Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Andy Nathan

Andy Nathan has started 14 posts and replied 189 times.

Post: FAILED Direct Mailing Campaign (sort of)

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118

I am not doing a lot of direct mailing but I have over 15 years of marketing experience. The key is to test, test, test until it works. Like Bob said above, you need the right mix of list, message, and mailer. 

You never know until you keep testing what works and what does not. Then the market changes and you need to start testing something new. 

Post: The Idea of Renting out Current Home to Buy a New Home

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118
Quote from @Kathleen Park:

I was wondering if any real estate professionals like you can prove this to be a good move in terms of investing. If you were me, what would you focus more on?

I live in the West Town area of Chicago. I’ve recently been thinking about renting out my current primary home (built & moved in 2019: value $550K: have a mortgage loan of 2.65%) and buying a new primary home (built in 2020: value $700K: thinking 20% down +80% loan to purchase) in the same area. However, I have a few concerns:

Pros:

  • Living condition: 1400 sqft → 1700 sqft with some boutique features
  • The rental market seems good in this area.
  • Another property is added to my existing real estate portfolio, which currently includes two other properties.

Cons:

  • Interest rate: 7% - No guarantee of decreasing the rate, which means there might be no opportunity for refinancing in the future.
  • The current home is too new to be rented out.
  • People often say not to buy property in Chicago due to high taxes and low appreciation.
  • There’s no necessity of moving since I have a decent primary home.

Any professional advice would be helpful. I really appreciate your time!


 I see some great comments from other people.But I just want to add my two cents.  Take this as it is for just two cents. 

First, people need a place to live. You have a lot of quality renters there because of the fact that there's a large demand to be close to downtown. 

Second, do the numbers work. Ignore interest rates. If you make more money in cashflow from your rental than your current outflow it doesnt matter. I dont know your numbers but assume you pay $3,000 per month on your current property (PITI). Can you rent it out for $3,500-$4,500 per month consistently?

If you then buy another similar house at $650K at 7%, you can possibly cover the rate increase and double your appreciation. Win-Win. 

Plus, over time you will get more cashflow and more equity.

Make sense?

Post: Tenant vacated property without notice

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118
Quote from @Tom McGee:

I just had a tenant vacate without notice in PA. She is on a one year lease until April 2025. Two weeks ago, she sent a request to leave and I prepared an agreement so I could acquire a new tenant first. She never responded. 

Today she moved out and vacated the property. I sent communication but it has not been responded to.

Can anyone provide advice:

What are my legal rights?

At what point can I begin to market the property and find a new tenant?

am I legally allowed to keep her last months rent and security deposit?

Is there a legal letter I should send?

What should I be proactive about?  Things to avoid?

Looking for some advice. 


Did she destroy your property? If not, your legal rights should include jumping up and down that they left your property before they did real damage. Get the new tenant in place and call it a day.

Post: STR in Chicago question

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118
Quote from @Adriana McLaughlin:

There is a condo in Chicago that allows STR. If I were to buy it, would I have to apply for the license with the city, or is the license for the property and not the owner?

Thanks, new to this STR stuff.

Adriana


 Make sure your property and you qualify. They have strict requirements.https://www.chicago.gov/city/en/depts/bacp/supp_info/sharedh... 

Post: Property Management Issue

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118

Few questions.


First, will the rehab help you rent the property to better tenants at a higher rate? In other words, are the upgrades an expense or investment?

Second, can you flip the property now and get a better return on your investment to flip to another property? 

Third, if you self managed would you make these changes? If not, why?

Post: Is there a Bigger Pockets app?

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118
Quote from @Jason Bohling:

@Andreas W. That sucks. It’s still working for me, I have an iPhone, though.

I can directly tell that my usage on BP went down tremendously when they stopped supporting the app.

Post: Hire a property manager or not?

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118

A lot of good points on both sides. I do PM in addition to managing my own rentals. Some of my clients want full service, others just don't want to deal with maintenance calls. Don't look at it as black and white 10%. Think of it as an entrepreneur. 

It is why I offer fractional property management services to my clients. What fraction of property management do you need for your rentals? As you grow, the answer will become clearer.

Post: Water bill is 400% higher then last bill, faulty meter or leaks?

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118

@Henry Lazerow reach out to the city of Chicago but it will take time. They are not known for customer service. Balance aggressively contacting them with politeness.

Post: Proof of Funds with multiple investors

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Andy Nathan

i didn't look on your profile to see how much experience you have, but just curious - how does it make sense to have 3-5 people split a single SF?  is it high end / seven figures?  otherwise seems like way too much complexity / too many cooks in the kitchen


I get where you are coming in with the cooks in the kitchen. Some of the deals we are analyzing will be close to seven figures. We have smaller deals that will not require as many investors. That is why I was asking because having this many investors on a deal is still new to me. 

Post: Proof of Funds with multiple investors

Andy NathanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 199
  • Votes 118

Thanks @John Warren and @Jonathan Klemm for your answers. Definitely appreciated!  

I feel like I would be repeating my answer, replying to you both individually. Some investors want to work with us before we find the property. Finding an investment based on what works for your investors and you is always easier anyway. 

Therefore, I don't know the agent involved yet, but I have some ideas on location. The challenge we are facing is that each investor might have a different part of the pie. I think the lender route might be the better option.

With the series LLC, it should be easy enough to switch companies once the deal is underway.