Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: JD Martin

JD Martin has started 63 posts and replied 9445 times.

Post: Are REITs stocks or real estate?

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999

I consider REITs closer to a form of bond investing. In theory, you own a limited piece of the trust, which is essentially the corporation, whose business is operating real estate for profit. As you are almost always a limited partner, you have essentially no control in the trust once you've invested your money. With stock investing, in theory one could obtain enough stock to take control of the company whereas in a REIT the controlling "stock" is pretty much always defined and held by the general partners. As a limited partner you are essentially a miniature bank, loaning money to the principal owners, for a defined rate of return, kind of like purchasing US Treasury notes. However, not only can the REIT default, leaving the LPs without value, they can also incur capital calls and other financial requirements that will force you to pay to play, ie to maintain your investment without dilution or wipeout.

Post: Detroit Tarrifs is now the time for a rebirth and new look @ this market

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999
Quote from @Eric Bilderback:
Quote from @JD Martin:
Quote from @Eric Bilderback:
Quote from @JD Martin:
Quote from @James Wise:
Quote from @Eric Bilderback:
Quote from @JD Martin:

I'd be shocked if it made any difference. Any car maker coming back to the US to start production is going to be somewhere in the South where unions are weak and right to work laws are everywhere. The old factories are dinosaurs and factory legacy is one of our huge disadvantages compared to China et al. I agree we need to make things here, but we don't need to make everything here and would be better served applying limited labor to future tech than making wagon wheels. It may sound harsh to say it but non-tech American workers are pathetic compared to the rest of the developing world. In my area Mexicans and other Central Americans that do "labor" work - construction, landscaping, basic factory work, etc - run circles around the natives. Americans have had it too good for too long and at the bottom rungs are not hungry, they're bitter, resentful and expect others to take care of them. We need good jobs here for sure for people who are not college educated, and we shouldn't be sending everyone to college anyway as it's a waste of time and money, but we also need a total reset of the working labor force ethos. Before I retired, you couldn't give away entry level water system jobs despite the great benefits; these guys wouldn't do the jobs for $20/hr even with no experience required. I hired a lot of people in my career and my favorite part about retiring was not having to find one decent warm body to fill important jobs among a thousand deadbeats. Maybe if we started letting people starve in the street again the hunger ethos would return. 

One of the most arrogant things I have read in quite a while.  Kids today are bombarded with talk about how entitled they are, how their achievements have an asterisk, it is like this is being done to them on purpose.  The kids I know are full of potential the generations before them including mine (Gen X) have completely thrown them under the bus.  I hate judging groups but if you want to look at an entitled group look at the boomers.  By and large they grew up in intact families in communities with deep roots most had opportunities kids today can only dream of as far as building wealth or starting a family.  

As a landscaper of 10 years before I retired out of that business I hired many mexicans they aren't supermen or they are as big a piece of **** as everybody else, LOL. I hired Mexican guys that could come up to America work their *** off for 2-3 years go home and buy a 50 acer ranch on the ocean.  No American kid hanging drywall, laying sod or framing a house will ever have that opportunity.  And to rub salt in their elder, richer, citizens look down their noses and mock them.  

 50 acres of oceanfront land, lol?.....C'mon now.


 🤣 No doubt James; Mr. Bilderback has a personal grudge with me which is why such claims are made. He wants to complain about the very guys he hired working like hell, saving all their money and then going back to Mexico to live large. Why hire them at all then? The worst kept secret in the world is that immigrants work 10x harder than any of our entitled citizens want to work. You think the roofers and lawn care guys around me hire Mexicans because they like them? 😂 I live where people would love to see everyone from Central and South America deported - except when they need to have some labor work done. 


 They are hired because yes, many of them are hard workers and good people, blah blah blah.  But more importantly they are willing to work for the kind of wages that you can only afford to stack 6 of them in a three bedroom home, many times they have no family stateside so you can work them all day everyday.  Americans want a higher standard of living.  If an American could work all day as a laborer and pay to have a home and a family then America would have all the workers it could ever want.  Nothing personal towards you (I agree with most of what you say (other then politics, LOL).  

My passion is our nation's calculation should not be who will work the hardest for the cheapest so owners of assets can make more, it should be how do we ensure American citizens have the opportunity and enough to prosperity to afford having a family and meaning for their own lives.  Prioritizing a country where our kids are able to own assets, start families, create strong communities watch out because these new generations will be unstoppable which would be great for the entire world.

