All Forum Posts by: Justin R.
Justin R. has started 74 posts and replied 618 times.
Post: Door count is a terrible metric. Please stop using it.

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Quote from @Dave Meyer:
Door count is the worst (commonly discussed) metric in the real estate investing community. Why does everyone use it? Can we all decide to collectively kill it? Or are there some of you out there that stand by door count being a useful barometer of success? Honestly, I'd love to hear the argument for why this metric is useful, cause I can't think of one -- so please reply back here.
Here's my argument. Door count is what many in the analytics world would call a 'vanity metric.' It's something that looks important and fancy, but doesn't actually tell you anything about business performance. Sound familiar? It's because door count is a useless metric, it exists to pump up the ego of the investor, and nothing more. Here's why:
1. Door count tells you exactly nothing about the quality of a portfolio. As an example, let's say Jane T. Investor has 12 doors, and she leads with that when networking. Well 12 doors sounds solid, but how are they performing? Are they cash flowing? Do they require enormous amounts of time and maintenance? Are the returns as good as what other investors in your market/asset class are generating? I know people with huge door counts who lose money every month. What good is a 'door' if it doesn't generate returns? Tell me how efficiently your deals generate returns, and then I'll be impressed.
2. Prioritizing door count makes you focus on the wrong thing. If I wanted to get 100 doors in the next few years, I bet I could -- but you can bet many of those deals would be thin. Shouldn't we be prioritizing quality over quantity? If I could choose between earning $5,000/month from 10 doors, or from 5 doors, I would pick 5 doors all day long! Good metrics push you towards good decision making, and door count does the opposite. For a lot of people getting lots of doors would be detrimental to their strategy!
3. Don't even get me started on passive investor door counts. They're absurd. I invest in multifamily syndications as well as residential properties. On the passive side of my portfolio, I am in syndications that collectively own over 2,000 units. Does that mean I own 2,000 units? Of course not, claiming so would be ridiculous (don't tell people on Instagram, though). If I own 1% of those syndications, does thatmean I own 20 units? I have no idea, nor do I care. Why on earth do I care what % of the doors I own? I care about actual measurements of returns like CoCR, AAROI, and IRR to determine if my portfolio is doing well.
There's my argument -- but I want to be proven wrong. Someone explain to me why this metric is useful.
Congratulations on 2,000 doors!
All joking aside I think door count is a fine metric. I view this metric inverse to most investors. To me its simply the numerator of an equation. If two people have the same NOI after debt service, but one has fewer doors, that model is most likely more efficient.
A few years ago I had several more "doors" than I do today, but my ROI has increased due to re-focus and efficiencies.
Post: Anyone has invested with Open door capital? How was your experience?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Quote from @Terry Hall:
I am in Fund 8. First year projection was 2-4%. I invested $50k; I received a whopping $125.very disappointed; I could have easily bought another rental or invested in a mutual fund and done so much better.
I understand your frustration. You do have to remember a few things here. The first 6 months are acquisitions, removing non paying tenants, and taking over operations/management which is just the beginning of the stabilization process. I too was spoiled by the 8% pref def along with huge exits during the run up economy and ever compressing cap rates. I am optimistic on this team that the exit will still be strong. I do feel they need to be better at communicating assurance in fiscal solvency to their LPs, but at any given moment they could theoretically pause infilling, and pay the pref distributions. The reason they are not, is because this is a value add fund, not a bond.
I am hopeful (as I also have vested interest as an LP) that your
"Very disappointed" turns into "very happy with results" by the fund exit.
Cheers!
Post: Real Estate group for high level investors to benchmark data.

