Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew McNeil

Matthew McNeil has started 31 posts and replied 686 times.

Post: Lender REFUSES mortgage payments from LLC business account

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 742
Originally posted by @Nick Belsky:

Yeah, weird.  But banks update policies all the time.  The questions are; do you love this lender so much that you are willing to file a complaint, go to court (potentially), have your credit hit, etc... or is it better just to refi out into another lender?  I've refi'd out several times due to policy changes but I've also adapted...  Got to weigh your options and determine how valuable your time and effort is to you.

Nick Belsky

Thanks Nick. Interesting. I may end up doing a refi to get out of this dilemma. 

Post: Lender REFUSES mortgage payments from LLC business account

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 742

My lender is warning its clients that it will no longer accept payments from a business bank account, which is how I’ve been paying the loan since its inception many years ago. They insist I must pay using a personal account starting next month.

If we don't accommodate the demand, they're warning its clients the consequences will be as follows;
1) Reject all payments 2) Add a late fee 3) Report non-payment to the credit reporting agencies

To require this of me would force me to be in violation of the legal requirements regarding LLC’s mixing of funds between personal and the LLC business accounts. Thus, they are exposing me to liability.

I feel the lender may be in violation of the law for the above-mentioned reason. Furthermore, my loan was conventional and sourced from Fannie Mae which recognizes the legitimacy of a Quitclaim between the mortgage holders (me and my wife) and the LLC; so long as the LLC is controlled by me and my wife . In other words, Fannie Mae views the legitimacy of the LLC as a legal entity and I don't feel Fannie Mae would agree with this demand of the lender.

It seems to me that I can challenge the lender advising that I’m not obligated to honor their demand, and to force me to do so would empower me to file a formal complaint with the state Attorney Generals Office.

Any thoughts or advice?

Post: $250K to $300k-where would you buy?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 742
Originally posted by @Brandon Sturgill:

@Chilly Nathan I'm a little late to the conversation, but it's hard to go wrong in Columbus, Oh...on a grand scale, everything in this city is sitting at 50% of future value...15 years pass and our $250k duplexes are $500-600k duplexes...just for holding them...it happened in Austin...Denver...around D.C...Columbus will bypass Chicago as the most populous city in the Midwest in 30-years...there is exponential room for growth right now.

That said, I firmly believe you can make money in markets like Orlando and Raleigh-Durham...not really a fan of Atlanta or any city inside of Alabama, but Kansas City has opportunity, along with Boise if you can still get in...it's the next Bend Oregon...I think the best idea is to have a personal connection to the market you end up in...a place you know people or would like to visit...or even live some day.

Always happy to chat more about the local market.

Best of luck

Boise is indeed tough to get into now. Glad I started investing there 12 years ago. However, Boise is not the next Bend. My parents live in Bend. No comparison. 

Post: How are you buy and hold investors resisting the urge to sell?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 742
Originally posted by @Dave Foster:

@Matthew McNeil and @Jay Hinrichs, If you do a full 1031 (purchase at least as much as you sell and use all of the cash in your purchases) you indefinitely defer all gain and depreciation recapture.  The way to think about a 1031 is that your basis transfers over from the old property to the new property so whatever is above your basis in profit or depreciation after a sale is deferred.  And this creates the opportunities I'm seeing most right now with our investors

1. Selling from high expense and cap ex to newer construction with lower cap ex potential.

2. Selling a highly depreciated asset and buying much larger assets to gain depreciable basis.

3.  Doing either 1 or 2 in order to drop the interest rate on financing.

I think these are opportunities that a lot of folks over look.  They get fixated on the cap rate return on an asset so don't think there's good deals out there.  But a 1031 straight across that costs you 10% less in expenses, adds 10% in depreciation write off, and drops 10% off on financing can really sweeten a deal.  It's finding the little things to sweeten a deal that make it work in a competitive market.

Excellent feedback and advice. I've added another insight tool to my bag. Thanks Dave!

Post: How are you buy and hold investors resisting the urge to sell?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 742
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
Originally posted by @Matthew McNeil:
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
Originally posted by @Michael Temple:

Every property I own has appreciated in the last year, but resisting selling is beyond easy for several reasons...

  1. Taxes: Between capital gains taxes and recaptured depreciation I would lose a lot of the gain in taxes.


  2. Impossible Replacement: After paying my taxes I would be unable to replace those houses in this insane market at prices that make financial sense.


  3. Loss of Current and Future Income: Every house I have is producing great cash flow and will continue to do so as long as I hold them. Selling them right now is like killing the golden goose.

The very last thing I want right now with interest rates near zero is a giant pile of Federal Reserve notes that would be nearly impossible to put back to work in real estate and I certainly can't earn a return on interest-bearing instruments, i.e. CD, bonds, savings accounts, etc. and the stock market seems way overvalued and trading sideways at the moment so I don't see much opportunity there for the medium term.