 I don't disagree with any of that. The bigger problem is that Americans at the bottom want to start at at-the-top wages and do half the work. Before I retired we struggled to give away public sector jobs that could only be held by US citizens (state law), at more than livable entry level wages ($20+) with outstanding benefits. When I did get someone hired, we were lucky if the guy made it 3 months before just not showing up any more. The last guy I hired - the best of the lot, since half of them either had criminal records or couldn't pass a drug test - burned through an entire year's worth of leave and sick time in less than 3 months, then after being told he didn't have any more time off left called in sick Thursday and Friday w/o pay and quit on Monday. And it was like this for about the last 10 years before I retired, or close to it. Bad enough that the guys we did have on crews preferred to work short handed and get some OT than be constantly saddled with slackers and bums that didn't know anything and barely worked when they were there. 

I don't think we can change this until we release the cradle-to-grave cushion underneath most of these people. Humans are naturally lazy, and a large percentage will default to the least amount of effort require to avoid starving on the street. Maybe if this were more of a distinct possibility in this country there would be an improved work ethic. I see opportunities everywhere I look, more than I could ever possibly take advantage of myself, and I'm often sharing them with people I know. Almost no one ever takes advantage of any of them, looks into anything or takes action of any kind. Hell, I counsel my tenants (the ones that want to listen) on the wiseness of owning property instead of being a lifelong tenant. Virtually none of them are interested. 

I'm a huge proponent of "Made in America" - I was boycotting foreign made crap way before it was popular (hell, I even wrote a song about it). I went out of my way to spend extra money on tools and parts and cars and equipment that was made here, because I believe that you are the strongest as a community if you try your best to act in concentric circles when it comes to buying decisions - local, then regional, then state, then federal, then foreign friends and allies. I also support the idea of having a healthy manufacturing base just in the idea of general national defense, besides providing jobs. But I also believe that we have had it too good for too long in this country and too many people want to live like kings, be paid like kings, and work like kings. We aren't hungry any more and anyone who comes here from somewhere else sees it and knows it. The very idea that we need tariffs from other high standard countries like Canada and Japan demonstrates this perfectly. 

I apologize to you I shouldn't have said you were arrogant.  I have seen you give excellent advice to people scraping to get ahead I know your a good dude.  Everyone is responsible for their life and their decisions I am very sympathetic to Americans plight in this hyper-consumer culture/matrix that is not fulfilling but it is hard for many people to see this especially when they are young.  I like Trumps policies but more importantly Americans need to raise there kids and create an environment that shows kids how meaningful work, skills etc are.  And set an expectation for young people that they will be working and people who work hard deserve dignity (including migrants) and society should be striving to create more opportunity for average people.

Have a good weekend thanks for the polite response. 
Thanks 🙂 I think most of us all want to see our communities and our country do well, and people performing meaningful work is a cornerstone for that. One big problem we are going to have to figure out how to overcome is the idea that work is for suckers and there's an angle everywhere for getting rich without effort. I think about how many people come to BP posting how they want to do real estate so they can retire at 30 and travel the world or sit on the beach. We've created the idea that people who work hard are suckers compared to those who figure out ways to game the system, and we need to change that.

Post: Detroit Tarrifs is now the time for a rebirth and new look @ this market

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999
Quote from @Isaura Orellana:

Wow, Jay. Saying something upbeat and positive about the possibilities and future of the Detroit market? I’m flabbergasted. You’ve been one of Detroit’s biggest critics on BP since my husband and I began turning water into wine, building SFRs and MFRs in Detroit six years ago, and I started dabbling on the platform.

First off, the rebirth of Detroit began around 2008–2009. Not sure how you missed the memo on that one. But it would indeed be epic and huge for Motor City, or “Comeback City,” as we like to call it.

And yes, Trump’s tariffs could absolutely turbocharge the Detroit auto industry and breathe new life into the city’s historic factories. Trump says a lot and does a lot, but advocating to bring back the auto industry to Detroit has consistently been one of his top 10 to 20 priorities since he came down that escalator. One might even argue it was a campaign promise during the last election cycle.

Let’s not forget Trump’s Treasury Secretary, who helped orchestrate the tariffs, is widely regarded as one of the most highly respected macro hedge fund managers in the world.

Not only are interest rates projected to drop significantly, but due to those same tariffs and broader economic policy, he’s already maneuvered $3 to $5 trillion in investment commitments that have flowed into the U.S. since taking office—yes, trillion.

