Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew Gentile

Matthew Gentile has started 5 posts and replied 87 times.

Post: Beginner looking for coaching/guidance/mentorship

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52
Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:

Okay, I don't know if everyone posting here has been living under a rock, you are setting a young guy up for failure by supporting absolutely unrealistic expectations.

In order to clear $120k of net income in the Midwest you need a RE portfolio to the tune of 8 million. At current rates probably 30% down to get to a 1.2 DSCR.

As an OOS investor, you have a huge disadvantage compared to local investors and you are cost burdened by paying a PM. You are also likely to pay more for contractors and get a lower-quality install because you are not there to supervise. 

Midwest housing stock is old. You can ignore capex for a while, but the financial liability just keeps quietly getting bigger. At some point you need a new roof, plumbing, windows, HVAC, etc - setting aside 5% of rent may cover a new water heater, but very few components of a house last more than 50 years.

It's 2024: books written in 2015 or 2018 are based on the market conditions in year 5 years before they were written. Milwaukee home prices have doubled since 2015 and interest rates are now 7.5% - 8.5%. The unicorn years are in the past.

REI is back to what it used to be historically: a long-term equity play to preserve and grow wealth. The years of free BRRRR cash flow with basically infinite returns are gone. We all wish we could get back ten years and buy some more.

For the record, I continue to grow our portfolio, because I think in 10 years from now I will be happy for every property that I have bought in 2024. (Just like I am happy today for every property I bought in 2014). 

But let's be real: the cash flow you can currently squeeze out of properties is barely enough to keep the lights on and do some maintenance while you watch equity grow.

The worst advice we can give a newbie is to keep hammering "just find a deal where the numbers work" and thereby pushing them into low-income neighborhoods with run-down housing stock and management challenges that most seasoned investor run from.

I absolutely encourage young investors to buy real estate, but look at it as a long term INVESTMENT, which means you are putting money in, not taking money out. As for cash flow, buy or start a business. The whole point of a business is cash flow. Whether you are starting an online service or buy a food truck, endless possibilities.. But that is a much better shot at cash flow than REI.

Okay, now I'll get off my salt box.

 I'd agree @Marcus Auerbach RE investment is safer to store money than it is to make money in the current environment. If cash-flow is the desire, starting out in real estate would not yield very good cash-flow results at the start but building equity is never a bad thing. 

Pros and cons for sure. Tax advantages, appreciation, costs just a few things to consider but with a long-term view like Marcus said, you'd be in good shape to start. Investment helps grow and keep money, cash-flow is easier down the road. 

Good luck!

Post: What’s keeping you from investing in real estate right now?

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52
Quote from @Kathryn Bennett:

As a millennial - fear. Between prices and rates the payments are stupid high. Knowing people who lost it all in 2008 has me scared. 


 Absolutely a realistic fear, we've seen some semblance of 2008 with the exception of inventory for most markets. History doesn't always repeat but it tends to rhyme. In this case affordability seems to be the main issue as opposed to sub-prime lending. Should be interesting to see what direction we head in this summer and beyond. 

Always underwrite anything you are investing in very conservatively in difficult environments such as right now. If it works in this environment with tight conservative underwriting you can be confident in your decision making and when things calm down you may just have a sweet deal on your hands. Problem now is finding deals that work today and that's where the real work begins. 

Post: Advice on property manager not replying to calls for over a month

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52

It's a very tough scenario especially if they have been effective for you for a decent amount of time. I concur with everyone, best to check for medical emergency first in this case, after that's been established as NOT the case, definitely time to get yourself into the mix and remove that manager asap. 

It's unfortunate but this is a hard business some times people just can't cut it even if they've had some success before. Everyone's journey ends a different way, hopefully this can be resolved quickly. Good luck.

Post: How is the Yorktown Muncie Indiana for LTR?

