Skip to content
Foreclosures

User Stats

48
Posts
2
Votes
Jamie Montpellier
  • Investor
  • Aurora, Ontario
2
Votes |
48
Posts

Should you buy A properties in A neighbourhoods...

Jamie Montpellier
  • Investor
  • Aurora, Ontario
Posted Aug 2 2014, 17:05

Dear BP members,

Here's the thing, we constantly hear about buying value right from the get-go and so I wish to know if buying turnkey properties in A neighbourhoods is a no-no because the value is already priced in...

Or should we be bargain hunting and looking for :

B type property in A type neighbourhood

C type property in B type neighbourhood

What do you think?

Jamie

User Stats

227
Posts
75
Votes
Terry Hershberger
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Nipomo, CA
75
Votes |
227
Posts
Terry Hershberger
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Nipomo, CA
Replied Aug 2 2014, 17:10

@Jamie Montpellier  I own all three. All will work depending on your goals. You should really be looking for deals. You make money when you BUY! So if you buy right, you will make money. Also if it's a buy and hold long term property, you will want to make sure it will cash flow. I generally like to get at least 25% Return on my cash in from the cash flow. Hope this helps you.

Happy Investing!

User Stats

48
Posts
2
Votes
Jamie Montpellier
  • Investor
  • Aurora, Ontario
2
Votes |
48
Posts
Jamie Montpellier
  • Investor
  • Aurora, Ontario
Replied Aug 2 2014, 17:22

@Terry Hershberger 

Well from the numbers I'm looking at the COC% is near a little over 21% that's considering a 7% vacancy rate and 7% maintenance based on rent. Do you use a higher percentage when running your numbers for cashflow numbers?

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

227
Posts
75
Votes
Terry Hershberger
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Nipomo, CA
75
Votes |
227
Posts
Terry Hershberger
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Nipomo, CA
Replied Aug 2 2014, 17:30

@Jamie Montpellier 

No, you are in the ballpark. Some use 10% for both. For me, it varies depending on the type of home construction and age of home. 

Happy Investing!

User Stats

40,142
Posts
59,295
Votes
Jay Hinrichs#1 All Forums Contributor
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
59,295
Votes |
40,142
Posts
Jay Hinrichs#1 All Forums Contributor
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
Replied Aug 2 2014, 18:24

@Jamie Montpellier   prime A can run lower than those numbers.. I have 11 what I call A's and they are always full so I have no vacancy factor.. maintenance costs 2 to 3% and that is just filters ... but these homes I brought brand new 5 and 6 years ago.. same cannot be said for used homes generally

User Stats

870
Posts
662
Votes
James Park
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Johns Creek, GA
662
Votes |
870
Posts
James Park
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Johns Creek, GA
Replied Aug 2 2014, 18:47
Jamie,
Everyone has their own real estate portfolio goals and you have to figure out what strategy works best for you.

Currently, I have one B type SFR property in a C type neighborhood
one B type SFR property in a B neighborhood, and I have
5 A type SFR properties in an A neighborhood where the schools are all rated 10/10/10 and were all acquired brand new in the last 5 years. 

When the opportunity arises I plan to trade up my 2 C and B SFRs for two more A SFRs. My goal is to own 10 A type SFRs free and clear. I find that the management of my A SFRs are truly passive and easy to manage and attracts 700 credit / 100k+ income tenants who pay rent before the 1st of the month, takes great care of your property, calls you perhaps 2-4 times a year. These A type assets seem to appreciate much faster than my B and C type assets and it is not uncommon to see multiple applications arrive at your email within the 1st week of listing the home for rent.

For my buy and hold I like to buy A type assets from motivated sellers at a 10-20% discount less than 10 years old.

For fix and flip, my criteria is look for homes built in the 1990s in the A type neighborhood where I know homes in the neighborhood will turn quickly.

James
  

Originally posted by @Jamie Montpellier:

Dear BP members,

Here's the thing, we constantly hear about buying value right from the get-go and so I wish to know if buying turnkey properties in A neighbourhoods is a no-no because the value is already priced in...

Or should we be bargain hunting and looking for :

B type property in A type neighbourhood

C type property in B type neighbourhood

What do you think?

Jamie

User Stats

3,085
Posts
1,035
Votes
Jeff S.
  • Specialist
  • Portland, OR
1,035
Votes |
3,085
Posts
Jeff S.
  • Specialist
  • Portland, OR
Replied Aug 2 2014, 19:01

@Jamie Montpellier You should buy in a B or C neighborhood that is on its way to the next higher letter. The house doesn't matter so much because in a good area the value is in the land.

Are you looking to just park money then buy A properties and forget them for a lot of years. If the economy survives the long haul then inflation will have been present and you should gain in both rents and value.

If you can't afford A properties then don't buy them. If financed they could eat you alive for possibly longer than you can take.

User Stats

4,238
Posts
1,872
Votes
Engelo Rumora
Property Manager
  • Investor
  • Toledo, OH
1,872
Votes |
4,238
Posts
Engelo Rumora
Property Manager
  • Investor
  • Toledo, OH
Replied Aug 3 2014, 10:16
Originally posted by @Jamie Montpellier:

Dear BP members,

Here's the thing, we constantly hear about buying value right from the get-go and so I wish to know if buying turnkey properties in A neighbourhoods is a no-no because the value is already priced in...

Or should we be bargain hunting and looking for :

B type property in A type neighbourhood

C type property in B type neighbourhood

What do you think?

Jamie

 Hi Jamie,

Solid B class is the way to go in my opinion.

Please see link to a recent blog I write for BP in asset classes.

http://www.biggerpockets.com/renewsblog/2014/06/28/abcs-real-estate-asset-classes/

Thanks and I hope you find it useful.

Have a great day.

User Stats

267
Posts
73
Votes
Joey Budka
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Santa Cruz, CA
73
Votes |
267
Posts
Joey Budka
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Santa Cruz, CA
Replied Aug 3 2014, 10:25

It is a No-No. Never buy retail priced investments.

User Stats

5,659
Posts
1,829
Votes
Elizabeth Colegrove
  • Hanford, CA
1,829
Votes |
5,659
Posts
Elizabeth Colegrove
  • Hanford, CA
Replied Aug 3 2014, 10:42

Our entire business model is buying class A- properties in A+ neighborhoods. We have bought them undervalue using short sales or foreclosures. They allow us to manage ourselves long distance do to the clientele. We have had no vacancy costs, since we usually have multiple strong applicants per house. 

User Stats

798
Posts
170
Votes
Pete T.
  • Real estate investor
  • Las Vegas
170
Votes |
798
Posts
Pete T.
  • Real estate investor
  • Las Vegas
Replied Aug 3 2014, 11:52

I agree w/ the comments above about the benefits of A properties being generally better than the paper advantages of lower classes, however, at least where I am at and what I would consider A neighborhoods, no one would be able to CF or find an investment.