Manufacturing, clean energy, AI, and infrastructure are now attracting global capital, with Detroit back on the map as a high-growth hub.

Additionally, Detroit was recently named the number one most undervalued housing market in the U.S., followed by Cleveland, St. Louis, Philadelphia, and Oklahoma City. The Big D also ranked second in the nation for average home price increases since the pandemic. The stage is set.

Winter is just now wrapping up here. It’s been long and cold, but we Michiganders (or Michiganians) weren’t phased. Life went on, and the building never stopped. Construction remained strong and steady, as usual.

As for whether we can get the factories up and running in a reasonable timeframe, sure, Gretchen may kick and scream and be a minor obstacle at first, but she’d be writing herself a one-way ticket out of Michigan if she didn’t fully embrace an opportunity of this magnitude for the strong-spirited people of Detroit and Michigan.

And honestly, it wouldn’t surprise me in the slightest if Trump’s close friend Elon, or other major players, started expediting the development of one or more facilities in Detroit, similar to what was done in Texas. I mean, it’s just common sense.

When it comes to smart purchasing near strong school districts, hospital access, and proximity to revitalized areas, Detroit is full of promising zones. Look at the fringes of so many historic districts: Dexter-Linwood with its massive revitalization in 48206 and 48238. Not to mention 48204 off Grand River, 48227 off Greenfield, Indian Village, 48224 in Morningside and East English. Not to mention Hamtramck, Dearborn, Dearborn Heights, Birmingham, Farmington Hills, Clinton Township and the list goes on.

Deals, deals, and more deals are happening throughout Detroit and Metro Detroit.

Detroit is BRRRR heaven.


 I'm not sure that's entirely fair 😜 I think what Jay has advocated against more than anything is the newbie with no job, no money and no experience that wants to parachute into Detroit and walk away Scrooge McDuck. When you have houses being advertised for a dollar it encourages that kind of thing.

Post: Detroit Tarrifs is now the time for a rebirth and new look @ this market

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999
Quote from @Eric Bilderback:
Quote from @JD Martin:
Quote from @James Wise:
Quote from @Eric Bilderback:
Quote from @JD Martin:

I'd be shocked if it made any difference. Any car maker coming back to the US to start production is going to be somewhere in the South where unions are weak and right to work laws are everywhere. The old factories are dinosaurs and factory legacy is one of our huge disadvantages compared to China et al. I agree we need to make things here, but we don't need to make everything here and would be better served applying limited labor to future tech than making wagon wheels. It may sound harsh to say it but non-tech American workers are pathetic compared to the rest of the developing world. In my area Mexicans and other Central Americans that do "labor" work - construction, landscaping, basic factory work, etc - run circles around the natives. Americans have had it too good for too long and at the bottom rungs are not hungry, they're bitter, resentful and expect others to take care of them. We need good jobs here for sure for people who are not college educated, and we shouldn't be sending everyone to college anyway as it's a waste of time and money, but we also need a total reset of the working labor force ethos. Before I retired, you couldn't give away entry level water system jobs despite the great benefits; these guys wouldn't do the jobs for $20/hr even with no experience required. I hired a lot of people in my career and my favorite part about retiring was not having to find one decent warm body to fill important jobs among a thousand deadbeats. Maybe if we started letting people starve in the street again the hunger ethos would return. 

One of the most arrogant things I have read in quite a while.  Kids today are bombarded with talk about how entitled they are, how their achievements have an asterisk, it is like this is being done to them on purpose.  The kids I know are full of potential the generations before them including mine (Gen X) have completely thrown them under the bus.  I hate judging groups but if you want to look at an entitled group look at the boomers.  By and large they grew up in intact families in communities with deep roots most had opportunities kids today can only dream of as far as building wealth or starting a family.  

As a landscaper of 10 years before I retired out of that business I hired many mexicans they aren't supermen or they are as big a piece of **** as everybody else, LOL. I hired Mexican guys that could come up to America work their *** off for 2-3 years go home and buy a 50 acer ranch on the ocean.  No American kid hanging drywall, laying sod or framing a house will ever have that opportunity.  And to rub salt in their elder, richer, citizens look down their noses and mock them.  

 50 acres of oceanfront land, lol?.....C'mon now.


