All Forum Posts by: Justin R.
Justin R. has started 74 posts and replied 618 times.
Post: Out Of State BRRRR How did you set up your team?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Brian Cerezo you gotta start with your property manager as the center of your circle. As much as I wanna say all your teams relationships are long turn, that just isn't the truth. Your property manager is truly a long term relationship. They know they will be working with you in the future and you will hold them accountable. For example; if they tell you a property will collect $XXX amount in rent & attract YYY tenant pool, it will be up to them to ensure it happens.
Find a rock start property manager, and their circle will be filled out other rock stars.
*Pro tip - If you can find a Rock star property manager that also holds a Realtors license, they will have more reason to find you the right rental property.
Post: Appraisal waivers... what I'm being told by local realtor

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
This is a competitive market, and sellers are calling the shots. In any market, a seller will prioritize an offer without contingencies as it is at a lower risk to fall out of contract. What your agent is saying, is there are so many competitive offers coming in without contingencies that you will have to do the same in order to get an offer accepted. This doesn't mean you are not allowed to have a appraisal or inspection contingency, but you must do something else to make your offer more favorable. Perhaps have a flexible closing time, offer to deal with the trash left behind, offer to not "retrade" on anything you find on the inspection contingency outside of specified items.
Markets are crazy right now. Here in the SF Bay Area the norm is no appraisal or inspection contingency (although sellers are usually supplying the inspection report.) It is a crazy market, but don't listen to the people that say to sell and not buy. Just buy smart. In a few more inflationary years we will look back and realized these prices aren't as crazy as we see on the cover.
Best of luck!
Post: Charting and Trending Expenses.

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Quote from @Nathan Gesner:
@Justin R. I'm not a big numbers guy, but I do like it when someone else does the work!
If you want, you can upload this to the FilePlace for others to find/use. Go to the bottom of any page, click "FilePlace" on the left side menu.
Well done!
Post: Charting and Trending Expenses.

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Quote from @Jon Kelly:
@Justin R. this is awesome, well done!
I think this is such an important stage to get to as an owner/investor. You allow yourself the ability to see the big picture and make decisions accordingly. This will help you make decisions on your existing properties (e.g. where to trim expenses or raise rents to offset expenses), but it will also help in using better assumptions when you analyze deals.
It's so hard to think about these things when you're just starting out because you're doing everything and get caught up with all of the small things. I have 23 properties, 57 units and 13 storage units and I'm just at the point of trying to think about the bigger picture. Thanks for the inspiration!
Other suggestions:
- Do you have any "corporate overhead" (e.g. taxes, lawyer fees, phone, marketing, etc.) that you can allocate to each property?
- I know you don't want to include Capex in the pie chart, but can you include the number somewhere? I think it would be good to at least see your Capex spend.
- Can you break out "maintenance/repair" to small categories? Maybe not on these summary charts, but somewhere where you see all maintenance/repairs if would be good to categorize to help you make decisions. For example, if 50% of your maintenance/repairs is turnover costs then maybe you should change your strategy to keep tenants in place longer. Or, if electrical is 25% of your budget then maybe find a better electrician or have an electrician go through all of your new purchases to fix/update electric on day 1.
Great points and thanks for the feedback!
I created this as a broad high level visual of fixed and variable expenses so I wasn't going to break out categories. Now that you mention it, perhaps I will add another Pie chart with that detailed breakdown.
I of course track my Capex on my P/L, but perhaps I will add another pie, or add that to one of the existing two. Or are you just thinking a simple table to express the Capex?
Most of my corporate overhead is categorized into my "general" fund and not tracked within a property itself, so I left that off the pie chart. There is a bit of marketing and corporate costs (series LLC), which are small and reflected in the "Misc" category.
Thanks for the input!
Post: Charting and Trending Expenses.

