did not decline much in the last recession in most cities, if at all, I checked FRED. I can't imagine we'll have a worse fall from prices right now than we did back then. If we fall from higher rents, well, then my cash flow will be reduced just like everyone elses. A lot of people lost during the downturn, even "cash flow" investors. A lot of it had to do with what city you were lucky/unlucky enough to buy in and other things beyond your control. I get that nothing is guaranteed.