 🤣 No doubt James; Mr. Bilderback has a personal grudge with me which is why such claims are made. He wants to complain about the very guys he hired working like hell, saving all their money and then going back to Mexico to live large. Why hire them at all then? The worst kept secret in the world is that immigrants work 10x harder than any of our entitled citizens want to work. You think the roofers and lawn care guys around me hire Mexicans because they like them? 😂 I live where people would love to see everyone from Central and South America deported - except when they need to have some labor work done. 


 They are hired because yes, many of them are hard workers and good people, blah blah blah.  But more importantly they are willing to work for the kind of wages that you can only afford to stack 6 of them in a three bedroom home, many times they have no family stateside so you can work them all day everyday.  Americans want a higher standard of living.  If an American could work all day as a laborer and pay to have a home and a family then America would have all the workers it could ever want.  Nothing personal towards you (I agree with most of what you say (other then politics, LOL).  

My passion is our nation's calculation should not be who will work the hardest for the cheapest so owners of assets can make more, it should be how do we ensure American citizens have the opportunity and enough to prosperity to afford having a family and meaning for their own lives.  Prioritizing a country where our kids are able to own assets, start families, create strong communities watch out because these new generations will be unstoppable which would be great for the entire world.

 I don't disagree with any of that. The bigger problem is that Americans at the bottom want to start at at-the-top wages and do half the work. Before I retired we struggled to give away public sector jobs that could only be held by US citizens (state law), at more than livable entry level wages ($20+) with outstanding benefits. When I did get someone hired, we were lucky if the guy made it 3 months before just not showing up any more. The last guy I hired - the best of the lot, since half of them either had criminal records or couldn't pass a drug test - burned through an entire year's worth of leave and sick time in less than 3 months, then after being told he didn't have any more time off left called in sick Thursday and Friday w/o pay and quit on Monday. And it was like this for about the last 10 years before I retired, or close to it. Bad enough that the guys we did have on crews preferred to work short handed and get some OT than be constantly saddled with slackers and bums that didn't know anything and barely worked when they were there. 

I don't think we can change this until we release the cradle-to-grave cushion underneath most of these people. Humans are naturally lazy, and a large percentage will default to the least amount of effort require to avoid starving on the street. Maybe if this were more of a distinct possibility in this country there would be an improved work ethic. I see opportunities everywhere I look, more than I could ever possibly take advantage of myself, and I'm often sharing them with people I know. Almost no one ever takes advantage of any of them, looks into anything or takes action of any kind. Hell, I counsel my tenants (the ones that want to listen) on the wiseness of owning property instead of being a lifelong tenant. Virtually none of them are interested. 

I'm a huge proponent of "Made in America" - I was boycotting foreign made crap way before it was popular (hell, I even wrote a song about it). I went out of my way to spend extra money on tools and parts and cars and equipment that was made here, because I believe that you are the strongest as a community if you try your best to act in concentric circles when it comes to buying decisions - local, then regional, then state, then federal, then foreign friends and allies. I also support the idea of having a healthy manufacturing base just in the idea of general national defense, besides providing jobs. But I also believe that we have had it too good for too long in this country and too many people want to live like kings, be paid like kings, and work like kings. We aren't hungry any more and anyone who comes here from somewhere else sees it and knows it. The very idea that we need tariffs from other high standard countries like Canada and Japan demonstrates this perfectly. 

Post: Is a lender obligated to talk to a court appointed executor?

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999
Quote from @Joe S.:
Quote from @Chris Seveney:
Quote from @Joe S.:

So a seller has reached out to me and said they have a property and they cannot get a payoff because the lender will not talk to them. They told me in about a week they would be the court appointed executor. So would the mortgage company be obligated to talk to the court appointed executor? Also could a court appointed executor appoint someone as their POA as well.
 


 until that person is appointed - no they cannot talk to the person  - the only person they can talk to is the borrower. Its a CFPB / FDCPA law - its on different than if you were on a loan and your wife was not - they cannot talk to your wife about it, unless you give specific permission.

Once it’s appointed, then yes they have authority to talk.

Once they are appointed, can they do a POA for somebody to talk on their behalf?

They should check with the court before going any further. It depends on your jurisdiction but your courts may not allow an appointed executor to assign their powers to someone else without permission as that is akin to just having the other person appointed, even with limited/revocable POA. It depends on the situation but in general courts look to an executor that is unbiased and has no finance stake in the outcome and that could be affected with a transfer of power.