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
I wanted to share something I created, and would also like to get feedback. Like many people do, I invest in several geographical markets, but wanted a way to visualize the expense breakdown of exactly where my money goes. I wanted to then take this visual product and compare/contrast all of my real estate markets. The main 2 things I wanted categorized were......
Pie Chart 1. A breakdown of where all my money is going, including my cut (before debt service.) This is important for me to see how much money is going to me, based upon a percentage, from each region. I don't include Capex because that is something that technically increases value of the property and typically done with my approval. I don't include interest/debt payments because I want an even playing field within all regions to compare, similar to why we don't use debt service for a cap rate.
- I can also compare and contrast each region by expense category. Great to see what the property management cost ACTUALLY is after all fees.
- Great for trending and keeping an eye on uncontrolled levels of repair/maintenance
- Future analyses
- Prioritize where to start cutting expenses or negotiating
Pie Chart 2. All expenses represented as a percentage. Neat to see them broken down, but offers less relativity because if all expenses are high in that region, it really mutes visual concept.
Im not super keen on the tables with the black labeled Revenue and NOI on the left, but I needed to add this both for my own reference and as a place to insert figures from my P and L.
The Revenue/Expense ratio is also neat to look at, and makes you second guess the 50 percent rule of thumb. This location happens to be in the midwest, with 100 year old homes so it was expected to be higher than my areas of higher rents, and newer homes.
Please use or modify this template as you see fit. If you can offer any suggestions on how I can make mine better, or word a category correctly, please do. Mine is far from perfect and I am not an accounting, or tech person by any means. If anyone would like me to add this to the template section of BP let me know and Ill gladly do so.

Post: Should I buy down interest rate?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
There is a simple trick for comparing rate buy downs.
1. Figure out your annual principle and interest payments over the first year with Par (no rate buy down)
2. Figure out your annual principle and interest payments over the first year at the buy down rate
3. Whats the difference?
4. Divide the cost to buy down the points by the difference and you will find out how many years it takes to break even. If you hold the home longer than this and don't plan on another refinance than it may be worth while. I typically buy it down only if it pays for itself under 30 months time.
Post: Metrics For Buy & Hold Investments

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Zackarias Aitchison
I suggest using a analytical approach, followed by a common sense/experience approach.
Cap rate is typically for a commercial deal, but still can be utilized in residential simply as a means of comparing apples to apples, basically know if your buying a decent performer.
Cash on cash is a great metric. It is literally your "realized" ROI. This is your return on your money that you can actually spend (if needed), not factoring in your wealth multipliers (appreciation, principle payday, tax advantages.)
Buying below market or with a value add play is also important, because everyone needs an out.
Combine this analytical method with common sense and experienced eyes will limit your risk. Understand where the local market is going, economic factors, school districts, crime, local demand, employment, nuisance factors (trains, traffic, cemetery, etc). This doesn't guarantee a homer every time, but if you meet your analytical and common sense standards with each purchase your portfolio as a whole will be golden.
Post: LLC or S Corp or Umbrella insurance?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
@Josh Edelson I live in CA and have several properties and went down the research pipeline five years ago regarding asset protection. I decided on the DST structure. It's safe, easier than an LLC to maintain good standing order (which I also use for partnerships), and much cheaper in CA over the long run. Feel free to reach out with any questions on the DST. It's a newer structure (at least when used in this fashion) so not a lot of people have real experience with it.
Post: Summer Job Ideas for Young Investors

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
Construction, property management, realtors assistant, appraiser trainee, home inspection company, sales/negotiating, investors assistant, Bigger Pockets is hiring as well!
Post: Umbrella Policy or LLC for out-of-state California investor?

- Rental Property Investor
- San Anselmo
- Posts 634
- Votes 572
CA out of state investor here as well. After years of research and many talks with attorneys this is what I suggest. Don't forget everyone is in a different position so keep that in mind.
1. Do the right thing, and don't let an unsafe situation manifest.
2. Be property covered in your landlord insurance.
3. Have some sort of debt/leverage on the property.
4. Be anonymous and get a property manager.
5. If you have the personal assets then get a good umbrella policy.
6. If you have a decent amount of wealth that you want to protect, get an LLC or DST. Don't think an LLC (Especially a single member LLC) keeps you safe. The biggest benefit is anonymity, and its an extra hurdle for an attorney to pierce. If you live in CA, a DST can be a better option. Not cheap to set up, but much cheaper than several LLCS over the course of a few years.