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52

I've spent some time in Muncie and Yorktown, previous relationship family lived there. Her father owned a few properties in the Yorktown area and was cash-flowing very well. Mind you, this was 2019-2021 so definitely a different environment for investing but the area is wonderful. Very happy people and not ridiculously priced homes from what I've seen lately. 

Post: What’s keeping you from investing in real estate right now?

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52
Quote from @Zach Vallandingham:

My biggest concern is time.  I am a full-time physician with a large amount of student loan debt and two young children. My wife is also a full-time physician. I would love to get into real estate investing, but I have some anxiety about the time vs benefit of making such a big decision at this point in my life. I Have a hard time keeping the grass cut at my own house.  But then I also think, there is no time like the present?  ***shrugs shoulders*** 

Time is definitely the most real constraint, it's what we all want the most and why we invest to begin with in my opinion, to reclaim time. I'd say in a situation like this you'd be well suited to do passive investment into real estate as a limited partner where if you do well financially as a physician you could look to fund investment projects but not necessarily manage them. 

Definitely hard to get into right out of the gate, but something to research for sure. That way you can find investments to provide a decent return and to compliment your full-time work. 

Hard task but not impossible in any way. You're in the right place to network, going to some local meetups could prove beneficial to learning about investment opportunities as well. Goodluck!

Post: What’s keeping you from investing in real estate right now?

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52
Quote from @Chris Bonner:
Construction costs continue to be out of balance in markets near me. They make projects hard to pencil out and riskier to move forward with. The pricing seems detached from the realities and quality of the services rendered, or the accounting of the project as a whole.

 Even in some of the cheaper land areas, construction on new builds has razor thin margins from what I've seen. Very few build projects we've priced out returned anything worth the effort they would take to accomplish. The current environment is very restrictive, forcing us as investors and real estate professionals to get creative.

Post: What’s keeping you from investing in real estate right now?

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52
Quote from @Spencer Riche:

"Date the rate, marry the property." Don't let high interest rates or another news headlines stop you from capitalizing on a great opportunity. If a property ticks all your boxes, has potential for added value, and yields the return you want after accounting for the cost of capital, why overlook it just because the rates are considered "high"? In my view, now is a prime time to make a move in the market when others are reluctant "waiting it out" and keeping their capital on the sidelines. I've landed some of the best deals of my career this past year. Plus, if rates drop later on, your position will only improve.


 I'd agree that you can find some of the best deals but I'd say they are definitely more difficult to find in this environment. The deals that work in this environment will be exceptional in a lower rate scenario so more than likely you'd be hitting a homerun if it works well now.

Not to say you could still hit a few singles that work moderately well now and slightly better later. Getting on base is the most important part. Deal flow in a difficult market helps hone your skill and teaches you valuable lessons as well. 

Post: We Closed Our First Deal

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52

@Steven Whipple

Congratulations! The first one in any new profession, venture, hobby is always the hardest. You've got to overcome fear, uncertainty and your own mind which is not an easy feat. Kudos to you for getting it done. 

Keep us up to date on your next chapter and continue to share how your experiences and colleagues prepared you to continue pulling the trigger in real estate investment!

Great job.

Post: Pre fab Homes

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52
Quote from @Bryant Brislin:

I think checking with the city to make sure they are okay with the product from a code standpoint, would be the most important thing.


 Bryant that is very true, we are looking to operate under the states affordable housing guidelines in hopes of utilizing state funding so that's definitely a big one. The builders website has indication that they have down affordable housing with the state before so that is hopefully good news from a code front. 

Thanks for sharing.

Post: Pre fab Homes

Matthew GentilePosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Worcester, MA
  • Posts 88
  • Votes 52

Hi BP Community,

I have been looking into Pre-fab homes for rental/condo properties and was curious if anyone has had success with Pre-fab homes before. The concept seems better than new construction in terms of project time, but I'm wondering about the cons to this idea with exception of price being an obvious one.

In theory it seems scalable and efficient, in my mind acquiring the land suitable would be the hardest task. Would love to hear more opinions on this topic.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9