Post: Detroit Tarrifs is now the time for a rebirth and new look @ this market

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999
Quote from @James Wise:
Quote from @Eric Bilderback:
Quote from @JD Martin:

I'd be shocked if it made any difference. Any car maker coming back to the US to start production is going to be somewhere in the South where unions are weak and right to work laws are everywhere. The old factories are dinosaurs and factory legacy is one of our huge disadvantages compared to China et al. I agree we need to make things here, but we don't need to make everything here and would be better served applying limited labor to future tech than making wagon wheels. It may sound harsh to say it but non-tech American workers are pathetic compared to the rest of the developing world. In my area Mexicans and other Central Americans that do "labor" work - construction, landscaping, basic factory work, etc - run circles around the natives. Americans have had it too good for too long and at the bottom rungs are not hungry, they're bitter, resentful and expect others to take care of them. We need good jobs here for sure for people who are not college educated, and we shouldn't be sending everyone to college anyway as it's a waste of time and money, but we also need a total reset of the working labor force ethos. Before I retired, you couldn't give away entry level water system jobs despite the great benefits; these guys wouldn't do the jobs for $20/hr even with no experience required. I hired a lot of people in my career and my favorite part about retiring was not having to find one decent warm body to fill important jobs among a thousand deadbeats. Maybe if we started letting people starve in the street again the hunger ethos would return. 

One of the most arrogant things I have read in quite a while.  Kids today are bombarded with talk about how entitled they are, how their achievements have an asterisk, it is like this is being done to them on purpose.  The kids I know are full of potential the generations before them including mine (Gen X) have completely thrown them under the bus.  I hate judging groups but if you want to look at an entitled group look at the boomers.  By and large they grew up in intact families in communities with deep roots most had opportunities kids today can only dream of as far as building wealth or starting a family.  

As a landscaper of 10 years before I retired out of that business I hired many mexicans they aren't supermen or they are as big a piece of **** as everybody else, LOL. I hired Mexican guys that could come up to America work their *** off for 2-3 years go home and buy a 50 acer ranch on the ocean.  No American kid hanging drywall, laying sod or framing a house will ever have that opportunity.  And to rub salt in their elder, richer, citizens look down their noses and mock them.  

 50 acres of oceanfront land, lol?.....C'mon now.


 🤣 No doubt James; Mr. Bilderback has a personal grudge with me which is why such claims are made. He wants to complain about the very guys he hired working like hell, saving all their money and then going back to Mexico to live large. Why hire them at all then? The worst kept secret in the world is that immigrants work 10x harder than any of our entitled citizens want to work. You think the roofers and lawn care guys around me hire Mexicans because they like them? 😂 I live where people would love to see everyone from Central and South America deported - except when they need to have some labor work done. 

Post: Selling a inherited home

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999

Well, if you're not both on board with how you're going to deal with the house you're in trouble. I'm guessing you want to keep the home as a rental or fix & flip, your brother/sister/cousin wants to sell tomorrow and get their share of the loot. 

You've got to fix that part first before you can proceed. If you are equal inheritors, only a court can force one side or the other to sell. 

Post: Screening for students?

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999

@Will Gaston is going to be your go-to source for student rentals. We rent in a university town but prices have gone high enough that we don't get as many students as in the past. I look for graduate students, married students, roommates coming in together as friends/siblings with parent co-signing. Almost always a co-signer for students unless they are graduate or married. I can't remember the last time we had an undergrad without a co-signer, if ever. 

Post: Converting primary residence to rental

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999

If you have a mortgage that says you will occupy the home as a primary residence you may be required to refinance and/or sell if you move. It depends on the kind of mortgage you have and the language in your documents. Yes, there is a good chance your lender will discover you are renting the house out when you get rental insurance. 

Just review your mortgage documents and see what they say. Some loan products will require you to refinance or sell if you don't occupy as a primary any longer. 

Post: Is a lender obligated to talk to a court appointed executor?

JD Martin
ModeratorPosted
  • Rock Star Extraordinaire
  • Northeast, TN
  • Posts 9,944
  • Votes 15,999
Quote from @Joe S.:

So a seller has reached out to me and said they have a property and they cannot get a payoff because the lender will not talk to them. They told me in about a week they would be the court appointed executor. So would the mortgage company be obligated to talk to the court appointed executor? Also could a court appointed executor appoint someone as their POA as well.
 


 Yes and yes but it will probably require written documentation and the second one unlikely without the court's permission.