My net worth goes up every month with appreciation and I have cash flow coming in. My biggest regret is that my rental portfolio wasn't 1000X larger during this massive run-up in prices. Finding properties that make financial sense might be hard for a while. I keep asking myself even if I wanted to sell, what the heck would I do with a giant pile of money that begins losing value to inflation before I walk out of the closing. Nope, I am totally staying put.

    Your the first to mention recapture that is the real issue at the end of the day selling now for lower cap gain tax can see that but the recapture for those with long term holdings can be the real killer .. which forces you to stay on the rental real estate Hamster wheel.

    But maybe some folks could 1031 into a building and the ON Going business if they want to create cash flow and try something a little different.

     

    I may be wrong, but I believe the depreciation recapture "follows" a 1031 Exchange. 

    I believe the reason you do the exchange is so you DONT have to recapture and pay that back.  If you sell outright 

    I am thinking its long term Cap gain and you pay recapture. 

    Let's ping @Dave Foster for his advice.

    Post: How are you buy and hold investors resisting the urge to sell?

    Matthew McNeilPosted
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Boise/Portland
    • Posts 709
    • Votes 742
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Michael Temple:

    Every property I own has appreciated in the last year, but resisting selling is beyond easy for several reasons...

    1. Taxes: Between capital gains taxes and recaptured depreciation I would lose a lot of the gain in taxes.


    2. Impossible Replacement: After paying my taxes I would be unable to replace those houses in this insane market at prices that make financial sense.


    3. Loss of Current and Future Income: Every house I have is producing great cash flow and will continue to do so as long as I hold them. Selling them right now is like killing the golden goose.

    The very last thing I want right now with interest rates near zero is a giant pile of Federal Reserve notes that would be nearly impossible to put back to work in real estate and I certainly can't earn a return on interest-bearing instruments, i.e. CD, bonds, savings accounts, etc. and the stock market seems way overvalued and trading sideways at the moment so I don't see much opportunity there for the medium term.

    My net worth goes up every month with appreciation and I have cash flow coming in. My biggest regret is that my rental portfolio wasn't 1000X larger during this massive run-up in prices. Finding properties that make financial sense might be hard for a while. I keep asking myself even if I wanted to sell, what the heck would I do with a giant pile of money that begins losing value to inflation before I walk out of the closing. Nope, I am totally staying put.

      Your the first to mention recapture that is the real issue at the end of the day selling now for lower cap gain tax can see that but the recapture for those with long term holdings can be the real killer .. which forces you to stay on the rental real estate Hamster wheel.

      But maybe some folks could 1031 into a building and the ON Going business if they want to create cash flow and try something a little different.

       

      I may be wrong, but I believe the depreciation recapture "follows" a 1031 Exchange. 

      Post: Fastest appreciating markets

      Matthew McNeilPosted
      • Rental Property Investor
      • Boise/Portland
      • Posts 709
      • Votes 742
      Originally posted by @Aaron Williams:

      @Matthew McNeil

      That’s definitely true. A recent listing of mine went $90k over asking and had over 20 offers and none of them were all cash. One of the biggest advantages to financed buyers is the willingness and ability to pay a large appraisal gap in the event the appraisal comes in low. Low appraisals are not uncommon right now as appraisers are limited to only using sold comps which, in a fast paced market, is lagging data.

      I'm tempted to list one of my houses for $100k more than what I think its worth just to see what would happen ;)

      Post: Fastest appreciating markets

      Matthew McNeilPosted
      • Rental Property Investor
      • Boise/Portland
      • Posts 709
      • Votes 742
      Originally posted by @Jonathan Dempsey:

      Boise seems to keep popping up everywhere I read.   Curious what others thoughts are and what I may be missing?!

      I've been investing in Boise/Meridian SFH's for a decade. Currently enjoying phenomenal appreciation. My RE agent says most buyers are out of state people paying up to $80k over asking price. Thankfully, rent prices are starting to increase which is good for RE investors. I just raised the rent on one house by $350/month, which would have been impossible a year ago.

      Post: Need a logo for our business

      Matthew McNeilPosted
      • Rental Property Investor
      • Boise/Portland
      • Posts 709
      • Votes 742

      Fiverr is an option; https://www.fiverr.com/

      Post: Pacific NW Retirement real estate purchase

      Matthew McNeilPosted
      • Rental Property Investor
      • Boise/Portland
      • Posts 709
      • Votes 742
      Originally posted by @Shannon Robnett:

      @Matthew McNeil Boise is off the charts right now for growth for sure!

      I started investing there 12 years ago. Best decision I ever made. 

      1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9