Spencer, IN Investment Properties for Sale
Browse homes for sale and investment properties in Spencer, IN. Refine your search by price, property type, or more.
Best cash flowing properties in Spencer, IN
 
      Active
       
        
          $153,000
        
      
      
        
          1
          bds
         |
        
          1
          ba
         |
        
          951
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1960
        
      
      
        1536 River Rd, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $320
          
          Cash flow
        
            10.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            8.7%
          
          Cap rate
        
            1.0%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $129,900
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          1
          ba
         |
        
          928
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1935
        
      
      
        1165 Freeman Rd, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $301
          
          Cash flow
        
            12.1%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            8.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            1.1%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        
        
          13 out of 14 properties for sale in Spencer, IN
        
        
                  
      
    Limited Results Shown
Create a free account, or log in to reveal all property listings and enjoy the complete experience.
 
      Active
       
        
          $374,900
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          3,502
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1986
        
      
      
        45 Flatwoods Rd, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $219
          
          Cash flow
        
            3.0%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            6.8%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.8%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $239,900
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          1,728
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1950
        
      
      
        456 W Hillside Ave, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-125
          
          Cash flow
        
            -2.7%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            5.5%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.7%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $399,900
        
      
      
        
          5
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          3,321
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1940
        
      
      
        1446 W State Highway 46, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-47
          
          Cash flow
        
            -0.6%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            6.0%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.7%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $409,900
        
      
      
        
          
          bds
         |
        
          0
          ba
         |
        
          0
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1994
        
      
      
        169 Sycamore St, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-858
          
          Cash flow
        
            -10.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            3.6%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.4%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $2,750,000
        
      
      
        
          5
          bds
         |
        
          6
          ba
         |
        
          5,392
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1986
        
      
      
        2034 Dubois Rd, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-12,086
          
          Cash flow
        
            -22.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            0.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.1%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $1,150,000
        
      
      
        
          
          bds
         |
        
          0
          ba
         |
        
          0
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1995
        
      
      
        135 W Wayne St, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-4,994
          
          Cash flow
        
            -22.7%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            0.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.1%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $445,000
        
      
      
        
          4
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          2,054
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1985
        
      
      
        4005 Texas Pike, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-900
          
          Cash flow
        
            -10.6%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            3.7%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.4%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $409,900
        
      
      
        
          
          bds
         |
        
          0
          ba
         |
        
          0
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1991
        
      
      
        101 E Wayne St, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-1,134
          
          Cash flow
        
            -14.4%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            2.8%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.3%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $429,900
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          1,404
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1978
        
      
      
        3320 Pine Wood Dr, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-822
          
          Cash flow
        
            -10.0%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            3.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.5%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $420,500
        
      
      
        
          2
          bds
         |
        
          2
          ba
         |
        
          2,260
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          1955
        
      
      
        681 Hancock School Rd, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-636
          
          Cash flow
        
            -7.9%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            4.3%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.5%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
         
      Active
       
        
          $310,000
        
      
      
        
          3
          bds
         |
        
          3
          ba
         |
        
          1,468
          sqft
         |
        
          built
          2016
        
      
      
        9800 W Ratliff Rd, Spencer, IN 47460
      
      
            $-70
          
          Cash flow
        
            -1.2%
          
          Cash-on-Cash Return
        
            5.9%
          
          Cap rate
        
            0.7%
          
          Rent to Value Ratio
        