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
I’m thinking it may be a great idea to start a group of several higher level investors (50 units and up) to create benchmarks, KPI’s, and outside opinions of portfolio. Basically an informal audit of ones portfolio.
This could be as simple as creating a few benchmarks (specific ratio of expenses, total PM fee ratios, vacancy rates and duration,etc)
As much as one could assume they have a well oiled portfolio, an outside investor could find areas of improvement.
Let me know if anyone would be interested, or if such a group already exist.
Cheers!
Post: Ashcroft Capital AVAF2 Fund 2 Status - Potential Capital Call?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Chris Seveney I hope you are wrong
Post: For those who invest remotely and scaled their business, how do you do it?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Diana Tran Great questions and awesome you are starting to make some moves.
I had a full time career but started purchasing homes out of state. At one time I had portfolios in 6 different states, which was too much for me.
I scaled back to my favorite 4 states to invest and started working on efficiencies.
I personally see the property manager as the “Hub” of each region. They are the only member of your team on the ground that doesn’t earn their living off of transactions. This is and should be a trusted relationship.
I’m not saying all Agents, contractors, brokers, etc are not to be trusted; but understand their relationship to your money. Your property manager is the only one that will tell you the truth, “No I won’t manage that property” and have to put their money where their month is when it comes to how much money you can collect for rent, clientele, area, etc.
This is an ongoing relationship, and a good manager can refer you to other contacts.
Ask for referrals. Be quick fire and slow to hire.
Meet them face to face. Personally a handshake still means a lot to me, and it will to them as well. Respect their time. Verbalize your own expectations. Don’t look at only their managers fee, ask what the average client pays in total fees (monthly, lease up, extensions, etc) as a percentage of rent collected. Made occasional visits so everyone knows you are present.
Beat of luck!
Post: Using Vacancy rate as monthly KPI

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Quote from @Bradley Buxton:
It's an important metric because it can kill your cash flow especially if you only have a single investment. Property managers need to be able to tell you the overall vacancy rate for all their properties and the rate for your specific properties. In my area there are some that seem like they keep track of rentals on napkins. If your PM companies are using software it should be an easy number to pull.
Yes thanks for your input. I understand the importance that why I am going to start having my PMs give me this monthly. My question is regarding how investors are obtaining their vacancy rate from their PMs. None of my PMs send a monthly vacancy rate, but some have the leases I a review in their portal. I am playing with the idea of asking them to create a monthly vacancy rate for my properties as part of THEIR job.
Cheers
Post: Using Vacancy rate as monthly KPI

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
I have several properties throughout a handful of states, all professionally managed. I usually glance as the vacancies but don't actually create KPIs for this metric. Of course all 5 managers use different software and portals, each with their own style of reports.
Im looking for ideas from other investors that are requesting Vacancy rates from their property manager. I just don't see me sifting through leases and figuring out move in/out dates as a good use of my time.
Perhaps I will just send an email to each PM requesting the current vacancy rate, and their associated units along with the rest of my monthly reports.
Thanks to anyone that wants to share their experience in this tracking.
Cheers.
Post: Royal Legal Solutions Texas

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Im still using Royal Legal Services and have been for approximately 7 years. I am happy with their asset protection plan, services and cost savings compared to a typical LLC strategy (I am in CA.)
The upfront costs are pricey to set up the DST, but they are also creating the land trusts, and adding everything to your entire estate plan. Once you are setup though it is nice as there is no franchise filing fee.
Yea you aren't getting the pleasure of walking into an office, but they are responsive and happy to help quickly through email. One of my favorite aspects is the $49 a month "Piece of Mind" package. It's like having an attorney in your back pocket for any legal questions, concerns, and advice.
Post: List of Syndicators/GPs to AVOID?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Gino Barbaro Really??
"Thank you so much for a 15-20% IRR when 3/4 of that is done by inflation, and the remainder from cap rate compression "
Also “Thank you for losing 100% of our over leveraged capital!”
That’s not how it works man. An operator HAS to be a good steward of their investors money ALL the time.
Post: What is an acceptable response time for a CPA to prepare my tax return?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Gustavo Nascimento I hired one a few years back that was active on BP. My taxes are fairly detailed and comprehensive, definitely not cheap.
When I wouldn’t get a response back, yet they were responding quickly to posts here in BP, I had to cut my ties.
Best to you